Hours
| Saturday | 4:30–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4:30–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 4:30–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 4:30–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 4:30–8:30 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1136 Almond Rd, Elmer, NJ 08318
Phone: (856) 358-3201
Website: http://www.centertoninn.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Ye Olde Centerton Inn Dining
Great food is timeless. · Reservations Only | Info · Call (856) 358-3201 · 1136 Almond Road, Pittsgrove, NJ 08318 …
Ye Olde Centerton Inn – Facebook
Ye Olde Centerton Inn is feeling festive in Elmer, NJ. Dec 12, 2025 . . The holidays are in full swing here at Centerton Inn, and our guests are just as …
Ye Olde Centerton Inn (@centertoninn) · Elmer, NJ – Instagram
est. 1706 timeless taste • modern charm dining room + tavern in pittsgrove, nj · Dinners, drinks, and date nights under a new-vintage glow …
Reviews
Jacqleen Gonzalez
Amazing hidden gem.
Start with the calamari and end with the brownie!!! Every bite was delicious and perfect. Steak was a tad charred and gave the charcoal taste so that was something we would address next time but definitely plan to make this one of our top spots. MAKE RESERVATIONS! Pic is of the bone in pork chop and oh my its incredible
… moreStart with the calamari and end with the brownie!!! Every bite was delicious and perfect. Steak was a tad charred and gave the charcoal taste so that was something we would address next time but definitely plan to make this one of our top spots. MAKE RESERVATIONS! Pic is of the bone in pork chop and oh my its incredible
KRISTINA Smith
I had the best birthday today! This restaurant is amazing everything was so worth the price! I had the centerton steak which was mouth watering! The server was so sweet and very knowledgeable about everything will definitely be coming back
… moreLouis Iaconelli
We attempted to make a reservation for a party of 9 and were told they would not accommodate a group that size. This was surprising and disappointing, especially since we were trying to plan ahead and give the restaurant notice.
There was no effort to offer alternatives, suggest splitting tables, or provide another option — just a flat refusal. I completely understand that space and staffing can be challenges, but the lack of flexibility or willingness to work with us was frustrating.
We were ready to bring a large group and spend money there, but instead had to find another restaurant that was more accommodating. Unfortunately, as a local to the area this left a poor taste and won’t be back I rather give my business to a restaurant that is grateful and appreciates the business.
… moreThere was no effort to offer alternatives, suggest splitting tables, or provide another option — just a flat refusal. I completely understand that space and staffing can be challenges, but the lack of flexibility or willingness to work with us was frustrating.
We were ready to bring a large group and spend money there, but instead had to find another restaurant that was more accommodating. Unfortunately, as a local to the area this left a poor taste and won’t be back I rather give my business to a restaurant that is grateful and appreciates the business.
M Obrien
Went for my husbands birthday. William the bartender kept us entertained since we were early for our reservation. William you are AWESOME. Our server Jarrod (sorry if i misspelled it) went over and beyond to make this night very special. The food was usual top notch. From beginning to end everyone made this a special night and I thank you from the bottom of my heart. EVERYONE was the best.
… moreIm2s0ot2u5a
First time here with my spouse. Although the food was plentiful and delicious, we were not impressed with the atmosphere. It is quaint, but some staff are very loud, the music is loud, and the owners did something unthinkable; they permitted a photographer to come in while patrons were eating. We were subjected to bright flashing lights going off all around us for more than 30 minutes. It completely ruined our meal and my appetite. We came home to enjoy the remainder of our meals, our own coffee, and our own dessert without flashing lights! That experience was inexcusable.
… moreTravel With Trey
An absolute gem in Southern Jersey. First of all, the restaurant is the 3rd oldest in the United States, over 300 years old so you get a cozy colonial atmosphere. If the history isn’t enough for you, the food is excellent. I had brisket egg rolls as my appetizer served with an au jus sauce and horseradish. The garlic house salad is so good, bursting with freshness and flavor. Finally, I had the New York Strip steak with fries. The fries were crispy and nicely well done while the steak was delectable. Just a perfect cut of meat, perfectly cooked. We have a great time chatting with the owner and our wonderful bartender who hit us off with some historical cocktails, including a Devil’s Whiskers. It was a great way to top off our evening.
… moreWill Salmons
Food is excellent! The seafood bisque is to die for! The pork tenderloin is amazing. The reason for only 4 stars is the building itself needs some tender loving care, but it is the oldest inn in NJ and 2nd oldest in the country. The staff was friendly and very inviting.
… moreTom Kelly
Great place. Amazing history – come for the building, stay for the amazing top notch reasonably priced food. Awesome service to complement Shawne’s awesome handlebar mustache. Great drinks too! Thanks for a great experience. We will be back!
… moreDan Stevens
My wife and I celebrated our 37th anniversary there today, Sean was our server and was very on point,the food was fresh and delicious,I would definitely recommend this quaint place,especially if you like old buildings, it was like stepping back in time,thanks for making it a memorable anniversary
… moreMike Marchlik
We had dinner here while visiting the area. The restaurant is a little on the upscale side and we were under dressed so I felt a little uncomfortable.
The dining room we ate in had such charm. The food was decent and for the price with dessert and salad being included it was a good value but on the high side. We had four children with our party and they were accommodative.
Great service, great character/charm, good food, priced on the high side but worth the value. I’d visit again dressed properly and with the kids at home.
… moreThe dining room we ate in had such charm. The food was decent and for the price with dessert and salad being included it was a good value but on the high side. We had four children with our party and they were accommodative.
Great service, great character/charm, good food, priced on the high side but worth the value. I’d visit again dressed properly and with the kids at home.