Sue Anne Redman
I had the Ceasar Salad with Chicken, it was fantastic! Alongside my salad I had a glass of Malbec, a superb compliment to my meal. My friend, who has been to Willow Creek many times, had her favorite, the Pulled Pork Sandwich. She was disappointed that they did not have their, delicious, homemade, sour dough bread for an appetizer. Something I can look forward to next time! For dessert, upon the waiters recommendation, as his favorite dessert, we shard the homemade Bread Pudding. It did not disappoint! One of the best I have ever had! The hot water was not working on their coffee maker, but that did not detour our waiter, he offered an espresso shot and I asked if he could make us Americanos, and he more than happily made 2, and they were super satisfying after such an amazing meal! There will definitely be a next time! I look forward to enjoying the cozy indoor seating, as we sat on the beautiful patio for lunch.
… moreKimberly Barnett
Excellent experience. Beautiful day so we sat on the patio, which is right across the street from the lake. The lemon drop martini was on point. The oven was broke so we did not get to enjoy bread service but will definitely check that box next time we come. Shout out to Miles for great service and a fun lunch.
… moreDudley Callison
This was a special birthday meal for our family of five. The reservation was easy and the table was ready for us. The atmosphere is 5-star, for sure. I’ve dined on the patio in warmer months and you can’t beat the view overlooking Evergreen reservoir. From the time we sat down, it took a full hour to bring out our food. No explanation offered, especially as to why the table for four next to were seated after us, ate appetizers and finished their meal before our plates came out. Our burgers were way overcooked and the bacon so overcooked that the meal tasted charred. Oddly, the fries with the Brie sandwich were cold, so not sure what was going on in the kitchen. The clam chowder soup was excellent, clearly the best part of the meal. At $150 for five of us, the food was a huge disappointment. Surely something was amiss yesterday. I’ll gladly amend my low rating if it’s a better experience next time, if we go back now.
… moreWilliam Wosilius
We LOVE Willow Creek! Ambiance is amazing being right on the lake, and the food is fantastic. We love that they employ local young people – they get the customer service mantra! Their new bartender (I think his name is Hunter) is phenomenal!
… moreJay
Food here is amazing. Atmosphere right by the lake is fantastic. Price is getting rough though. Valentine’s 2026 was over $400 for 2 people that each had 2 mixers. We have been going here at least 1-2 times/year, for 10+ years, but that tradition might be coming to a close with inflation hitting so hard. );
… moreAlan Wang
Returned to Evergreen to visit old stomping grounds (Class of ’88) and hang out with dear friends. The food and service at Willow Creek were phenomenal! Dining outside with a picturesque sunset (and moonrise) along with the sounds of hummingbirds (and eagles) didn’t hurt! Love this place and hope to return soon! Highly recommend!
… moreKeren Aspen Wallace
Had dinner here with a friend and the atmosphere is very nice. The first course which was a salad came out and it was delicious. I was so excited for the next course but was extremely disappointed. I ordered the ravioli which the waitress told us that this appetizer could be shared with multiple people. There were only 3 raviolis which I was completely surprised by and the pasta dough was not cooked all the way through. I can’t believe that I paid $25 for just 3 raviolis. I wish the food was better and there was more of it.
… moreSergey coma
We recently visited Willow Creek and were absolutely delighted! The atmosphere in the restaurant is wonderful, with a beautiful view from the window that adds a special charm to the dining experience. The staff was very attentive, and the service was top-notch. We were especially pleased with the extensive wine selection and excellent food. Every moment spent here was truly enjoyable! We’ll definitely be back!
… moreAshly Ulrich
Gorgeous restaurant overlooking the lake. Delicious menu! We enjoyed a lovely brunch by the lake!
There was a line before they even opened, so I would recommend making a reservation if you’d like to get brunch, especially on a weekend. The bruch specials were perfect for fall!
Thanks so much!
… moreDavid Barry
This place is a true gem. Rustic, Colorado-like atmosphere overlooking Evergreen Lake.
Food was delicious. Jake, our server, was informative, helpful and fun.
The wine list was a real surprise, great variety and quality at very reasonable prices. We also recommended the dessert drinks!
We plan to make this a regular stop, even with the hour drive from Castle Rock.
… more