Social Profile: ![]()
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
At Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Carle Place, voted the #1 Best Pizza Chain, we combine Italian tradition with seasonal flavors. Enjoy the sweet-spicy kick of our Mike’s Hot Honey® & Burrata pizza or the hearty Broccoli Rabe & Sausage pie, plus pasta like burrata & prosciutto spaghetti. Every dish is made with hand-picked Italian tomatoes, freshly grated pecorino Romano cheese, and baked in our 900° coal fire ovens. Add fresh jumbo chicken wings or an Italian Sausage & Peppers sandwich for the full experience. Near Roosevelt Field Mall and Eisenhower Park, we offer dine-in, takeout, and delivery.
Casual chain serving charred-crust pies, plus wings, subs & Italian plates in a modern setting.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 137 Old Country Rd, Carle Place, NY 11514
Phone: (516) 877-7750
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: acfp.com
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Italian Pizza, Pasta & Salads in Carle Place | Anthony’s
Coal‑Fired Pizza & Italian Eats Near Roosevelt Field, Carle Place … Right across from Roosevelt Field Mall, Anthony’s fires every pizza in a 900‑degree coal …
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings | Where Fire Meets Flavor
Experience the flavor of Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings. Enjoy handcrafted & authentic pizza, wings, & Italian cuisine. Order takeout, delivery or …
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza – Carle Place – OpenTable
Get menu, photos and location information for Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza – Carle Place in Carle Place, NY. Or book now at one of our other 7820 great …
Last Updates
Reviews
Yuri Choi
We visited Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza for the first time on Saturday around 8 PM for a quick bite, and the experience was genuinely upsetting.
We were not greeted when we walked in and had to seat ourselves. After sitting down, we waited about five minutes with no water and no menus until I asked for them. Only then did someone acknowledge us. Basic hospitality should not require prompting.
We ordered the artichoke dip and the baked ziti, which was recommended by our waitress. The baked ziti was frankly unacceptable. It tasted like microwaved cafeteria food, unevenly heated, lacking freshness, and made with very poor-quality vegetables. There was no depth of flavor, no sense that it was freshly prepared. I had to send it back.
We used to think Olive Garden set the bar low for Italian food. Unfortunately, this experience was worse. For a restaurant that promotes itself around “coal fired pizza,” this level of food and service is extremely disappointing. There’s a serious disconnect between the brand and the reality.
I hope management takes this feedback seriously, because this is not the standard any restaurant should be operating at.
… moreWe were not greeted when we walked in and had to seat ourselves. After sitting down, we waited about five minutes with no water and no menus until I asked for them. Only then did someone acknowledge us. Basic hospitality should not require prompting.
We ordered the artichoke dip and the baked ziti, which was recommended by our waitress. The baked ziti was frankly unacceptable. It tasted like microwaved cafeteria food, unevenly heated, lacking freshness, and made with very poor-quality vegetables. There was no depth of flavor, no sense that it was freshly prepared. I had to send it back.
We used to think Olive Garden set the bar low for Italian food. Unfortunately, this experience was worse. For a restaurant that promotes itself around “coal fired pizza,” this level of food and service is extremely disappointing. There’s a serious disconnect between the brand and the reality.
I hope management takes this feedback seriously, because this is not the standard any restaurant should be operating at.
Dennis Fazzio
My wife and use to love going here for salad and wings but over the last three times the wing and bread are over cooked (burned) and dried out even when asked not to over cook them. Anyway, clean restaurant with good service in a good neighborhood with plenty of free parking.
… moreNeenzb0
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
We hosted a retirement party here for my colleague Jason, and I honestly cannot say enough good things about this experience.
In the week leading up to the event, I was extremely busy, and my mother coordinated directly with the manager — to the point where he even gave her his personal cellphone number so she could text with any questions. That level of accessibility and care alone spoke volumes.
On the day of the party, the staff had multiple tables set up perfectly to accommodate our group of over 30 people. Our waitress was an absolute rockstar — she handled separate drink tabs effortlessly, kept everything moving smoothly, and made sure no one was ever waiting too long. The food was delicious, and she stayed in constant communication with me throughout the event, checking in to see if we needed more food or anything else.
The manager was also present the entire time and made a point to personally check in with us, letting us know he was there for anything we needed. That hands-on approach made such a difference and truly elevated the entire experience.
Even after the party officially wrapped up, we stayed at the bar until closing, which says a lot about how comfortable and welcome we felt.
I would 100% recommend this location and this specific staff. They truly went above and beyond and helped make this retirement celebration an unforgettable experience.
… moreWe hosted a retirement party here for my colleague Jason, and I honestly cannot say enough good things about this experience.
