Tiny, straightforward pizza counter turning out a variety of slices and whole pizzas.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 143 W 40th St, New York, NY 10018
Phone: (212) 366-5550
Website: https://www.150freshpizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
$1.50 Fresh Pizza – 151 E 43rd St, New York, NY 10017 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in New York, NY! $1.50 Fresh Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …
$1.50 Fresh Pizza Delivery Menu | 1723 Broadway New York
Order delivery or pickup from $1.50 Fresh Pizza in New York! View $1.50 Fresh Pizza’s February 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with …
Dollar Slice Club Episode 3: $1.50 Fresh Pizza Smoky … – Instagram
The top 14 slices in NYC, based on over 95 million ratings on Beli. Let us know what you think should have made the list!
Reviews
Zoebella
Holy crapadoodado this place was unreal. We got 2 slices of pepperoni pizza, bbq chicken and a cheese. This is our third night in NYC and our fifth pizza place to try and omg was the best one yet. Cheapest, warmest, freshes ahhhh. We will definitely be back. Highly recommend. For four pizzas and two bottles of water was $11.50 usd which is just unfricken betable in pretty much the heart of time square. To find this place it is under scaffolding just around the corner of time square. Do not get mistaken with the pizza shop that is pretty much opposite this shop on the corner this shop is not on the corner. On apple maps it is still called 99cent fresh pizza. It is on 40th street in between 7th ave and broadway. There are benches inside where you can stand and eat your slice before going back out on the streets. Enjoy fellow followers
… moreAxzl
This pizza place was surprisingly good. The crust was good, the toppings were good, the flavor was good. Honestly, everything was solid.
I definitely recommend getting pizza here, even if it’s just to try it out. Just make sure you have a plan for where to eat. There isn’t much room inside, and some people can be a bit obnoxious.
One thing worth mentioning is hygiene. I noticed cash being handled while also working the oven and using kitchen tools like pizza slicers. I guess that’s normal for some places, but it did stand out.
Overall, an easy 5-star rating for me.
… moreI definitely recommend getting pizza here, even if it’s just to try it out. Just make sure you have a plan for where to eat. There isn’t much room inside, and some people can be a bit obnoxious.
One thing worth mentioning is hygiene. I noticed cash being handled while also working the oven and using kitchen tools like pizza slicers. I guess that’s normal for some places, but it did stand out.
Overall, an easy 5-star rating for me.
Michael
This is some high quality pizza for sure, very unique, you won’t find this kind of spot all the time. Definitely recommend it, not kidding, try it yourself when you want some good cheese. I didn’t make a reservation but there was a spot for me anyway. This lemonade is good man
… moreLuna Moreno
Good pizza that’s fresh and ready fast for a good price. They take card and get the two slice combo with a drink. Only standup counters to eat so be ready for that or take it to go.
… moreBrian Huang
$6 for 2 slices of pepperoni and a water (or soft drink). Delicious pizza at a price that can’t be beat. Line moves quickly, efficient service.
… moreJoel
update: unfortunately lowering this to 3 from 4. I ended up getting sick overnight from the freshly made pie. not sure why because it tasted good during
Ratings are hard but this is at 4+ and also 3- in different ways. For the area and all, it’s a good slice at a very good price. You’re not going to want to sit here and eat and if you want the best slice in the area this is not it. It has good pizza and good staff and a place to stand while eating it. It gets very packed near times square but moves fast for slices. The dough is too doughy for nyc pizza. Place is clean enough and might be a good chance to talk to other new yorkers who are also just in for a quick slice. The whole pies are cheap compared to other local places and they have a full range of toppings to add. IMO it’s worth it for a full pie and in general a good spot to stop at.
… moreRatings are hard but this is at 4+ and also 3- in different ways. For the area and all, it’s a good slice at a very good price. You’re not going to want to sit here and eat and if you want the best slice in the area this is not it. It has good pizza and good staff and a place to stand while eating it. It gets very packed near times square but moves fast for slices. The dough is too doughy for nyc pizza. Place is clean enough and might be a good chance to talk to other new yorkers who are also just in for a quick slice. The whole pies are cheap compared to other local places and they have a full range of toppings to add. IMO it’s worth it for a full pie and in general a good spot to stop at.
Dominik Tratnik
Good value for money. Not the crispiest crust out there, but perfect for a quick bite on the go.
… moreAraina Eber
We were spending a few hours in New York and decided to taste test pizza. First we went to the highly rated Joe’s Pizza in Broadway. It was good, long line, but good. Not as great as I remembered NY pizza being. Then we went to $1.50 pizza because we parked right across the street. This was actually better than Joe’s in me, my 14 year old and 6 year old son’s, and husband’s opinion. It had that true New York taste that I remembered. Classic, great price, totally worth it and better. GO HERE!
… moreGeorge C
Great pizza Great price. Don’t underestimate it. Way better then expected. Greasy, nice fold and flop. 2 slices and soda 4$.
… moresbso
Better than some places that charge 3 times as much. We got the pizza almost instantly and was piping hot. The cheese could be better quality but $10 for an 18″ pie, it could be worse. For the price of a corn dog across the street from port authority, you get a whole pie.
… more