Jo Ann Rytel
Great bakery! You won’t be disappointed. Terrific donuts. Great rye bread. Order ahead to avoid being disappointed. Just got a neopolitan birthday cake that was awesome. Would recommend you give it a try.
… moreStephen Xanthos
We needed a birthday cake for my mother-in-laws 90th birthday celebration and my wife wanted to list all the names of her mom’s children, grandchildren and great grandchildren on the cake. We went to Waretown Bakery and they did an outstanding job decorating the cake and it was absolutely delicious.
… morebeth wittek
I ordered 4 dozen flower cupcakes for my daughter’s first birthday. They came out beautifully and were delicious. It was exactly what I wanted. The icing wasn’t too sweet which was great since there was so much of it in the designs! I’d definitely order from them again.
… moreMary Cervenak
This was my first time visiting the bakery, atmosphere was clean, adorable and busy. The service was excellent and friendly. The donuts were the best I ever had in Ocean County. The crumb cake was extremely moist and tasty. I highly recommend if you had already had the opportunity.
… moreJohn Hegarty
The donuts are great. There’s jelly in every bite of the jelly donuts. I brought their donuts to my other job location and now its a requirement when I go up there to stop for donuts first. My wife is a big fan of the cakes as well. Im almost hesitating revealing this gem of a bakery.
… moreDanielle Rullo
We ordered a cake for my sister’s birthday and Liz made an exact replica of our inspo picture! Not only was the cake beautiful and exactly what we wanted, it also tasted amazing. People at the party were asking where the cake was from because it was so good!! You can see the attached photos the inspiration cake compared to the one Liz made for us
… moreKendyll Wagner
I just visited this bakery with my program participants, and we had such a positive experience. One of my participants wanted a bagel but was short on money. Without hesitation, Danielle kindly purchased the bagel for him. Her compassion and generosity truly meant so much to us. Small acts like this make a huge difference, and we are incredibly appreciative. Danielle is amazing, and this bakery clearly has wonderful people working there. Highly recommend!!!! 🙂
Thank you again!
-Joey’s Quest Day Program
… moreKaren Philpot
Wonderful small bakery with delicious pastries, cakes and pies. We traveled to NJ over Thanksgiving holiday. While my server was filling my order I inquired with another woman whom was busy bringing cakes and pies out if I could get a buttered poppy seed roll. Because the shop is busy for holidays they usually don’t offer buttered seeded rolls on the menu. I explained to how I grew up in Jersey and miss the yummy poppy seed rolls since I can’t get them in my current state. She was wonderful and said it would be ok for my server to make one for me. I went back to our hotel and surprised my husband and we split the roll with a hot cup of coffee. It was wonderful ☕️. Thank you to the great employees at this establishment
… moreMarisa Stachelski, Realtor
As soon as we entered Waretown Bakery we were greeted with the happiest “good morning” and the biggest smile. The staff is always so friendly and welcoming! The food is delicious every time and the prices are great! When we were finishing up our order the woman offered my 6 year old a cookie for the road. What a sweet gesture! This bakery is everything old school feel and consistently amazing!
… moreGene Carey
I get the donuts for my family, and I drive all the way from Little egg harbor… Was disappointed the last time… Not much filling in the donuts this time which is a far cry from last time before that… Please, if it costs more then charge more .. Everyone loves a good donut… Not Dunkin
… more