Social Profile: 
… View more
When Cheese Met Cake isn’t just a bakery, it’s where New York–style tradition meets Indiana-grown heart. Every cheesecake is baked low and slow for a start to finish process that takes 16 hours, crafted with the finest name-brand ingredients, and served fresh in over 200 rotating flavors. From classic favorites to creative seasonal pairings, our display case changes daily so there’s always something new to discover. Located in Greenwood and proudly serving the greater Indianapolis area, we specialize in luxury cheesecakes by the slice, whole cakes for events and weddings, and custom creations for your restaurant’s menu. Stop by and see why When Cheese Met Cake is becoming Indiana’s go-to destination for cheesecake lovers near and far!
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–5 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–6 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–6 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–2 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 200 S Emerson Ave suite b, Greenwood, IN 46143
Phone: (317) 851-9906
Website: http://whencheesemetcake.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
When Cheese Met Cake: Home
Ready to Indulge · Bakery News: · Grab and Go Items In Store Only · Customer Favorites · Hours & Location 200 S Emerson Ave Ste B Greenwood, IN 46143 317-851-9906
When Cheese Met Cake | Greenwood IN – Facebook
Weigh and Package Fresh Peanut Butter Fudge with me Available in the Bakery in 1/2 pound increments. 200 S Emerson Ave Ste B Greenwood IN 46143 We are open …
When Cheese Met Cake (@whencheesemetcake) – Instagram
Local Indy Bakery Specializing in Fresh Baked NY Style Cheesecake and many other made from scratch desserts. Follow us for our daily rotating menu!!
Last Updates
Reviews
John Devore
Very friendly and welcoming staff! So many delicious options for anyone who loves cheese cake. Definitely have to revisit to try more things!
… moreLyn
We come by here every time we are in the neighborhood. and we aren’t even huge cheesecake fans. But, her cookies, her brownies and yes, even her cheesecake is amazing!!
I have always enjoyed the stuffed chocolate chip cookies and the brownies. This time we tried the Zesty Blueberry Lemon Bar and it was terrific!! Definitely worth the stop, we’ll be back!!
… moreI have always enjoyed the stuffed chocolate chip cookies and the brownies. This time we tried the Zesty Blueberry Lemon Bar and it was terrific!! Definitely worth the stop, we’ll be back!!
Derick Wilson
I have nothing but EXCELLENT things to say about When Cheese Met Cake. I ordered a large basket/box for Valentines Day. This came with 6 mini cheesecakes (flavors I could choose) 6 chocolate chip cookies, 6 chocolate covered strawberries, and a box double chocolate brownie bites. While there I also ordered a slice of plain cheesecake with strawberry topping on the side and a cookies and cream cookie sandwich. Everything was amazing. The plain slice had to be one of the creamiest cheesecakes I’ve ever tasted. It was so good. I want to say that it’s a bit pricier than other places might be but I can ASSURE you the quality of the products and the taste completely JUSTIFY the pricing. Absolutely everything I bought that day was delicious. If you’ve never given this place a try….why haven’t you? I definitely will be going back. Good service, good people and fabulous treats!
… moreSaydee Riley
Man oh man! Follow their social media page daily (there always updating it for customers) & Finally got to get this for my husband! We’ve been dying to try it & let me just say we COMPLETLY understand the hype! First walking in was greeted instantly which took my anxiety away, Danielle & the lovely lady working with her were super friendly & it was super easy to order! Such a Beautiful Bakery! My husband LOVED the peice of NY style pineapple upside down cake! It was so Good!! We will deff be back!
… morePlz 1000 subs
Came in for my son’s birthday last minute because he was sick until that morning. I ended up doing the cheesecake cupcakes so cute!!! She added some delicious strawberry compote to the 6 plain ones they had. The owner was super nice so was her worker! These were so Devine we will definitely be coming back soon!!!
… moreWarren Storie
If I was deathly allergic to cream cheese and was on my deathbed, my last wish would be to consume the very cakes made in this shop.
As an avid connoisseur of the cheesecake arts, I came in with high expectations. They were not just met, but blown out of the water. Dani is absolutely magical with her craft, and she is so pleasant to chat with. The product here is so good that my fiancée had to point out that I completely demolished my slice without muttering a single word or even offering her a bite (oops).
… moreAs an avid connoisseur of the cheesecake arts, I came in with high expectations. They were not just met, but blown out of the water. Dani is absolutely magical with her craft, and she is so pleasant to chat with. The product here is so good that my fiancée had to point out that I completely demolished my slice without muttering a single word or even offering her a bite (oops).
Kasie Werner
My two favorite ladys. The best cheesecake place ever hands down. Gotta try cheese cake and all other goodies. So good!!
… moreTara Salazar
My daughter, grandson, and I try to visit here at least a couple of times a month. Each time, we pick out three to four different pieces of cheesecake to share and taste test, trying new flavors has become a special family tradition for us.
Last week, I had the pleasure of speaking with the owner and hearing her inspiring story about following her dream. It’s always a joy to support local businesses, especially when they offer something as exceptional as this place does. The cheesecake is truly the best I’ve ever had, and the hospitality makes every visit even more memorable.
This shop deserves to be considered a staple in Greenwood. If you’re ever in the area, I highly recommend stopping by and trying a few of the many amazing flavors they offer
… moreLast week, I had the pleasure of speaking with the owner and hearing her inspiring story about following her dream. It’s always a joy to support local businesses, especially when they offer something as exceptional as this place does. The cheesecake is truly the best I’ve ever had, and the hospitality makes every visit even more memorable.
This shop deserves to be considered a staple in Greenwood. If you’re ever in the area, I highly recommend stopping by and trying a few of the many amazing flavors they offer
Sheri C
OMG!! When Cheese Met Cake is my absolute favorite dessert spot! Cheesecake is to die for, and so many yummy options. The shop is spotless, and the staff are so sweet! Visit soon and often!
… moreKristen Fick
I tell everyone to go to When Cheese Met Cake. Just because you can see the quality in the photos. Let me tell you, this is THE REAL DEAL.
This is cheesecake the way cheesecake is meant to be: a rich and buttery crust with the super fine graham cracker crumbs. Dense but creamy cheesecake. Plus, a load of high quality toppings. The top edge of the cheesecake was perfectly golden. I got the Heath and it had the perfect amount of cronch… Not just a little dusting of Heath.
Dannielle is just lovely. She has a beautiful and sparkling clean establishment. TBH, the cheesecake is so good that I’d eat it out of a dumpster though.
15/10 I am obsessed.
… moreThis is cheesecake the way cheesecake is meant to be: a rich and buttery crust with the super fine graham cracker crumbs. Dense but creamy cheesecake. Plus, a load of high quality toppings. The top edge of the cheesecake was perfectly golden. I got the Heath and it had the perfect amount of cronch… Not just a little dusting of Heath.
Dannielle is just lovely. She has a beautiful and sparkling clean establishment. TBH, the cheesecake is so good that I’d eat it out of a dumpster though.
15/10 I am obsessed.