In the week leading up to the event, I was extremely busy, and my mother coordinated directly with the manager — to the point where he even gave her his personal cellphone number so she could text with any questions. That level of accessibility and care alone spoke volumes.
On the day of the party, the staff had multiple tables set up perfectly to accommodate our group of over 30 people. Our waitress was an absolute rockstar — she handled separate drink tabs effortlessly, kept everything moving smoothly, and made sure no one was ever waiting too long. The food was delicious, and she stayed in constant communication with me throughout the event, checking in to see if we needed more food or anything else.
The manager was also present the entire time and made a point to personally check in with us, letting us know he was there for anything we needed. That hands-on approach made such a difference and truly elevated the entire experience.
Even after the party officially wrapped up, we stayed at the bar until closing, which says a lot about how comfortable and welcome we felt.
I would 100% recommend this location and this specific staff. They truly went above and beyond and helped make this retirement celebration an unforgettable experience.
srt8 Venum
Had an excellent lunch here (Carle Place Long Island location) the roasted wings were meaty and seasoned nicely, I expected it to be spicy but was not, which was ok with me. Now for the pizza, we had half meatball half sausage pie. The sauce was really good, cheese was excellent in taste and consistency and of course with brick oven pizza a nice crust. Special shout out to our waitress Abby, she made us feel welcomed, she was attentive and very kind and personable she made our experience that much better. We will be back soon.
… morePurse Queen61
I’ve been before– and continually return for the cauliflower pizza. However, the abundance of cayenne pepper (?) nearly took me out! But… it was good. Thank goodness the chicken wings are still top notch!
… moreTom S
Hands down the best wings ever!
I know this is a pizza joint but I usually come here just for the wings.
Got an order of 10 original wings tonight and a meatball & ricotta pizza. The wings were ready in under 5 mins. They are perfectly charred, fall off the bone, and great taste with the onions on top.
The pizza was great too. Crispy thin crust
With sweet tomato sauce, clumps of ricotta, and tender meatballs.
The wait staff were all very attentive and professional. Greeted at the door, sat immediately, and my waitress was there to take a drink order right away.
Nothing like Anthony’s coal fired.
… moreI know this is a pizza joint but I usually come here just for the wings.
Got an order of 10 original wings tonight and a meatball & ricotta pizza. The wings were ready in under 5 mins. They are perfectly charred, fall off the bone, and great taste with the onions on top.
The pizza was great too. Crispy thin crust
With sweet tomato sauce, clumps of ricotta, and tender meatballs.
The wait staff were all very attentive and professional. Greeted at the door, sat immediately, and my waitress was there to take a drink order right away.
Nothing like Anthony’s coal fired.
Lee Birnbaum
I’ve tried other Anthony’s which j thought was better.
this location appears to have super thick bready crust.
this pie was requested with extra thin crust, and extra cheese.
i could only imagine how think the crust would have been if I hadn’t requested “thin”.
the meatballs were a bit firm, unlike other locations i had tried where they’re pretty soft and tender, not sure why.
i would give other Anthony’s locations I’ve tried (in NJ) over 4 stars, maybe even 5. but this location disappointed, more like 2.5 stars. at least the ingredients are still high quality even if they don’t cook it well.
… morethis location appears to have super thick bready crust.
this pie was requested with extra thin crust, and extra cheese.
i could only imagine how think the crust would have been if I hadn’t requested “thin”.
the meatballs were a bit firm, unlike other locations i had tried where they’re pretty soft and tender, not sure why.
i would give other Anthony’s locations I’ve tried (in NJ) over 4 stars, maybe even 5. but this location disappointed, more like 2.5 stars. at least the ingredients are still high quality even if they don’t cook it well.
Angela H
This is our first time to Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza. We were greeted by a pleasant staff member and seated promptly. They had a nice menu selection and good beers on tap. The pizza came out quickly and was piping hot! The Paulie’s pizza with the hot peppers was amazing. We definitely will be coming back to try the rest of the menu.
… moreMark Silver
It’s exceptional for what it is. Note that if you don’t like your pizza well done (as in slightly to moderately blackened on the bottom and sides), this place will probably be a turnoff for you. Otherwise they use quality ingredients and it’s very tasty.
… moreJames Oh
The broccoli rabe was o…k…
Now the pizza: who said shrimp scampi works on pizza?? I have a deep love for pizza and most toppings but this one didn’t really work for us. I felt like I should be eating pasta and the shrimp separately.
The pepperoni pizza was very good.
… moreNow the pizza: who said shrimp scampi works on pizza?? I have a deep love for pizza and most toppings but this one didn’t really work for us. I felt like I should be eating pasta and the shrimp separately.
The pepperoni pizza was very good.