Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
We are a full service Waterfront Seafood Buffet. But we are not only seafood, we also offer Roast Beef, Pork, Chicken, Pastas and more. See Examples photos of our Buffet at Our Buffet offerings change frequently, so these are only examples, but many of them will remain the same. Reservations are also available online from our Website. Large Parties are always welcome, and we also offer Private Dining and Special Events (Banquets) for every occasion.
Huge seafood buffet offering 85 items ranging from raw bar selections to meat & poultry.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 83413 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Phone: (305) 664-4940
Website: https://rebrand.ly/whale-harbor
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
ABOUT | Whale Harbor Seafood
Discover some of the history of the Whale Harbor Restaurant (The Seafood Feast Buffet) … 83413 Overseas Highway, Islamorada FL 33036. tripadvisor logo · 305-664- …
Whale Harbor Seafood Feast – Restaurant – Facebook
We recommend reservations, but as always walk-ins are welcome too. Restaurant| Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet| Islamorada Florida. WHALEHARBORRESTAURANT.COM.
Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet – Restaurant in Islamorada
Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet serves delicious food in Islamorada. Huge seafood buffet offering 85 items ranging from raw bar selections to meat & poultry.
Reviews
harvey Business cards casa
I really don’t like leaving this bad review I really tried many of the different foods here and I have to be honest it was not very good.
The paella was not even close to a real paella . The fish choices where not fresh and tasteless. The cold shrimp two out of three where no deveined. The oysters look like they were chewed on before serving.
The flan desert terrible tasted like corn starch. The beef was completely raw see photos.
This is in my opinion not even close to what this place use to be. It’s basically a cheap Chinese buffet for a high price.
But at least at a Chinese buffet you get sushi and more options and hibachi for around $20 bucks.
This is just a tourist trap.
… moreThe paella was not even close to a real paella . The fish choices where not fresh and tasteless. The cold shrimp two out of three where no deveined. The oysters look like they were chewed on before serving.
The flan desert terrible tasted like corn starch. The beef was completely raw see photos.
This is in my opinion not even close to what this place use to be. It’s basically a cheap Chinese buffet for a high price.
But at least at a Chinese buffet you get sushi and more options and hibachi for around $20 bucks.
This is just a tourist trap.
Marlene RM
A girlfriend with some adventurous skills. She surprised me with a spontaneous Key West getaway, despite the threat of a storm brewing in the ocean! But she’s got some fishing skills – she reeled me in. And I’m glad I took the chance. No regrets – it was an unforgettable weekend! ️
… moreNic K
$40 per adult, $20 per child. $50 if you want to eat crabs. Lots of space, polite staff, fast service. I liked the food, 3-4 types of fish, everything was delicious, salads were excellent, desserts as everywhere. There was no sushi or I did not notice. I can definitely recommend it but a little expensive.
… moreuLtraTechx iPhone Repair R
This place used to be all you can eat crabs and now for additional $5 you get two claws. A total of $45 just for food per person. I’ve never felt more ripped off. When I used to love coming to this place as a kid.
… moreKarl Bedford
My family and I had dinner here on our way to key west for a weekend trip and had an awesome time. The seafood was fresh and delicious. The host was kind and professional. The staff were great too. Great view and good atmosphere. I’d love to go back next time I’m down there.
… moreG C
What a treat! This has to be must stop location whenever I would be back in the area.
How many buffets would you find with such a wide variety of seafood and some are locally caught! Also, usually buffets try to make it all about value and neglect other things like presentation or cleanliness. This place has both too! I’ve never been to a place that custom makes pasta as fancy as this with linguine (usually some Mongolian stir fry).
For as much as I can try in one sitting, all the food was tasty and fresh, top to bottom to the dessert (had key lime pie and chocolate cake). The only thing I didn’t finish was the one cube of pork that came with the yuca. It looked like it could be good and the way it’s supposed to be made, but for me it seemed too ordinary/non-tender and given the other choices I thought I shouldn’t waste precious stomach space! I also really liked the white fish in coconut sauce (looks yellow, like a lemon type sauce?). I think the white fish isn’t local though, but at least the mahi mahi and snapper is.
