About Us Since 1992 of restaurant experience, we are excited to present our concept to you and all our guests. We welcome you to experience authentic Southern Cuisine at our restaurants. Our caring and committed staff will make sure you have a fantastic experience with us. Dine In or Take Out We have worked to package our meals in a way that lets you bring the quality of our meals into your home. We always love to serve you fresh and high quality food. We ensure that your dining experience will always be top notch! Always Fresh Food At 5 Brothers Chicken & Waffles, we believe that great food and great company go hand in hand. Our mission is to create memorable dining experiences by providing exceptional service and delicious cuisine. We
Address and Contact Information
Address: 30 NY-25A UNIT 2, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733
Phone: (631) 675-0054
Website: https://www.5brotherscw.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
5 Brothers Chicken & Waffles – American Restaurant
Drop us a line, and we’ll get back to you soon. 5 Brothers Chicken & Waffles Locations. 30 ROUTE 25A SETAUKET, NY 11733 USA. 530 Medford Ave Patchouge NY 11772 …
Order 5 Brothers Chicken & Waffle – Menu & Prices – Uber Eats
Use your Uber account to order delivery from 5 Brothers Chicken & Waffle in East Setauket. Browse the menu, view popular items, and track your order.
5 Brothers Chicken & Waffle – East Setauket, NY – Seamless
Breakfast; Chicken / Tenders / Wings & Waffles; Catering; Ice Cream & Waffles; Vegetarian Menu; Grill Platters; Sandwiches; Side Orders; Party Wings …
Reviews
steven pastor
After consistently hearing positive feedback about this establishment, I decided to stop in on a Saturday afternoon to see for myself. The gentleman behind the counter was courteous and welcoming, which made for a pleasant first impression.
Although the food took approximately 15 minutes to prepare — slightly longer than expected — it was a reasonable wait given the quality and freshness. The meal did not disappoint. The waffle was prepared perfectly, and the fried chicken was juicy, well-seasoned, and cooked to an ideal consistency.
Overall, a very satisfying experience and well worth the visit.
… moreAlthough the food took approximately 15 minutes to prepare — slightly longer than expected — it was a reasonable wait given the quality and freshness. The meal did not disappoint. The waffle was prepared perfectly, and the fried chicken was juicy, well-seasoned, and cooked to an ideal consistency.
Overall, a very satisfying experience and well worth the visit.
Connor Ohlhorst
What a treat this place is! I’ve been going to the Patchogue location since they’ve opened and I’m so glad they’re opening more locations! The brothers are so personable and they want to make sure everybody has a great experience. The chicken is better than any chicken I’ve had before and my daughter loved the bubble waffle with ice cream and toppings! I’m looking forward to trying their new chicken sandwiches. Wishing them the best of luck with the new locations!
… moreKenny Tax (Long Island Foodies)
What an amazing experience.
From the moment I walked in until the moment I left the owner treated me truly like family. He sat there and conversed with me for 15-20 minutes. We chatted the entire time my chicken was freshly cooked.
I ordered a three-piece and waffle with mac and cheese.
Sometimes when you order deep fried chicken it tastes oily. This did not. It was cooked perfectly hotter than a volcano and delicious.
The waffle was amazing as always with a little dusting of powdered sugar… It’s more like dessert than anything else.
I absolutely loved the mac and cheese. It had a great taste and not like your typical mac and cheese.
Everything was fantastic. It was so clean. Nothing felt greasy. And just all around amazing.
… moreFrom the moment I walked in until the moment I left the owner treated me truly like family. He sat there and conversed with me for 15-20 minutes. We chatted the entire time my chicken was freshly cooked.
I ordered a three-piece and waffle with mac and cheese.
Sometimes when you order deep fried chicken it tastes oily. This did not. It was cooked perfectly hotter than a volcano and delicious.
The waffle was amazing as always with a little dusting of powdered sugar… It’s more like dessert than anything else.
I absolutely loved the mac and cheese. It had a great taste and not like your typical mac and cheese.
