Tina H
It was a Saturday evening and we didn’t have a reservation so we waited a bit and got to sit outside. We shared a few appetizers and an entree. Food was delicious . Cocktails were ok. Staff was great! I would say they were too attentive. Immediately when a plate was empty, they were there removing it. Made us feel a bit rushed. I will b returning.
… moreTiziana Pratico’ Brugellis
Went for a quick lunch,
The decornis nice, food is clean and staff is kind of welcoming. Why 4 stars? It didn’t impress me enough to give it the 5th one.
… moreMichael Watson
Had a great meal here tonight. The best meat balls I’ve ever had. I ordered the roast chicken and it was delicious. Well decorated and the service was excellent. I’ll definitely come again.
… moreCrystal Martinez
They added a Lava Cake to their dessert menu… I’m in HEAVEN!!!!! I don’t even need the lasagna bolognese I always ask about (IYKYK) … nope KEEP THE LAVA CAKE ON THE MENU!!!!! I’ll order it every time I come in! (Which is like 2-3x a month.
… moreKevin Perna
We hosted a bridal shower at Il Gufo yesterday. The food was amazing and our guests are still talking about how wonderful it was. The staff was so very accommodating and went out of their way to ensure our every need was met. The private room is absolutely beautiful and was exactly what we wanted to celebrate this special occasion. Exceptional experience at Il Gufo!!
… moreGeorge Dallas
Bartender, young kid, with the wavy blonde hair, who’s tall… IS ABSOLUTELY EXCEPTIONAL! THAT GUY DID NOT STOP WORKING. HE WAS FOCUSED AND SERVICE EVERY REQUEST AT THE BAR! WHAT A GREAT ASSET TO HAVE!
… moreMatthew Maggipinto
Il Gufo of Garden City is absolutely outstanding! From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with warm, professional service and a beautiful atmosphere. The staff is knowledgeable and attentive without ever being overbearing. Every dish is prepared with incredible attention to detail — fresh ingredients, authentic flavors, and gorgeous presentation. You can tell there’s real passion behind everything they do. Whether it’s a casual dinner or a special occasion, Il Gufo delivers a truly exceptional dining experience every time. Highly recommend!
… morePatty Tucci
Il Gufo is my new favorite GC restaurant, their menu is a breath of fresh air. Unlike many Italian restaurants that are stuck in an Italian food time warp their menu is an update of delicious Italian delicacies. Their choices are like eating in a restaurant in Italy. There is nothing I don’t like that I have ordered at Il Gufo. Service is wonderful I never feel rushed and love how they remove dirty dishes quickly. FYI great place for desserts and a cup of espresso.
… moreChris G
ll Gufo is a Italian restaurant with a large opening during the warmer weather in Garden City. It has a nice selection of drinks, with friendly bartenders, and nice selection of dishes. I had the arancini, which was fair, but the tagelini Ragu was good. I would try it out.
… moreE C
Went with friends when the restaurant had just opened (like first week) Limited menu, and a bit busy. The place was buzzing with energy! Food was delicious, especially the pizzas. We had to wait for a table and the bar was very crowded, but it was worth it. Since then, have been back 2 times. Must try the whipped ricotta!
… more