Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4515 NY-30, Amsterdam, NY 12010
Phone: (518) 842-4907
Website: http://www.nicolinos518.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: spoton.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Nicolino’s Restaurant: Home
Nicolino’s Restaurant is a great place for a night of delicious Italian … 4513 State Highway 30 Amsterdam, NY 12010. Visa – Accepted by Nicolino’s …
Nicolino’s Restaurant | Amsterdam NY – Facebook
Nicolino’s Restaurant · Thursday Features ☎️518-842-4907 · Parm Night ! · Weekend Features! · Thursday Features Soup : Fire Roasted Tomato & White Bean ☎️ …
Menu – Nicolino’s Restaurant
4513 State Highway 30 Amsterdam, NY 12010. Visa – Accepted by Nicolino’s Restaurant2; Mastercard – Accepted by Nicolino’s Restaurant2; AMEX – Accepted by …
Reviews
Jennifer Cammarata
Just tried Nicolino’s tonight with my husband and brother in law and we were all impressed with the food and service. Jocelyn was an excellent server. We put our entire order in at once including drinks, appetizer, soup/salad, and our meals, and Jocelyn made sure everything came out staggered. The portions were huge and our meals were freshly made and piping hot. Excellent choice if you’re in the mood for Italian food!
… moreMay Clemente
We had amazing dishes and great service with our waiter Grace. Always a great meal at Nicolino’s!
… moreRebecca Gwozdz
Upon arriving, the restaurant had lost our reservation- But they were able to seat us after a not long wait. Our server was new (her first night, I think she said) – but what she lacked in experience, she made up for in personality. One of our orders was wrong originally and had to be sent back- which meant we didn’t get to eat together – but the food was delish! We were seated near a larger party who were very loud. It was difficult to hear one another – once that party left (near the end of our meal) – things were better.
… moreRobert Weller
My first time here. The restaurant is a quite nice family establishment. We were here to celebrate the life of a close family friend’s passing. The party was 25+ people. I’m sure the kitchen was pressed by the size of the lunch orders. Red and white wine were served along with glasses of water for all. Soda and other beverages were also available. Eventually carafes of water placed on the tables. The antipasto was very nicely done with roasted red peppers, artichokes, greens, cappacola, small diced tomatoes, etc all well seasoned. The fried calamari with red sauce was very, very good. Crispy, yet light, and most importantly NOT over cooked and rubbery! (THANK YOU, Nicolino’s) A big plus, for me, the tentacles WERE included. The “French” onion soup was forgettable. Not that flavors were bad, they weren’t. The beef broth could be more robust. Had it been called Italian French onion soup, it would have been most accurate. I’ve never had French onion soup with oregano in before and it was unexpected. The beans and greens had very good flavor. More than a bit salty and the beans could have been cooked a bit more, but the greens still had crunch left, Bravo. While the red sauce on the lasagna was VERY good (light, bright and nicely seasoned) and the ground beef and sausage were delightfully cooked and seasoned. The lasagna itself was heavy and dense. Too much (thin sliced) mozzarella and no apparent ricotta cheese. Perhaps another trip here is warranted to give it a fair shot. Large groups are a daunting challenge. To be fair, the portions are huge and yes, some leftovers are in my future. A good portion of extra sauce (Rao’s? My own?) for the lasagna will help and some low sodium chicken stock and added beans are coming soon for the beans and greens.
… moreDave Carnevale
We chose Nicolino’s for my older son’s 17th birthday dinner last weekend, and it proved to be a great gift for the whole family. Excellent food, our server CJ was super attentive and friendly and the birthday cannolo for my birthday bambino was a wonderful surprise. We promise not to wait a whole year to come back. Thank you!!
… moreAndy Britton
The food is exquisitely delicious, and I love the inside of the place
… moreDeborah Frascatore
We gathered at Nicolinos after my mother’s funeral. There were about 25 people. Arrangements were made a few days prior. The food was excellent as well as the service and we could not ask for anything more with the atmosphere. Thank you Nicolinos for such a beautiful and pleasant experience.
… moreKim Ambesi
My husband and I have been here a few times and each time Jocelyn was our server and she was outstanding!! Nicolinos has great food, great service, and is a great place to eat! Also they have gluten free options that are top notch
… moreWilliam Boswell
Had another awesome time at Nicolino’s with friends. Visited and meet some new friends at the bar. Food and drinks were amazing!!! Staff were very courteous, attentive and fun. I highly recommend Nicolino’s for a nice night out.
… moreVidya Ramlakhan
This is the worst Italian restaurant I ever went to the food is digusting cold old stale food the sauce taste like it’s been sitting in a can for days very poor. This place cannot be a real Italian restaurant very poor on taste and fresh chief boyordy tastes better than this place.
… more