Everything was fantastic. It was so clean. Nothing felt greasy. And just all around amazing.
James
I’ve been twice and both times the chicken and waffle were delicious. The waffle is soft and tasty while the chicken was surprisingly flavorful. They aren’t small peices either. The only miss was the chocolate chip brownie, which was very sugary and didn’t taste that fresh to the point I couldn’t even finish it. Staff were friendly both times I visited.
The food takes a while to prepare; I want to say I waited 15 minutes last time so advice would be to order ahead of time. I wouldn’t hesitate to go back and try more off the menu.
… moreThe food takes a while to prepare; I want to say I waited 15 minutes last time so advice would be to order ahead of time. I wouldn’t hesitate to go back and try more off the menu.
Ali The Halal Foodie
Attention Seawolves New Restaurant
5 Brothers Chicken & Waffles
30 NY-25A, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733
3 pcs Chicken tender
Fried chicken
Waffles
Waffles with ice cream
Bubble ice cream waffle
Sweet Corn nuggets
10 Honey BBQ Wings
Curly fries
Nashville Hot Chicken
Homemade banana pudding
Homemade Baked Mac and Cheese
Review:
5 Brothers Fried Chicken & Waffles is known for its flavorful fried chicken and generous portions. The restaurant is a dine in establishment, offering a variety of comfort foods with a focus on fried chicken and waffles. The waffles are fluffy, delicious, and paired nicely with the seasoned fried chicken. I personally love their wings, banana pudding, and their refreshing lemonade.
⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
(4 out of 5 Stars)
Don’t forget to say Bismillah and Alhamdulilah for everything
Follow @AliTheHalalFoodie
… more5 Brothers Chicken & Waffles
30 NY-25A, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733
3 pcs Chicken tender
Fried chicken
Waffles
Waffles with ice cream
Bubble ice cream waffle
Sweet Corn nuggets
10 Honey BBQ Wings
Curly fries
Nashville Hot Chicken
Homemade banana pudding
Homemade Baked Mac and Cheese
Review:
5 Brothers Fried Chicken & Waffles is known for its flavorful fried chicken and generous portions. The restaurant is a dine in establishment, offering a variety of comfort foods with a focus on fried chicken and waffles. The waffles are fluffy, delicious, and paired nicely with the seasoned fried chicken. I personally love their wings, banana pudding, and their refreshing lemonade.
⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
(4 out of 5 Stars)
Don’t forget to say Bismillah and Alhamdulilah for everything
Follow @AliTheHalalFoodie
Costa deVeer
This restaurant was a life changing spiritual experience. This meal cleanse my body and my father was able to speak again. As he hasn’t been able to speak for 80 years because of a hole in his throat from smoking just one time when he was 8.
Also is this an Eggoji waffle???? They also gave me a lot of syrup which I put on my plate. Idk why it was paper though. The chicken was fine but a little too much. Maybe half the size and I would have been able to finish it all. I also got to meet all 5 brothers! They were was nicer then the 5 guys over at 5 guys.
I attached a photo of the lovely meal they made me.
Overall 9.27/10
… moreAlso is this an Eggoji waffle???? They also gave me a lot of syrup which I put on my plate. Idk why it was paper though. The chicken was fine but a little too much. Maybe half the size and I would have been able to finish it all. I also got to meet all 5 brothers! They were was nicer then the 5 guys over at 5 guys.
I attached a photo of the lovely meal they made me.
Overall 9.27/10
Hunter
I stopped in on a late night drive on a whim. I’m so glad I did! The chicken is super tender and juicy, mac and cheese is creamy and the sweet corn nuggets are absolutely fantastic. I’m so glad I found this place it’s absolutely worth a visit.
… moreDaniel
Compared to Patchogue which is what drove me here it was very disappointing. The cashier was not friendly. It took long for the chicken even though no one was in the store when we got there. Tasted bland. Just did not enjoy it. Do yourself a favor and go to the Patchogue location.
