Address and Contact Information
Address: 3543 Watkins Rd, Horseheads, NY 14845
Phone: (607) 739-2405
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Hickory House Restaurant – Facebook
We will be reopening January 6, 2025. We wish everyone a safe and Happy New Year! Nancy Austin and …
Ye Olde Hickory House, 3543 Watkins Rd, Horseheads, NY 14845, US
Get more information for Ye Olde Hickory House in Horseheads, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Discover Yee Olde Hickory House in Horseheads, NY | Reviews
Yee Olde Hickory House is a classic American restaurant. Explore reviews, photos, and menu highlights to see what makes this place a local favorite in …
Reviews
Money Pick
Service was good. Our Kids had the Hotdogs and fries. Their food came out first and nice and hot! Was delicious.
Our food, burger and chicken Alfredo was mid.
Burger was dry(ordered well done but more done than intended)
Alfredo sauce we did not like. For some reason it just tasted like perfume to the both of us. Yeah a bit odd. We did not eat it after 2 bites but still paid no biggie..
Other than that it was ok. The folks working are nice people 🙂
… moreOur food, burger and chicken Alfredo was mid.
Burger was dry(ordered well done but more done than intended)
Alfredo sauce we did not like. For some reason it just tasted like perfume to the both of us. Yeah a bit odd. We did not eat it after 2 bites but still paid no biggie..
Other than that it was ok. The folks working are nice people 🙂
R K
Saturday Prime Rib Steak Heaven at Ye Oldie Hickory!
If you’re looking for a place that combines amazing food, a welcoming vibe, and a family-friendly atmosphere, Ye Oldie Hickory is the spot!
Saturday’s Prime Rib Steak is hands-down my favorite—juicy, tender, and packed with flavor that beats everything else on the menu (and that’s saying a lot!). Don’t miss their chicken wings and the classic liver and onions (on Tuesday), both full of bold, comforting flavors that will have you coming back for more.
As a family-owned restaurant, Ye Oldie Hickory shines with its warm hospitality. The owner and staff are super friendly and make everyone feel at home. It’s kid-friendly too, so bring your whole family or gather your friends for a cozy and memorable dinner.
Plan your next visit, and thank me later—you’ll leave with a happy belly and a big smile!
… moreIf you’re looking for a place that combines amazing food, a welcoming vibe, and a family-friendly atmosphere, Ye Oldie Hickory is the spot!
Saturday’s Prime Rib Steak is hands-down my favorite—juicy, tender, and packed with flavor that beats everything else on the menu (and that’s saying a lot!). Don’t miss their chicken wings and the classic liver and onions (on Tuesday), both full of bold, comforting flavors that will have you coming back for more.
As a family-owned restaurant, Ye Oldie Hickory shines with its warm hospitality. The owner and staff are super friendly and make everyone feel at home. It’s kid-friendly too, so bring your whole family or gather your friends for a cozy and memorable dinner.
Plan your next visit, and thank me later—you’ll leave with a happy belly and a big smile!
Marcus Sekella
Good food ! My wife and I love the French onion soup and the home town atmosphere! The drinks go down smooth as well
… moreBianca Wagstaff
I absolutely love going here with my boyfriend. We went again last night and their fried rice is the best thing I’ve ever had. I get the scallops with the Cajun sauce extra spicy. I highly recommend this place over anything else in the area. We are treated like family and love the hospitality they give us. Will be going here until we’re old and wrinkly. 100/10. Would recommend.
… moreMy Mazurowski
I personally don’t like all potatoes, but everything else like the steak was delicious. 10/10 would recommend when you don’t have any idea where to go.
… moreHarden Boystern
– Sign says “wait to be seated” but no one was around to seat us. After a few moments, a bar customer came over to give us menus and told us to “sit anywhere”
– Rug is stained pretty badly, and the table top finish is so old that it is sticky
– Ordered a chicken entree, wife got the seafood sampler: Chicken was dry and tough, fish was flaky and tasty, most of the clams were tiny strips of breading, sour cream for the baked potato was spoiled
– $52 for two dinners and two sodas before tip
– Seemed like mostly locals in the place
… more– Rug is stained pretty badly, and the table top finish is so old that it is sticky
– Ordered a chicken entree, wife got the seafood sampler: Chicken was dry and tough, fish was flaky and tasty, most of the clams were tiny strips of breading, sour cream for the baked potato was spoiled
– $52 for two dinners and two sodas before tip
– Seemed like mostly locals in the place
Kayley Donohue
Very cute and homey place! Everything was homemade and even their water was great! Highly recommend the mozzarella sticks and the french onion soup. The prices are great and the portions are amazing! They even play great music!! The lady was very nice 🙂
… moreBryan Gardner
Stopped here for dinner after softball game. Food was good, but the service was very slow for not being busy.
… moreJohn Jacob
I found rat droppings in My cream of wheat and hair in my meatloaf what a bad experience
… moreJeff Till
The waitress was friendly and the restaurant had character but there are some needed updates that need to be made such as the table tops. It was Friday night fish fry and we had the broiled fish which was not fresh at all and the stuffed fish which was mediocre at best. The cole slaw and bread was very good. The bar was packed and folks were enjoying themselves.
… more