Stephanie Davidson
I’ve eaten here twice now while visiting Fort Collins. The young guys who have helped have been super friendly both times. I have tried the Lost Creek and Trailhead sandwiches. The toppings have been fresh and the bread is so soft. There is a good vibe to the restaurant. I will be back again! I definitely recommend eating here, if you are a sandwich lover, like myself.
… moreL A
I’m sad to leave a one star review, however, i struggle with ARFID and previously ordered the pilgrim sandwich as a go to safe food here. Despite the sandwich being a popular selection they have completely removed it as an option from their menu. I am bummed because now I won’t be back to eat here, the removal just felt so random.
… moreJacob Daniels
Edit: I improved my rating to 3 stars to reflect the refund I received for the pictured sandwich. Did not interact with the employees much when picking up my order, but the service of whoever is monitoring reviews is great!
Original review:
I like arugula, but the sandwich was 90% arugula; I could not taste a single other thing. It’s really not great, especially for the price.
… moreLorenzo R. C
Really great sandwiches and soups. Hearty amount of meat, with fresh vegetables, avocado and honey Dijon mustard. The tomato bisque was outstanding. Even the restroom were very clean and well kept. Definitely worth trying
… moreAbigail Crawford
Great service and great food! The staff was very friendly and helpful. We split a Cuban and I wish I had gotten a whole with how yummy it was. Great first impression and will be back!
… moreShawn Cumpston
Very good sandwich! 8 had the Ridgeline without the garlic mayo. Yummy! Quality ingredients and great bread. Not that spongy Sub*** stuff. Definitely will be back!
… moreJaclyn Pickard
Update:
After writing this review, I did receive notice of a refund. While I did not expect a full refund, this was a very nice gesture. Adding one star for customer service response. Thank you.
————–
Employees were super helpful and nice. Not busy.
We got two sandwiches and a cookie – like $40, so expensive. They were fine, nothing special
Issue here was we added turkey for $4 to the veg wrap, left and drove towards towards denver, opened the sandwich and womp, no turkey in sight. Too far to go back. I emailed immediately explaining the issue and never got a response.
… morePreston Humphries
Friendly service and chill atmosphere! Food was ready quick and tasted delicious as always! My favorite sandwich shop when visiting Colorado!
… moreLori Feig-Sandoval
There’s one cold sandwich and one hot sandwich which they list as vegetarian. Under the protein options it just says $9.95, so I asked what the protein was and he said oh we don’t have one. We just do veggies. Today they were out of the hot one which is roasted eggplant. Okay so then my husband ordered a vegetarian that was just basically a bunch of garden vegetables and now we’re going to have to take it home to eat it because it had no flavor so my husband will have to doctor it up. There was no salt or pepper no olive oil or vinegar, no mustard, no seasonings. BORING, but still $11.00. Well we hope they will do better at some point. I remember now why I have never walked into the Yampa in Old Town, which is just a few blocks from my house.
… moreAlexander Turner
Absolutely obsessed with this place. I have usually just door dashed and decided to pop in the 4020 a college location and had an outstanding customer service experience. Emery provided excellent customer service and I am for sure going to pickup/eat in person at this location moving forward. Highly recommend the pilgrim!
… more