… moreArslan N
I’ve supported these guys for years and genuinely love them, but I’m honestly shocked at their prices now. I don’t know if they recently increased them, but compared to similar spots, it’s gotten really expensive.
I tried ordering:
• 3 chicken sandwiches (+3 sides you can’t remove)
• 8-pc mixed chicken (+side & waffle)
• 5 wings (+waffle)
Total came out to $91!
For what?! I just don’t understand the pricing anymore. This used to be affordable, but now I’m paying premium, sit-down prices at what’s essentially a fast-food place—especially when tons of other restaurants offer similar items.
I ended up going to Tex’s Chicken & Burgers instead. For under $50, I got:
• 10-pc chicken
• 3 sides
• 4 biscuits
• double cheeseburger
• loaded fries
• 4 full wings
And even if I added four chicken sandwiches on top of all that, the total STILL wouldn’t have reached $91.
They really need to make their pricing clearer. This whole “every item automatically comes with sides” model is going to hurt them in this economy. Most people would prefer to pay $2–$3 less and skip the random sides. But the way it’s presented, you’re asked which sides you want—without any explanation that choosing no sides makes the meal cheaper.
For example, I was told the 5-pc chicken is $18. Already on the high side, but fine.
But at checkout it became $22 because a side was auto-added. I didn’t even want the side. And honestly, $18 for 5 pieces—where two of those pieces are usually a wing and a leg—means I’m paying roughly $3.60 per piece. After tax, almost $4 for a leg?! Come on…
It’s frustrating because with $91, I could walk into almost any Mediterranean spot and get a lamb chops platter, a kebab platter, AND a steak or lamb shank platter—all for less than what I was about to spend here on fried chicken. Even well-known Italian places wouldn’t charge that much for a large pizza and a couple of entrées.
Bottom line: be careful. They pad the bill with sides you might not even want. Ask them to remove those to avoid hidden charges. Maybe then it becomes more reasonable. But with so many competing spots offering similar food, prices like these are going to push customers away.
… moreI tried ordering:
• 3 chicken sandwiches (+3 sides you can’t remove)
• 8-pc mixed chicken (+side & waffle)
• 5 wings (+waffle)
Total came out to $91!
For what?! I just don’t understand the pricing anymore. This used to be affordable, but now I’m paying premium, sit-down prices at what’s essentially a fast-food place—especially when tons of other restaurants offer similar items.
I ended up going to Tex’s Chicken & Burgers instead. For under $50, I got:
• 10-pc chicken
• 3 sides
• 4 biscuits
• double cheeseburger
• loaded fries
• 4 full wings
And even if I added four chicken sandwiches on top of all that, the total STILL wouldn’t have reached $91.
They really need to make their pricing clearer. This whole “every item automatically comes with sides” model is going to hurt them in this economy. Most people would prefer to pay $2–$3 less and skip the random sides. But the way it’s presented, you’re asked which sides you want—without any explanation that choosing no sides makes the meal cheaper.
For example, I was told the 5-pc chicken is $18. Already on the high side, but fine.
But at checkout it became $22 because a side was auto-added. I didn’t even want the side. And honestly, $18 for 5 pieces—where two of those pieces are usually a wing and a leg—means I’m paying roughly $3.60 per piece. After tax, almost $4 for a leg?! Come on…
It’s frustrating because with $91, I could walk into almost any Mediterranean spot and get a lamb chops platter, a kebab platter, AND a steak or lamb shank platter—all for less than what I was about to spend here on fried chicken. Even well-known Italian places wouldn’t charge that much for a large pizza and a couple of entrées.
Bottom line: be careful. They pad the bill with sides you might not even want. Ask them to remove those to avoid hidden charges. Maybe then it becomes more reasonable. But with so many competing spots offering similar food, prices like these are going to push customers away.
Kyle F
Everytime I look at the menu, I want to try something else from here but I always end up ordering the catfish cause I can’t pass it up. The catfish and corn nuggets are my favorite. The fried chicken is also great.
… more