Hours
| Monday | 9 AM–12 PM, 4–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 9 AM–12 PM, 4–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 9 AM–12 PM, 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 9 AM–12 PM, 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 9 AM–12 PM, 3–9 PM |
| Saturday | 3–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 7639 Southeastern Ave Suite B, Indianapolis, IN 46239
Phone: (317) 862-2960
Website: http://www.xtrordinary-pizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Xtrordinary Pizza
Click on the “MENU” button above to be taken directly to the menu, or find it located in the top corner! … Be sure to Follow Us on Facebook and share photos of …
Menu – Xtrordinary Pizza
Specialty Pizzas! *Pizza sizes listed above*. Meatlovers Pizza … Xtrordinary Pizza(317) 862-29607639 Southeastern Ave Suite B, Indianapolis …
Xtrordinary Pizza | Indianapolis IN – Facebook
Xtrordinary Pizza is the best pizza in town—everyone knows that. What they didn’t always know was where to find it. Now? There’s no missing it!
Reviews
Mitchell Lewandowski
if you have the munchies this is the place! We got a pizza that was piled high with toppings just like they say we got a pizza bowl that was really delicious got a BLT which has lots of bacon very good and rib tips and their barbecue sauce is a real nice! there is three of us eating it and we still have leftovers the fellas in there real cool and if you’ve never been there just pull in that parking lot it’s in the back definitely must try place if you’ve never tried it
… moreErica Haymon
Absolutely amazing. Me and my husband had been hearing about this pizza and we decided to take the drive and see for ourselves. We were NOT disappointed! DEFINITELY RECOMMEND!!!!!
… morePatricia Stewart
When I say we ate a quality pizza fully loaded delicious pizza had some left over and the taste didn’t change.We order 2 mediums. Should’ve took pictures before hand,but our stomach was touching our backs..lol you see all those ingredients yummy
… moreRichard Martin
Indies hidden treasure of Southeastern’s extraordinary pizza parlor the pizza is very good. Everybody knows it on that side of town more people should know about this pizza parlor very hearty toppings extra cheese, they’re giving the popular pizza parlors in Indy a run for their money. In my opinion extraordinary pizza got them all BEAT !!! highly recommended pizza parlor for all occasions take out and delivery only so when you get YOUR ORDER HOME , you’re home becomes an extraordinary pizza parlor right there at home sign very satisfied new Indianapolis customer enjoy Praise Jesus . Great job. I’ll definitely be back. ✌
… moreShawn IsHere
First time trying this little carry out spot while visiting family. Tried it because of many good reviews. I don’t get it. It wasn’t bad but just below average to me. The immediate locals must not have any other spots to get pizza or just haven’t ventured out. ♂️ We hade a sausage and mushroom and a pepperoni pizza…both ordered for pickup. Think very cheesy and greasy without much flavor. LOTS of cheese! They didn’t warn me about the grease and it leaked out of the box on my truck seats from only a 1.5 mile drive. No biggy, cleaned it up. You should just be aware though to bring a bag or something to wrap the pizzas to prevent from happening to you. Also, they only make them one way…no thin crust available. Lastly, got some of their wings as well. Decent wings but the sauce comes on the side and not baked in. This place appears to be a family side hustle, the building did not seem well kept inside with water on the floor of the lobby and potholes in the parking lot. I didn’t feel love for pizza and customers when I went there.
PS They also don’t have blue cheese for wing dipping as well. ♂️ To be honest, I guess I’ll stick to Jockamos, Brozinnis or Big Woods…don’t like being disappointed with my pizza. ☹️ I actually feel even Papa John’s is better than this place.
… morePS They also don’t have blue cheese for wing dipping as well. ♂️ To be honest, I guess I’ll stick to Jockamos, Brozinnis or Big Woods…don’t like being disappointed with my pizza. ☹️ I actually feel even Papa John’s is better than this place.
Aaron Ward
By far one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. 5 out of 5 stars. Great owners, staff, and customer satisfaction
… moreJon Stephens
The pizza is good, but not worth the owners threats. I have gotten pizza here for years. They posted on their Facebook page that they are taking orders until 6 pm tonight (new years eve). I showed up to order at about 5:15 and they said they weren’t taking anymore orders. I said I thought you were taking orders till 6, I guess I won’t be coming back here anymore. As I was walking out the fat brother ( this place is owned by 2 brothers) decided to start cussing and threatening me. Completely unprofessional. I will definitely not be going back now. This dude is seriously unhinged.
… moreAllen Munden
Went and got a “Take and Bake” from them and I have a lot to say. First, the pizza was very heavy piled high with toppings and cheese. Second Great price!!!! Third, very friendly staff!!! The only thing I can say that they should change??? Put your sign out front, I almost went right past it. This pizza place is a must and I will be coming back for more. Oh, almost forgot to say this, the3 pizza was FIRE! The BOMB!!!
… moreLinda Hudson
So, we drove approx 45mins to get pizza from Xtrordinary Pizza. According to there website page, their hours are 9:00-12:00; closes at 12:00 and reopens around dinner. I even called before we made the 40min journey and spoke to a man who confirmed the hours of operation. We get there at approx 11:15 and there was a “CLOSED” sign in the window. So me, thinking they had forgotten to turn it off, went to the door and some man appeared and said “we’re not open”. I said “I called and confirmed the hours with some man on the phone”. He said “nobody’s here”. All the while me being scared to get out of the car because there was a van in a parking spot next to where we parked, with the window down and a dog that looked like the size of an elephant, glaring at us.
We had saw the pizza online and it looked so DELICIOUS which is why we made the 40min drive. NEVER AGAIN!
So, we drove clear to the opposite side of indy to Roselli’s Pizza and enjoyed their buffet, all you can eat pizza, pasta, salad & drink for $15!!!……WELL WORTH THE DRIVE!
… moreWe had saw the pizza online and it looked so DELICIOUS which is why we made the 40min drive. NEVER AGAIN!
So, we drove clear to the opposite side of indy to Roselli’s Pizza and enjoyed their buffet, all you can eat pizza, pasta, salad & drink for $15!!!……WELL WORTH THE DRIVE!
michael day
First time coming here the parking lot is very small but the pizza is great loaded with lots of toppings and the 2 women that served me was very nice
… more