Charles Noe
“D’Agostino’s is a legacy revenue node specializing in authentic Chicago-style thin crust. Their Wheeling infrastructure has been a cornerstone for years, providing consistent throughput for dine-in and high-velocity delivery. The ‘Dags Special’ remains a gold standard for local pizza assets. A family-friendly environment with a professional pub atmosphere. Essential neighbor-proof signal for the Milwaukee Avenue corridor.”
… moreAdam Hoover
Really good spot for pizza. Smells amazing once you walk through the door. Deep dish was perfect. Wait times for deep dish were not bad. All staff were friendly and helpful. Prices are not over the top and definitely worth checking out. Next time I’m back in the area I’ll return.
… moreMarc Arturi
D’Agostino’s Tuesday nights are so much fun! They have a live trivia game, a great bar that feels like you’re up North at a cozy cabin! Good service and friendly knowledgeable bar and wait staff. Clean facility and restroom. I highly recommend D’Agostino’s in Wheeling!
… moreA. P.
Debbi was amazing, helping me set up a surprise party for my wife. The service was fantastic; fast, friendly and efficient. Food was amazing and quantify. The private party room was quaint and perfect. Our new go to for events.
… moreJeremy Dubin
This is a great classic Chicago pizza restaurant along with a significant amount of other delicious Italian food foods. The Caesar salad was very simple yet delicious. The pizza is always amazing in their Bosco sticks aren’t the best around. Apparently that with a cold beer and it’s a match made in heaven.
… moreKim Siebert
We had order the bbq ribs and chicken and I think you should try a different bbq sauce because it’s way too sweet and too much of it. Also the chicken should be whole pieces and not skinless pounded chicken but I would come again to try something different!
… moreGrant Fifield
Nice pizzeria known for thin crust pizza. Prices are a little high though. For a 10 inch thin crust pizza with one extra topping and a fountain lemonade + tax it cost $16+. I wish this place had a buffet that could lower the prices a bit. Pizza was good, but may be a while before I come back unless I have a bigger pay-day. Bathroom was clean and had a changing table for dad’s with kids and the parking lot looked newly paved.
… moreTyrone Williams
Pizza has potential however there were issues with the kitchen staff (proper pizza oven temps / new cooks). Based upon that I can’t give a proper review of the pizza. I don’t want to slam a business that’s trying. I remember coming years ago and being very satisfied!
On a side note the server was amazing and provided the excellent service. I will be back in the future to give an updated review.
… moreJennifer Rivera
Great spot. We sat at the bar and the bartender was friendly and on top of when we needed another round. Ordered the bruschetta and a thin crust pizza, both very good. The sauce is on the sweeter side so if that’s not your preference (it’s not really mine either) then order something else from the menu. Food came out fast and they do not skimp on the toppings, which is awesome. The best thing though, my bf left his phone behind (and our leftover pizza). He went back today and not only did they have his phone set aside, they even saved our pizza for us! It’s the little things that set a place apart and we will definitely be back!
… moreAudrey Stegg
The stuffed ravioli and the meat lovers deep dish pizza was bomb. Also, the mini casino by the bar was a nice fun surprise!
… more