Nikolai
So first and foremost, “Your pizza shop” is an interesting name. thier slogan: “Finest pizza anywhere” should be “middest pizza anywhere” The sauce is nothing special, the cheese is honestly kinda gross, but passable, and the pizza reheats very poorly and is borderline disgusting. and this is a personal gripe but the way they place their pepperoni irritates me. every time ive ordered a pizza its had some topping missing.
the pizza kinda sucks, but if you really crave it and there’s literally no other alternative, its okay.
now… the chicken is another story. Your chicken shop should be this places name because oh my god its some of the BEST fried chicken ive had it rivals some places ive been to in Louisiana, its so crispy, juicy, tender, and the jojos are very good. both the fried chicken boxes and the hot wings are delicious and the sauces, while basic, are quite enjoyable. It’s worth getting food here just for the chicken im so fr, whatever they’re doing with it they do it EXTREMELY well, and out of anywhere you could get fried chicken or wings in the area, this is by far the best without a doubt
… moreNicholas Buch
I gotta say…I am reading these reviews and from the negative to the positive reviews, we all have our own experiences. I can only say from my personal, honest experiences with this location that I have never had a bad experience. From the phone calls placing my orders, to the time they say it will get to my home and they’re usually earlier, to the quality of the food, I just love. Your negative posts I dont understand because I’ve never experienced those things in the last 3 years. I hope this place stays in business because I will continue to order food from here.
… morechante pettis
So salty got kids chicken so didn’t have cook when I got home and seen my kids plate it red and not done! Called and the manager arguing with me say it’s impossible!!! I didn’t want anything free cause I put rest in air fryer.
… moreKasey G
This is an edited review. Mistakes happen and the MGR contacted me directly. My review was not based on the food taste but on the quality. Since getting great customer reaction from this company, I will change my review to 5 STAR. I myself work in customer service and appreciate the opportunity to make things right. I was given a “do over” to try again. Thank you Jen!! GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE. When it is not exact talk to the MGR – that is what they do. Correct an error….
… moreRobin Nicewander
They’re very nice and accommodating anything you want they do the best. And they aren’t far to go. Thank you for being sso considerate. Jeff & Robin
… moreRobert Weisgarber
Two weeks ago it took over two hours for my delivery to reach my house. This week I ordered for pickup. Low and behold they dumped my order after an hour. I talked to the woman both times. Apparently when it is there mistake I am supposed to forgive it, if I am late it is piss on the customer. It’s not even that great of pizza, just close. I will never return to this place. They didn’t even remember to bring my two liter two weeks ago. I am having gold fish for supper tonight.
… moreSam Ingram
Excellent pizza and wings!
BUT. . . dont order within an hour of closing. If they forget something, they’ll just answer the phone, say “sorry we’re closed” and hang up on you. Even tho they’re not closed yet. Good job guys.
… moreJohnna Wargo
I placed an order thru Slice and found out it was going to take a long time for delivery. Then, I tried to cancel, butt,was told that I could not. She said that had to cancel thru the app that didn’t give me the option…once they had my virtual card, I was screwed. Then the manager called and resolved my problem. Thank you Massillon Your Pizza shop
… moreSarah K.
I cannot say thank you enough to this group. Last week, we ordered about 15 pies for an after wedding party which was delivered at 10:30pm when they were about to close up shop for the night. The pizza was outstanding! The crust was not crunchy or dry, but it was just soft enough with a bit of a bite. Absolutely delicious! It was one of the best pizzas we ever had. The delivery driver was kind, considerate, and prompt. The bride and groom didn’t get much to eat that night, and the pizza was top notch for them at the after party. Thank you for being so accommodating and helpful. We will absolutely order again when we’re in the area.
… moreJoe Urbas
$50 order (ehh), Kids liked the pizza but seems like it may have been dropped because only half of the pizza had cheese or toppings lol. Wings looked like they may have sat under the heat lamp for a few too long. Meatball sub was spot on though
… more