Jenn was an excellent server as well. Super friendly, personable, and even helped me get the dips for my seared tuna that I forgot!
The only negative I can think of is the AC was kind of strong when I got in. However, I sort of “warmed up” to it more throughout the meal as I ate more
The views were also nice here in this prime spot ️
I didn’t try the crab legs though as I’m not that much of a crab person
In summary, this place would be a main destination for me in the area, and other things more secondary! It definitely hit the spot for me for an end-of day filling and relaxing place!
… moreHow many buffets would you find with such a wide variety of seafood and some are locally caught! Also, usually buffets try to make it all about value and neglect other things like presentation or cleanliness. This place has both too! I’ve never been to a place that custom makes pasta as fancy as this with linguine (usually some Mongolian stir fry).
For as much as I can try in one sitting, all the food was tasty and fresh, top to bottom to the dessert (had key lime pie and chocolate cake). The only thing I didn’t finish was the one cube of pork that came with the yuca. It looked like it could be good and the way it’s supposed to be made, but for me it seemed too ordinary/non-tender and given the other choices I thought I shouldn’t waste precious stomach space! I also really liked the white fish in coconut sauce (looks yellow, like a lemon type sauce?). I think the white fish isn’t local though, but at least the mahi mahi and snapper is.
Jenn was an excellent server as well. Super friendly, personable, and even helped me get the dips for my seared tuna that I forgot!
The only negative I can think of is the AC was kind of strong when I got in. However, I sort of “warmed up” to it more throughout the meal as I ate more
The views were also nice here in this prime spot ️
I didn’t try the crab legs though as I’m not that much of a crab person
In summary, this place would be a main destination for me in the area, and other things more secondary! It definitely hit the spot for me for an end-of day filling and relaxing place!
Tony Robinson
I’ve had dreams about this place since I walked out the door the last time I was here. It has been a few years, and my only disappointment is that they now give you a ticket, good for one plate of crab legs. They no longer offer unlimited crab legs. This broke my heart, I have to admit!!! But the rest of the buffet is the same as I remember it. There is a nice, large selection of seafood to select from and lots of dessert selections. Parking is easy, convenient, and free, right out front. There is plenty of seating, usually walk-in ready. Reservations during really busy periods might be recommended. I always get water to drink, and with a tip of 20% ish it was $50. Money well spent in my opinion. The view is amazing, you are right on the ocean!!! I can’t wait to return.
UPDATE 5-7-2025 crab legs are now optional and extra!!
… moreUPDATE 5-7-2025 crab legs are now optional and extra!!
Sweet_Southern_Living
Beautiful views and friendly service, but the food was a letdown—especially for $120 for two.
My peel-n-eat shrimp and crab legs ($5 extra) were overcooked and dry. Mahi bites started off good, but the fresh batch tasted burnt.
My husband said the regular meats were decent, and the desserts were actually pretty good Sadly, the quality didn’t match the price. Disappointed overall.
➡️ Follow us on Socials for more detailed travel tips & restaurant reviews @ @Sweet_Southern_Living
… moreMy peel-n-eat shrimp and crab legs ($5 extra) were overcooked and dry. Mahi bites started off good, but the fresh batch tasted burnt.
My husband said the regular meats were decent, and the desserts were actually pretty good Sadly, the quality didn’t match the price. Disappointed overall.
➡️ Follow us on Socials for more detailed travel tips & restaurant reviews @ @Sweet_Southern_Living
Sarah Gallegos
Great atmosphere. Great food. And absolutely amazing service they were so friendly and accommodating.
… moreTim Ridge
Very nice! Right on the water! Beautiful views! Awesome fresh seafood both Hot & Cold! Best Ceviche around! They serve Pulled Pork & Beef as well!! Definitely on my list to go back next time!
… more