Roarke Landin
Best New York Style pizza I have had in years!! The staff is friendly and quick to help customers. They are available online and even have a tablet at the cashier if you don’t know what you want. I ordered online and checkout was easy. The place was very busy for a random Wensday. The prices are reasonable and the location is pretty good. I had no issues with parking. If you are solo or duo then you might be able to sit here and enjoy some food but, I wouldn’t recommend this as a sit in restaurant.
… moreJennifer Del Castillo
The feel of the local hole in the wall. True NY style pizza. Very affordable.
… moreCraig Moir
The Pizza at Anthony’s is excellent.I have ordered from here twice so far and both times it was outstanding. The dough is fresh soft and chewy. The Pizza is N.Y. Style pizza, big floppy delicious slices. The owner Bill, he really knows his New York Pizza because he’s actually a New Yorker himself. He’s a great guy and has a great crew working with him. The kitchen crew is awesome at making those pizzas. I have not tried the pasta yet. I had a salad with my last order and the Italian dressing was just like the Pizza restaurants in Long Island N.Y. excellent dressing.
… moreMichael –
This place is the best around for pizza. My girlfriend and I loved stopping here for a slice on Sundays before we moved away. I’d get pepperoni and she’d get mushrooms and olives. She always praised how fresh their vegetables were and how much they loaded onto the slices. I want to see them succeed even more and open a location in Loveland.
… moreCraig Skillman
I’ve been a fixture here for 26 years but was born and raised in Central Jersey. I was home at Christmas and had a few pies from 2 pizza parlors in Trenton. Including a tomato pie, a Trenton favorite. I can honestly say I prefer the pizza that Bill makes at the Anthony’s on Iliff Ave. I’ve also had fantastic calzones. So I say to whom ever instructs the chefs here does a terrific job. The taste and quality never waivers.
… moreTamy Herrera
Still Amazing food, and friendly service!
But No more Calzones! We ordered Calzones many times throughout the years from here, and have absolutely loved them!!
We tried to order a couple the other day, and found they were no longer on the menu. My son and I almost cried, Calzones were our family’s personal specialty food that we each could really enjoy.
1 month ago:
AMAZING!! They never disappoint!
I’ve eaten at the restaurant, and had take-out and delivery service. They have top-notch, friendly customer service. And, all the different food we have had on the menu is always so tasty. Even when delivery times are long, the food is always hot, and worth the wait.
My personal and family favorite, and a default go to for delivery of great food. Today’s delivery was no exception. ❤️. So good, the fam wouldn’t even wait for me to take a pic of the pizzas, lol.
Thank you for your quality of service.
… moreVivian
First visit…reminds of Pizza places in New England. Super yummy pizza and salad (include more dressing). Very good customer service. Definitely will be back. Might be time to find or open a bigger place…dine in would be a nice option. The 2 small tables are just too squeezed in.
… moreRachael Painter
We used to love Anthony’s and were excited to bring our family there for dinner. We get there to realize the indoor dining has been shut down completely, so we just decide to order it to go. We sent our family back to our house to wait. We ordered a large pizza and cheese sticks. The food took 40 minutes and normally we would have been fine with that just because we love their pizza. We get home and the cheese sticks were broken, soggy and smooshed (the $11 cheese sticks mind you) you could get better cheese sticks at any fast food establishment. Our pizza was covered in grease and had no flavor. It was definitely a major let down and I feel like we all used the phrase “They used to be so good! I don’t know what happened” through the entire meal. Everyone ended up eating about half their slice before we just gave up and made sandwiches. A big waste of $45 that’s for sure.
… moreDebra Johnson
Great crust. It bends in just the right places. We had a half and half pizza. Half cheese and half pepperoni, olive, and ricotta cheese. Most places here in Denver don’t offer ricotta. Service was amazing.
… moreDavid Barge
Excellent tasting NY style 18 inch pizza. Staff is helpful, but they need to smile when engaging with customers.
… more