Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 112 S Main St, Eureka, IL 61530
Phone: (309) 304-1020
Website: http://wendypuff.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Wendy Puff Pizzeria + Pub
See our latest menu, find our hours, and order online directly from us. Locations in Eureka, IL.
Wendy Puff Pizzeria + Pub | Eureka IL – Facebook
We have room for 12 players – first come, first serve. No sign up or reservations required… just show up. WP Wednesdays will take off after dining room service …
Order Online – Wendy Puff Pizzeria + Pub
… not accepting online orders. Banner image. Wendy Puff Pizzeria + Pub 112 S Main St. 112 S Main St, Eureka, IL. Appetizer. Salad. Puffs. Dipping Sauces. Desserts …
Reviews
Holly C
Food was delicious! But the service was AMAZING! We are from out of town, so we weren’t aware reservations are strongly suggested on weekend days, but we are so glad we were able to sit at the bar. The bartender (I think Sofia was her name) was absolutely wonderful! She made us feel so welcome! She is very personable and that is very much appreciated for 2 out-of-towners! Thank you for great food and conversation!
… moreTroy Jones
This place was fantastic! We had 3 different pizzas, all were fantastic. The service/bar tender was super cool, great beer selection and decent bourbon choices as well. We will absolutely be returning.
… moreimweezle
My wife and I dined here last night, and we were blown away by the level of service, quality of food, decor, and pricing. We will definitely be back!
We traveled from Peoria to eat here, and it was worth the 30 minute trip. The design of the restaurant is beautiful, with exposed white brick walls, industrial hvac pipes, and some modern finishes.
We were immediately greeted upon entering the restaurant by the owner himself (which we later found out), and seated promptly. He visited us again to ask since this was our first time, if we had any questions. He’s a super friendly guy, and really was a pleasure to talk to.
We ordered two pizzas, which were made fresh from the exposed kitchen and brick-oven stove. One was a bit more adventurous featuring Italian deli-meats (Cappacola, etc.) and some hot peppers, and the other was a more traditional pepperoni with some upscale touches like Burrata and lemon zest. Both pizzas were excellent.
All said and done, we had two pizzas, a mocktail, and a gelato for dessert, and it was about $55. We felt like we got great value for our money, and we look forward to coming back soon!
… moreWe traveled from Peoria to eat here, and it was worth the 30 minute trip. The design of the restaurant is beautiful, with exposed white brick walls, industrial hvac pipes, and some modern finishes.
We were immediately greeted upon entering the restaurant by the owner himself (which we later found out), and seated promptly. He visited us again to ask since this was our first time, if we had any questions. He’s a super friendly guy, and really was a pleasure to talk to.
We ordered two pizzas, which were made fresh from the exposed kitchen and brick-oven stove. One was a bit more adventurous featuring Italian deli-meats (Cappacola, etc.) and some hot peppers, and the other was a more traditional pepperoni with some upscale touches like Burrata and lemon zest. Both pizzas were excellent.
All said and done, we had two pizzas, a mocktail, and a gelato for dessert, and it was about $55. We felt like we got great value for our money, and we look forward to coming back soon!
David Nordhielm
Eureka is lucky to have such a cool pizza spot. Pizza is great and service was great as well. Pizza came out in about 5 minutes.
… moreSteve Peterson
First time for us to Wendy Puff Pizzeria and we loved it! My wife is gluten and dairy free and the one itch she hasn’t been able to scratch is good pizza, so she was thrilled! We had vegan garlic puffs for an appetizer that were yummy too. The server and bartender were super friendly and helpful, and the interior is sharp as well. Reservations are recommended for dinner; we were lucky on Valentine’s Day and able to sit at the bar since we had not thought ahead. We will be going back!
… moreShan B
First time eating there and we ended up getting carry out as we had a gift card and we’re going to bring it home for our family. As I walked in, I was instantly greeted by multiple people with smiling faces, and just people that seem genuinely happy. I picked up two pizzas and the garlic knots as I was ready to leave. I accidentally dropped the garlic knots all over the floor. Apologizing profusely and picking up the garlic knots I ended up throwing them away and immediately the manager said we will make you new ones. It’s not every day where an accident happens like this and they just offered to make new ones with no extra charge. They didn’t have to do that but it just goes to show that this place cares and has great customer service. I got home and our food was absolutely delicious. Our favorite was the sausage plus pizza!!!! It was so yummy and the mozzarella cheese was to die for! We will definitely be back again. Thank you Wendy Puff!
… moreAnnie L.
We received a gift card for Wendy Puff over the holidays & were so excited to try this local pizza place!
The pizza is a thin crust that has a great puffed crust around the edge to hold on to. The menu is all pizzas (puffs) with a few salads & handful of appetizers, as well a full drink menu.
Each pizza feels elevated with the flavors fully thought out– no boring pizzas here! On the ‘Pedro the Elect’ the chicken meatballs were incredibly flavorful & the white bean chili reduction added a lovely depth to the pesto! We also had the ‘The Soppressata’ & ‘The Green Hornet’ pizzas.
There were gluten free crust & vegan cheese options available.
The staff was super friendly & happy to answer my questions/offer suggestions. One of the owners (2 brothers) checked in on our experience. It was great to meet him & share how delicious meal was!
Making a reservation is recommended because the restaurant is smaller & seating is limited, but there were a few seats available at the bar during both our visits.
Wendy Puff is worth the short drive from Peoria to Eureka & we will definitely be back!
… moreThe pizza is a thin crust that has a great puffed crust around the edge to hold on to. The menu is all pizzas (puffs) with a few salads & handful of appetizers, as well a full drink menu.
Each pizza feels elevated with the flavors fully thought out– no boring pizzas here! On the ‘Pedro the Elect’ the chicken meatballs were incredibly flavorful & the white bean chili reduction added a lovely depth to the pesto! We also had the ‘The Soppressata’ & ‘The Green Hornet’ pizzas.
There were gluten free crust & vegan cheese options available.
The staff was super friendly & happy to answer my questions/offer suggestions. One of the owners (2 brothers) checked in on our experience. It was great to meet him & share how delicious meal was!
Making a reservation is recommended because the restaurant is smaller & seating is limited, but there were a few seats available at the bar during both our visits.
Wendy Puff is worth the short drive from Peoria to Eureka & we will definitely be back!
Natasha Zinda
Went here for our 9th anniversary! We loved the entire experience the owners clearly love and are passionate about what they do. We were a lol disappointed they were so busy some of the items we came for were sold out but that’s a testament to their success. It’s always popping so make sure to make a reservation. If you are gluten free this us such a great option as it’s THE BEST gluten free pizza I’ve ever had. And calling them pizzas is selling it short these are artful flavors.
… moreJulie
If you want an amazing experience come here. The pizza is fire, no pun intended tended and they can do EVERYTHING GLUTEN FREE. The food is bar no. Some of the best. The drinks are fantastic and the staff make you feel welcome. We will come back again and again to support this business & our community! Don’t miss out come have an amazing time at Wendy Puff
… moreNakiel Horsley
Truly a breath of fresh air for central Illinois. We did a date night here. Went all out! Drinks, appetizers, salad, and pizza. Everything was high quality with flavor bursting in every bite. You must try. The ambiance was super cozy and surprisingly bustling for a Thursday night. Service was great! Can’t wait to go back. Even one of the owners came and chit chatted with us randomly. Loved the experience!!
… more