Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1110 White St, Key West, FL 33040
Phone: (305) 735-4449
Website: http://whitestreetpizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
White Street Pizza
White Pizza 12 Inch Pie ; Prosciutto Pizza · $25.00 ; BROCCOLINI WITH SAUSAGE · $24.00 ; Key West Shrimp Pizza · $26.00 ; Spinach Pizza · $23.00 ; Chicken Pizza · $24.00.
White Street Pizza | Key West FL – Facebook
1102 White St, Key West, FL, United States, Florida 3… 26 people interested.
Book Your White Street Pizza Reservation Now on Resy
White Street Pizza. 5.0. (16) reviews. Italian … Possibly the finest in paradise. White Street Pizza. 1110 White Street. Key West, FL 33040.
Last Updates
Reviews
Lisa Morency
Great vibe…reminds me of the old Chevy’s back home in Lowell, MA. Best pizza and meatballs. The chocolate salted key lime pie was bursting with a variety of flavors making it a nice blend. Our server, Jen was so helpful with recommendations and provided outstanding service in a welcoming, friendly manner.
… moreMike Harder
Wow! I have been visiting regularly for 15 pkus years and this is by far the BEST pizza in Key West!
All homemade, great ingredients. Excellent service. I got my order to go, even a custom printed pizza box! Very nice inside if you want to sit down and have a meal also!
Do not pass this hidden gem up!
… moreAll homemade, great ingredients. Excellent service. I got my order to go, even a custom printed pizza box! Very nice inside if you want to sit down and have a meal also!
Do not pass this hidden gem up!
John Glynn
Great pizza. Great service.
Went last night and had Danika as our server. She was dynamite: attentive, funny, responsive, kind.
The pizza is a super thin crust with a healthy, larger crispy edge. Us three dinners were from Boston, Chicago and NYC (pretty good pizza cities … wink!) and we were impressed.
Fun fact: We went on the day Neil Sedaka died. Funny enough they had a bunch of Neil Diamond photos up on the walls. Neil S. and Neil D. grew up across the street from each other.
… moreWent last night and had Danika as our server. She was dynamite: attentive, funny, responsive, kind.
The pizza is a super thin crust with a healthy, larger crispy edge. Us three dinners were from Boston, Chicago and NYC (pretty good pizza cities … wink!) and we were impressed.
Fun fact: We went on the day Neil Sedaka died. Funny enough they had a bunch of Neil Diamond photos up on the walls. Neil S. and Neil D. grew up across the street from each other.
Bradi Hanrahan
We stopped for the 1st time tonight and had the Margarita & Pepperoni pizzas Delicious!!! And OMG the key lime pie!!! Do yourself a favor and get the pie Danica was or server and she was great! Highly recommend this restaurant. We will be back again soon.
… moreRobin Hattaway
We had to try a few things to give a proper review
The meatballs are to die for ! Get your own order because you won’t want to share. Tiramisu also scrumptious ! We had the key lime pie & a sausage and mushroom pizza. The crust was thin, just the way I like it.
10 out of 10.
… moreThe meatballs are to die for ! Get your own order because you won’t want to share. Tiramisu also scrumptious ! We had the key lime pie & a sausage and mushroom pizza. The crust was thin, just the way I like it.
10 out of 10.
Katherine Bernardi
What a wonderful place with great food and amazing service!
Happy hour is a must from 5pm-6pm offering half off appetizers, salads and wine! just got home from Italy a few weeks ago and felt like I never left. My mom and I decided to grab 4 appetizers to share while my fiancé went for the simple yet delicious pepperoni pizza (you just can’t go wrong) my favorite was the Marinated Beef Tips while my mom loved the Grilled Watermelon Salad . Definitely a new hidden gem!
… moreHappy hour is a must from 5pm-6pm offering half off appetizers, salads and wine! just got home from Italy a few weeks ago and felt like I never left. My mom and I decided to grab 4 appetizers to share while my fiancé went for the simple yet delicious pepperoni pizza (you just can’t go wrong) my favorite was the Marinated Beef Tips while my mom loved the Grilled Watermelon Salad . Definitely a new hidden gem!
Camilo
The pizza was alright. But they’ve taken a strong stance against offering some basic ingredients like pineapple, bacon strips, and ham. As a Hawaiian pizza lover, offering pineapple on pizza is a dealbreaker if I’m to return. They also don’t have chicken wings
… moreLisa Grabowski
The food is fresh and flavorful!! Service is attentive and friendly. Definitely try the happy hour between 4pm and 6pm. The meatballs are a standout!! Don’t forget the chocolate key lime pie for dessert!!
… moreMarcia Teal
So good! Reasonable prices for very good food. We had the meatballs, sausage/pepperoni red pizza, chocolate key lime pie and tiramisu. The tiramisu was huge. Did I mention the food was so good? Highly recommend.
… moreShawn Flaming
This is a great little spot off the beaten path. From the time you enter you get the feeling of cozy small family owned restaurant. We loved the ambiance with comfortable booths.
Very good service from the two young gentleman working there. Gave us an idea of the menu and what some of their more popular items were. Also informed us of the Happy Hour specials which was 50% off wine and pizza. What a great deal. My wife ordered the Sauvignon blanc which was a perfect pairing with the food we got.
We went with the mushroom pizza but I could recommend any of their pizza, I’m sure they won’t disappoint. The beef tips were good but my favorite was their Roasted Brussels & Cauliflower.
We will definitely be going back there and looking forward to trying new items.
… moreVery good service from the two young gentleman working there. Gave us an idea of the menu and what some of their more popular items were. Also informed us of the Happy Hour specials which was 50% off wine and pizza. What a great deal. My wife ordered the Sauvignon blanc which was a perfect pairing with the food we got.
We went with the mushroom pizza but I could recommend any of their pizza, I’m sure they won’t disappoint. The beef tips were good but my favorite was their Roasted Brussels & Cauliflower.
We will definitely be going back there and looking forward to trying new items.