Burt Benjamin
This was our first time visiting. Customer service was 20/10! Friendly, inviting and informative. Help with choices and options. Food was tasty and sure will be returning!! The bread and Marinara Sauce was everything. You must try.
… moreJonathan Prudholme
Delicious! The Hawaiian and 46th Specialty pizza were both on point. I don’t eat a lot of pizza but when I do, my expectations are high. This place exceeded my expectations and I plan on returning again. Everything you see on the menu sounds delicious.
… moreThe Hernandez Family
This place was amazing, I absolutely loved it. The food was great. my family and I all loved how the pizza was made! We are definitely going to go here again!!
… moreJacqueline Peebles
At first I thought I was just hungry! I had one slice of pepperoni and sausage pizza for lunch and it was so good that I brought my husband back for dinner! No pictures of the actual pizza because it was just that good! I’ll be back!
… moreLora Schafer
First we loved the toppings. Lots of flavor, lots of them, good balance of cheese and meat. For a New York style pizza I do wish it was still a bit thinner but n the crust. But a great family night pizza pick.
… moreMarcus Altus
This is authentic NYC pizza. Loved it! Just the right amount of sauce and cheese and the crust was wonderful. Their salads were also fresh and delicious. This is my new favorite pizza joint. Thanks!
… moreRandy Lee
We skipped Longhorns for pizza tonight. Best choice ever. Pizza, garlic bread and salad was very good, presentation was outstanding and the service was way over what I expect. We will be back, they got something figured out and I want more.
… moreManuela Egekwu
A couple weeks ago we discovered 46th St. New York Style Pizzeria. We instantly loved the food. Since then we came back twice. After an long evening event we decided to order and take out pizza. We picked up the Pizza and immediately in the car I discovered a unpleasant smell. Didn’t think nothing off it. When I got home the and opened the pizza the smell got worse. I tried the pizza and it tasted horrible. We called that we had an issue there was nothing they could do. I went back and dropped the pizzas off and said they could only exchange one pizza. The lady was very unfriendly and said we will not refund or recook the pizzas. Josh, was very helpful and was able to get us one exchanged. Very poor costumer service.
… morePhil Erven
46th Street Pizza in Cibolo is absolutely fantastic! From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was warm, inviting, and very clean. The overall ambiance makes it a great place to relax and enjoy a meal with family or friends.
A huge shoutout to Nicci, who was super awesome! She went above and beyond to make sure we were taken care of—friendly, attentive, and full of positive energy. On top of that, Nicci proudly served in the U.S. Army, and we truly thank her for her service.
The food not only looks amazing but tastes even better! Everything came out fresh, hot, and flavorful—clearly made with care.
Between the great food, excellent service, and welcoming environment, this place definitely deserves all 5 stars. Highly recommend 46th Street Pizza if you’re in the Cibolo area!
Oh, the beer is super cold! And great selection!!!
… moreAlejandro “knocks” Lopez
One of the best pizzas I’ve ever ate It taste genuine unbelievable man I’ll come back again
… more