Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5879 Sullivan Trail, Nazareth, PA 18064
Phone: (610) 759-0143
Website: http://www.peteyseateys.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Petey’s Eatey’s | Nazareth PA – Facebook
NOTICE OF CLOSURE To Our Valued Customers, Due to unforeseen circumstances, we regret to inform you that Petey’s Eateys is now permanently closed as of 7pm on …
Hot eats, cool treats returning to former Petey’s Eatey’s spot
PLAINFIELD TWP., Pa. – A one-time hot spot for burgers, hot dogs, cheesesteaks and ice cream is finding new life in Northampton County.
‘Deeply disappointed’: Lehigh Valley eatery bids farewell, making …
Petey’s Eatey’s is pictured at 5879 Sullivan Trail in Plainfield Township. … PLAINFIELD TWP., Pa. – A popular spot for burgers, cheesesteaks, …
Reviews
Chuck DidntSuck
Stopped by Petey’s Eatey’s twice after having menu items recommended to me on my video’s. First time was to try the cheesesteak and then I came again to try a mammoth breakfast sandwich (the belly buster). Both of these trips were a little while back and I’m honestly due to stop in again and try something else out. I stopped in for the cheesesteak December of 2021 and I went back for the breakfast sandwich December of 2022.
The cheesesteak had the cheese mixed throughout and it was on a pretty solid roll. There was less meat than I had hoped (trails off towards the end of the roll on both sides) and it honestly could have used more cheese too, but it was definitely something that would scratch an itch. At the time the price was excellent (like $8.50 or something in that range) but I am not sure if it’s still around that price or not. This isn’t something I would go out of my way to get again, but it wasn’t something I was upset about at all.
The breakfast sandwich was a beast. Pork roll (or whatever you call it), bacon, eggs, cheese, hash brown on a Kaiser. The flavor was good all separate and once I was able to actually get my mouth around it and get everything in one bite, it was solid. It isn’t something I would suggest eating often, and I’m sure your cardiologist would agree. Either way, pretty tasty stuff. Going to have to check back in soon for sure, but for an economy steak I was happy and for a once a year breakfast or so, it did the trick.
… moreThe cheesesteak had the cheese mixed throughout and it was on a pretty solid roll. There was less meat than I had hoped (trails off towards the end of the roll on both sides) and it honestly could have used more cheese too, but it was definitely something that would scratch an itch. At the time the price was excellent (like $8.50 or something in that range) but I am not sure if it’s still around that price or not. This isn’t something I would go out of my way to get again, but it wasn’t something I was upset about at all.
The breakfast sandwich was a beast. Pork roll (or whatever you call it), bacon, eggs, cheese, hash brown on a Kaiser. The flavor was good all separate and once I was able to actually get my mouth around it and get everything in one bite, it was solid. It isn’t something I would suggest eating often, and I’m sure your cardiologist would agree. Either way, pretty tasty stuff. Going to have to check back in soon for sure, but for an economy steak I was happy and for a once a year breakfast or so, it did the trick.
Daisy Loane
Always have gotten good food! Their burgers are huge and super good. I also really like their milkshakes and ice cream. They have a small partially inclosed eating area that’s nice. The staff has always been helpful and friendly. The prices are fair too.
… moreAndrue Sullivan
I ordered a cheese steak with just sauce, and it was absolutely delicious! It was $9, at 10 inches, and I only waited 10 minutes. The young lady behind the counter was very professional and polite, and was quick to take my order and notify me when done. The cheese and sauce were thoroughly mixed in with the meat and filled the roll. I will definitely be back to try out their other sandwiches, especially the breakfast menu.
… moreEisernen Fuchs
An absolute gem of a hole-in-the-wall experience.
Great food, rather quick service, and its a little spot to relax on your travels.
I drive from about 2 hours away to come down now and then for a bite, why not? It’s great value and a very nostalgic spot!
… moreGreat food, rather quick service, and its a little spot to relax on your travels.
I drive from about 2 hours away to come down now and then for a bite, why not? It’s great value and a very nostalgic spot!
Melanie Di
Cute little mom-pop shop. Great milk shakes and amazing wings! Never had a bad wing yet!
The kids that work here are exceptional!
Check it out. You won’t be disappointed!!
… moreThe kids that work here are exceptional!
Check it out. You won’t be disappointed!!
SemiCharmed
Just ordered fries among other items. My child found a STAPLE in his food. I can’t imagine what would’ve happened if he swallowed that and how long it would have taken to figure out something was wrong. I will gladly not order from again.
Edit: The staple was lodged into the fry. So it didn’t just happen to fall onto it.
… moreEdit: The staple was lodged into the fry. So it didn’t just happen to fall onto it.
Jay
Been working in the area lately and discovered this place. They have a great menu for such a small place! The food was good and all the staff on each of my last several visits have been super friendly and helpful. They only offer outdoor seating which is a nice touch for this time of year. The parking can be a bit tight, but the gas pumps from what I have seen have not been super busy.
… moreLinda Sokel
Had a great light lunch, tuna salad, and the blueberry milkshake was delicious on a hot day. Menu had a nice variety, staff was very friendly and prices were very reasonable. Enjoyed eating at the outside tables. For a small place, the customers just kept coming and everyone said how good all their food was. Next time I’m in the area, I will stop here to eat again.
… moreChristian Feliciano
Don’t go in the morning, the taller blond lady who works the register in the gas station during the week is incredibly rude and unprofessional. I stopped brining my daughter and son in to get breakfast sandwiches because the last time I took them into grab one from the warmer a month ago she made a comment that I need to call ahead, I wasn’t aware grabbing two was a crime. This isn’t a normal routine for us. She stopped in maybe once a month. Each time she just continues to be rude as if you’re bothering her or inconveniencing her. And then she continued to talk to another customer dropping the F bomb more than a few in front of my 4 and 5 year old as well as plenty of other inappropriate words . It felt more like a bar room at 1 am and not your neighborhood friendly gas station which I thought this was.
I decided to give them another try a few days ago. I went to get food, but in the afternoon and the teenagers working the counter spent 5 minutes talking and ignoring me instead of taking my order at the outside window.
Food isn’t bad, customer service sucks . I don’t expect 5 start service , but at least watch your language in front of kids and acknowledge your customers .
… moreI decided to give them another try a few days ago. I went to get food, but in the afternoon and the teenagers working the counter spent 5 minutes talking and ignoring me instead of taking my order at the outside window.
Food isn’t bad, customer service sucks . I don’t expect 5 start service , but at least watch your language in front of kids and acknowledge your customers .
Tim Jones
I ordered a Ruben on 6-11-22 around 5:00 pm. The worker told me it would be about 15 minutes. Well, it went well beyond that! The staff was apologetic the whole time for the wait. They even offered me a free soda or ice cream. I just wanted my sandwich. Finally after 28 minutes I received my Ruben. I was very hungry so I just decided to eat it in the car. What an Amazing sandwich! If they would of told me I have to wait for an hour now for one, I would have no issues with it! The staff the environment and the food was a triple combo for an amazing experience. My taste buds are STILL dancing from my food. Thanks to everyone that made it possible to eat such a great sandwich!!! I will see you soon and often! Please enjoy your day!
… more