M Capone
This had become our favorite place for pizza… Especially the deep dish… EXCEPT TONIGHT. Man, after several great pizzas… We got a completely awful one. Had DD deliver a medium cheese and sausage deep dish, and I can’t even get more than a $5 credit for a completely undercooked pizza…. Cold in the middle… Cheese not melted… Barely any sauce on top… And the worst part is the raw sausage. We are microwaving the pizza just to make it barely edible. Really bummed out. Will give them another chance down the road… But this is bad tonight. Not sure if they have someone new cooking and they pulled it way too soon. Stuffed pizza needs more time to cook!!! Definitely the fault of the kitchen… DD drive straight here.
… morePaul Lale
Well, the 2 pizzas were burned and terrible tasting and loaded waffle fries were terrible for $60 dollars. The only good thing was the fried zucchini. If you get it togo then I highly recommend you check it before you leave. If this food wasn’t for others then I definitely would had taken this food back and get a refund. So, they are very lucky. I won’t be coming back.
… moreGeorge Frederick
Good bar pizza
Wasn’t prepared for the heavy metal on the jukebox. And I like heavy metal. We’re definitely in a bar no silverware and paper plates
… moreSamantha Sheppard
My family had windy city pizza for the first time yesterday and it was delicious! We got the special for a large pizza,wings and garlic bread pizza! Everything was perfect! Definitely will be returning!
… moreJessica Smith
Hands down one of the best pizza and wings we’ve had in a very long time!!! This has become our new favorite place!!!
… moreDean Natelborg
I’ve been here twice now, the pizza was excellent both times! The watresses we had were very nice but very unattentive and the service was very…. slow both times.First time I went it was very loud , but the watress was able to turn down the speaker down near us after the second time we asked, the second time I went with my wife on a Saturday afternoon around 3, the radio was on but not to loud, very pleasant for eating in a bar atmosphere but like I said before, food is excellent, service needs to step it up a couple notches! Worth trying for the pizza ! Hopefully the watresses will get their act together !
… moreWayne Bush
Great stuffed pizza and cool little bar. Definitely will stop back in!
… moreMichael Borozan
We tried Windy City for the first time tonight, we were impressed with our pie. We had the Sicilian crust pie, they did not skip on the ingredients. We will definitely order from them again.
… moreKay Jones
The pizza is always hot and delicious. Wings are great too. Never had a bad experience. The bartenders are all friendly and helpful.
… moreMarc M
5 star! Sicilian pizza is amazing. Old school NW indiana pizza. No one in the area makes a Sicilian pizza anymore, except HERE ! Hidden place inside the bar. All the food is pretty amazing.
… more