Brent gaffey
This place wasn’t what I expected, I thought it would be a sit down pizza joint with a bar and some intimacy, i was wrong. This place felt like a to-go pizza place with some stools to eat quick. They had a large venue outside and a food truck as well. It serves some odd pizzas as well, which i most definitely tried. The most odd combination that i ate was the pickle pizza, which wasn’t bad, just odd considering I’ve never had it before. Pizza was mostly good, worth it once.
… moreGabe Fitzgerald
I first tried Yankee Pie Apizza the day they opened the food truck around 2 years ago and it was amazing, some of the best pizza I had in the south at the time. Recently I noticed they had an actual restaurant so I stopped in to check out the me u and have some of that great pizza I remembered. I was very disappointed when I got home and opened the boxes. I got a mootz and buffalo chicken pie. Both burnt, crust as thin as a crepe and little cheese. I also ordered 6 boneless wings, which ended up being bone-in. Very little sauce on the wings but they tasted good. I’m not sure if it was due to someone else cooking tonight but overall I am very disappointed. I had been really looking forward to the great pizza I remembered from the food truck.
… moreShelby Dreyer
I’ve been meaning to try this place out for a while, but finally made it in last week. My kids have been asking to go back every. Single. Day. That definitely means something.
I love all of the different options, and the crust texture is perfect. The pizzas were also bigger than we expected (we assumed personal size), which is a good thing
… moreRobert Roberts
I was fortunate enough to attend a soft opening at Yankee Pie Apizza and I must say…WOW! I tried 6 different pies and I could not say a bad thing about any of them. It was all soooo good. I had the Original Clam, Cristen’s Special, Hawaiian, White, Pepperoni, and the Italian Bomb. My personal recommendation would be the Original Clam or the Cristen’s Special. They all have just the right amount of cheese and sauce made with fresh ingredients. The amount of char (it’s not burnt!) on the thin crust was perfect for just the right amount of crisp. There is a family pavilion area with picnic tables, fire pits, an inflatable movie screen, and corn hole with lights so you can play at night. This place is going to change the entire dynamic of Downtown St Marys for family time. Bring lawn chairs (or blankets), order a pie, or better yet 4 (you’ll thank me later)…and take a seat to enjoy a family movie on the big screen 7 nights a week! You can’t beat it. Much success to Jeremy, his family, and his team!
… moreMitch Blyler
Yankee Pie Apizza in downtown St. Marys is more than just a pizza place—it’s a community hub. The owner, Jeremy, is passionate about collaboration and supporting local businesses and nonprofits. The pizza is delicious, with perfectly charred crust and fresh toppings. My favorites are the Meatball Sub and the BBQ Chicken Pizza. Beyond great food, Jeremy regularly partners with other businesses to host events and sponsors community programs. Yankee Pie Apizza is a real asset to Camden County and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for both a great meal and a way to support the local community!
… moreJoDanna Castle
We stumbled upon this place while walking around town. We dined in and witnessed several pick up orders. They were quite busy and the workers were very efficient and all had excellent customer service and worked as a team. We had Lucy’s jalapeno popper pie. Loved it!!! We will definitely be returning to try more pies!! The crispiness, char, and flavors were spot on! This is a casual dining atmosphere of order at the counter. Not restaurant style dining.
… moreJohn & Mandy
This place has such an AMAZING, unique style of pizza!! Unlike ANYTHING I’ve tried before. But then I’ve never been to New Haven, CT. The owners have brought a slice of home to the deep south. And boy am I glad they did! Yankee pie combines all of my favorite aspects of pizza in a perfect size, thickness and quality. Wonderful pizza recipes with top notch quality toppings. Have already frequented and will frequent again. There’s a reason there’s a line. Who wants to go to a pizza place where nobody’s there?
… moreNoche
Awesome New Haven style pizza with a local feel! The flavors are amazing. All the ingredients taste fresh and the combinations are great. I highly recommend the Italian Bomb. Downtown St Mary’s definitely needed this place. They are currently utilizing a food truck while the restaurant is being built, be ready for a wait though if the ovens get backed up but it’s totally worth the wait. When the main kitchen is completed they’ll have more oven space. I love that they are using the old post office and are planning on keeping the stone wall in the interior that I remember seeing as a kid while going to pick up mail with my grandparents. Owners and staff seem very friendly. Atmosphere is fun and inviting. I’m looking forward to enjoying this place for years to come.
… moreJon Dewar
Great pizza and staff! We order pizzas here just about every week. St Marys really needed this! Give them a try, you’ll be glad you did!
… moreTiffany DeMeritt
We love Yankee Pie Apizza!! Our favorite is the Italian Bomb!! Also I had a two topping pie with Pepperoni and bacon! YUM! It’s in the perfect location of downtown St. Mary’s at the waterfront with a great family atmosphere. All of the staff have been super friendly! Go get some asap!! You won’t be disappointed!
… more