Kinsey's Italian Cafe - McCordsville, IN 46055 - Menu, Reviews, Hours & Contact

Kinsey’s Italian Cafe is open daily from 11-8 Monday- Saturday. Our buffet is available Monday-Friday 11-2. It is $12.95 and includes pizza, salad, wings, okra, …

Kinsey’s Italian Cafe in McCordsville – Indy Pizza Blog

A certified hidden gem in McCordsville, Kinsey’s Italian Cafe has spongy soft pizza crust and an amazing calzone called the Panzerotti.

Reviews

Ilana P

First time dining here. Food and service was very good. My chicken cheesesteak sandwich was amazing. The fries was tasty also. You get a lot of food for your money. Our server Hailey was very attentive and quick. We will be back.

… more

A.J. Donato

This place is usually good and I love the food. We however had a very very bad interaction here Wednesday night. We had an event to go to Wednesday evening, and thought an hour and 30 minutes would be enough time to eat here. We were sat immediately upon arrival. However, our waitress was running rampant like there wasn’t enough help that night folks that got there after us all got their food before us, and we were still waiting for our food after an hour of being sat. The service staff kept telling us it’ll be ready in a couple minutes, but I honestly think that they either forgot our order or something went wrong with it. We eventually just had to get it in a to go box and we were still 30 minutes late to our event after we told the service staff that we needed it to go. It was still about 20 minutes before we got our food in a box.

… more

Stacy G

Delicious food. Great staff! Good atmosphere! The bruschetta is the best I have ever tasted. The salad and beef ravioli were delicious! The house merlot very good. Great place to eat!!!!

… more

Mark Rumney

We had a really nice meal this evening. First time visiting but we wanted to visit as Kinsey’s close to home.

Service was attentive and our server stayed right with us even as restaurant filled up after seating us. Salad presentation nice but will say the Calamari was tasty yet a bit overcooked.

We ordered the Veal Parmigiana and the Kinsey Meat Trio entrees. Sauce had a nice flavor. Meatball was tasty as well as the lasagna. The veal a patty but still well presented.

There will be plenty to take home as portions nice sized. We were glad to stop in to Kinsey’s for dinner and look forward to another visit.

… more

Isaac Garcia

I walk in and its seems like a lovely resturant the employees are great and good customer service and also i love the atmosphere. but the food need some work! sorry but the only thing that was good in the buffet was the pizza and salad, every tray was empty. The chicking wings looks kinda moldy but i really dont know if it was though, and i really hope not! I didnt really try it cause it didnt look as good. But if this reesturant improve on the buffet ill give it a 5 star forsure !!

… more

Linda Hanks

This was our first time visiting this restaurant and will gladly say I was very impressed. I got Kinsey’s Trio Cheese specialty pasta and added grilled shrimp. The garlic knots are housemade and taste very great. My husband was a fan of his pizza topped with grilled chicken and sausage. We were greeted as we walked in the door and as we walked out. Very nice Italian Restaurant.

… more

Brad Anderson

An unexpected treat in Mccordsville. Real Italian food with excellent service by Stephanie. We weren’t expecting the meat balls to be made with a medium spicy Italian sausage, quite a pleasant surprise. A very large portion, too. The fettuccine tasted fresh made as did the alfredo sauce. Maybe a touch too much garlic for my taste but it must not have been too bad since I cleaned my plate, err, bowl. We definitely plan to return and well done Stephanie!
We have been frequenting Kinsey’s Italian Cafe for over 3 years now and found the food quality to be very consistent as is the personal service.
Sad to be moving away but we’ll be back, just not as often.

… more

stephany smith

It was a little chilly where we were seated. Mayb that part was added on with no heat? Great service and the food was flavorful. I recommend to try this place. I had manicotti with italian sausage.

… more

Angie Thomas

The food was delicious! Our server was very nice and helpful and explained the menu and lunch specials and buffet options. The dessert was wonderful. They had plenty of parking. And they have a separate room available for larger groups to reserve. The food is homemade and they have delicious garlic knots.

… more

Matthew Spencer

Now, don’t be put off by the initial appearance of the interior decor.
This was our first time at Kinsey’s.
We were taken care of by a lovely lady named Stephanie. She is charming, witty, and has a great sense of humor.
We started with some mozzarella sticks. Tasted like they were hand breaded…pretty good!
My wife ordered the Panzerotti and I ordered the Seafood Pasta.
Both dishes were quite tasty and there was plenty to bring home for later.
We’ll definitely visit again!

… more

… View more

Kinsey’s Italian Cafe

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results