Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2528 NY-12B, Hamilton, NY 13346
Phone: (315) 824-1800
Website: https://www.oneidapizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Ye Olde Pizza Pub | Home
Authentic New York-style pizza, fresh ingredients, and a welcoming vibe. Oneida Pizza is your local spot for quality food and great company.
Menu – Ye Olde Pizza Pub
Our Menu. SpecialsPizzaWingsAppetizers & SaucesSaladsSubs & SandwichesWrapsBurgersGrilled ChickenPastaFried ChickenDinnersKids …
Ye Olde Pizza Pub Inc (@YeOldePizzaPubInc) – Facebook
Ye Olde Pizza Pub Inc. 3268 likes · 53 talking about this. Your Affordable, Family Restaurant- family friendly.
Reviews
Dennis Carney
Used to love this place, last few pizzas have been off. Ordered a normal medium chicken wing pizza and got this. I’m not even sure what this is, it’s loaded in cheese and super soggy. It’s disappointing considering the prices there.
… morebrittney jorgensen
Ordered for the first time Paid 80$ for garbage! Wings were suppose to be garlic, I don’t know what they were but they were not! Wings were soggy left in an inch of oil. Not a single one was cooked properly not even a crunchy outside! Ordered two pizzas as well one wasn’t cooked all the way dough in the crust was raw and the other was burnt. I would never recommend to anyone, I’d rather buy frozen at least I know it will be done and it won’t cost me 80$.
… moreA
Crusty, dusty, dingy and sticky.
We ended up being the only ones that came in and sat down to eat the whole time we were there. When we looked around you can see the cobwebs swinging from the ceiling, the water damage marks and all the dust. I dare you to take a nice hard look at the self serve soft drink machine
You seat yourselves, order at the front, pour your own drinks. They did bring our food to us though then we cleared our own table.
Wings are itty bitty things with decent flavor. No crispiness and have some sort of coating under the sauce that adds to the sogginess. It is the same thing with their “taters”- just sad wet sliced potatoes begging and crying for two more minutes in the hot oil bath.
The pizza is just alright. Crust is decent but it’s not that homemade deliciousness. The garlic pizza was missing the garlic flavor.
It fed us but definitely wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone and will definitely not be back.
… moreWe ended up being the only ones that came in and sat down to eat the whole time we were there. When we looked around you can see the cobwebs swinging from the ceiling, the water damage marks and all the dust. I dare you to take a nice hard look at the self serve soft drink machine
You seat yourselves, order at the front, pour your own drinks. They did bring our food to us though then we cleared our own table.
Wings are itty bitty things with decent flavor. No crispiness and have some sort of coating under the sauce that adds to the sogginess. It is the same thing with their “taters”- just sad wet sliced potatoes begging and crying for two more minutes in the hot oil bath.
The pizza is just alright. Crust is decent but it’s not that homemade deliciousness. The garlic pizza was missing the garlic flavor.
It fed us but definitely wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone and will definitely not be back.
Deborah Edick
Not sure where the AI came up with overall review of amazing pizza and wings and consistency in quality after reading other reviews.
The wings are over priced, at least 1/2 the size of wings at other establishments, and the coating is mealy. I strongly recommend not ordering takeout especially close to opening time as the wings are usually left over from the previous days business . Since they are closed on Monday you’re just getting Sundays leftovers if ordering Tuesday between 4-6.
Loaded taters are greasy and nasty.
If you’re looking for a laxative this is the place to go, if you’re able to keep it down long enough without regurgitating.
This place has gone way downhill over the years.
Really should have a dress code for the girls on the front end as well as training in customer service.
Will definitely not be back anytime soon.
… moreThe wings are over priced, at least 1/2 the size of wings at other establishments, and the coating is mealy. I strongly recommend not ordering takeout especially close to opening time as the wings are usually left over from the previous days business . Since they are closed on Monday you’re just getting Sundays leftovers if ordering Tuesday between 4-6.
Loaded taters are greasy and nasty.
If you’re looking for a laxative this is the place to go, if you’re able to keep it down long enough without regurgitating.
This place has gone way downhill over the years.
Really should have a dress code for the girls on the front end as well as training in customer service.
Will definitely not be back anytime soon.
Bhailis
Amazing Pizza&Wings. I always get the highest and consistent quality orders from the pizza pub!
I’ll pop service to 3 stars only because getting charged 40.03 for a medium and 15 wings is highly overpriced. If the app worked and I did not have to call-in the order it would have been around 25-30$ so that makes 0 sense.
… moreI’ll pop service to 3 stars only because getting charged 40.03 for a medium and 15 wings is highly overpriced. If the app worked and I did not have to call-in the order it would have been around 25-30$ so that makes 0 sense.
Melody Seaton
Waited over an hour and half for a pizza, wings and taters kept being told 10 more minutes. Run by teenagers no manager. People actually left before getting their food requesting money back. Worst experience will not return.asked for a refund and was totally ignored
… moreTravis Westcott
Ye Olde Pizza Pub has remained a family favorite since I was a child. Now I take my kids there. The food is excellent and they play movies on a big screen while you eat. You’ll never find a place with the unique taste of the pizza and breaded wings, not to mention their potato wedges. The owner and the employees are super humble, kind, and friendly. They care about their customers’ experience. I highly recommend Ye Olde Pizza Pub.
… morebrienna
I’ve ate here my entire life and this past year has been bad, decided to get a pizza after awhile and they put paper underneath the pizza in box which then ruined my pizza by attaching to the crust they’ve never used paper before so why start now and ruin things.
… moreGINA MORALES
I was up here for my niece’s wedding at Camp Fiver,they ordered pizzas Thursday evening,2 pepperoni 1 vegetable pizza and 2 cheese pizzas. I’m gonna tell you right now…THAT PIZZA WAS THE BEST I’VE EATEN IN YEARSSSSSS!!!! Thank you for putting your heart and soul and foot into making that pizza. The crust was amazing,now you know if the crust is good,the pizza is good. It reminded me of my youth growing up on the city in Queens NY. I’m telling everyone that decides to come your way or passing by,please stop and this business and get their pizza. It will not disappoint!! Thank you again guys for making pizza the correct way ❤️
… moreHaley Schladebeck
The chicken wings tasted like fish and were a third the size of a regular wing, but full price. Ordered a 16″ pizza and received a 12″ instead. Concerned for the freshness of the food, also poor customer service. Will not eat here again. $50 wasted and regret leaving a tip.
… more