Emily Laramy
Best lobster roll on the island bar none. First ate here in 2022 and was our first stop when we came back in 2025 & it’s just as great with its delicious Texas toast style bread and amazingly generous lobster portions. I got it twice in my week visit both hot and cold versions and loved them equally. WORTH THE PRICE! Get it with some Nantucket crisps, a crunchy soda or lemonade, and grab a bench to enjoy in front of the whaling museum while people watching!
… moreSe C
This was my first stop at Nantucket. I got to try the Reuben and a cold Lobster roll. The service was quick and easy.
The sandwiches both tasted great and it was like getting a nice intro to Nantucket. Small place with no seating. Just takeout only.
… moreRandy Smejkal
Had the Lobster Roll, cold w/ mayo. Enough said. This warm split top buttered roll with a cold generous amount of fresh lobster was amazing. We are on the island working the cold months & this was amazing!!! Can’t wait to be back in a couple weeks!! Oh, the God Father sub & the Meatball sub are delicious too!!! Can’t go wrong here!!!
… moreThomas Dudro
Excellent sandwiches (especially the Reuben) and might be the best lobster roll I had between Newport, Cuttyhunk, Martha’s Vineyard, and Nantucket. Would heartily recommend.
… moreJackie Levine
The lobster roll here is fantastic and full of lobster. I got it cold, but it is available hot or cold. The bun is warm on the ‘cold’ style. The watermelon juice is delicious and super refreshing on a hot summer day.
… moreWalter Hermenau
Visited Nantucket Friday. Checked menu at several places before selecting Walter’s Deli. Had the corn beef/pastrami Reuben. My favorite sandwich and I am a seafood guy. Fantastic and delicious!!! Generous portions and priced right. My wife had the roast beef sandwich. It was a hit as well. Person that made the sandwiches was a nice guy to boot.
Sat on a bench in front of a realtor’s office. Realtor asked me where I bought the Reuben because it looked so good.
… moreDana Denton
Walter’s fed us a few times when we were there this May. The hot Lobster roll was delicious. I also had the Rueben for the ferry ride home and everyone was jealous! And don’t forget to get a huge brownie, and do not share!
… moreSam
Delicious lobster roll I was very impressed. Warmed buttered roll with very very generous amounts of lobster salad. Highly highly recommend. And one of the best priced lobster rolls on Nantucket.
… morePeter Dawkins
There are many reasons to visit Cape Cod and its islands – one of them being the great food and fine dining. To my surprise my entire family agreed the best food on our visit were the sandwiches from Walter’s Deli. Coming from NYC we have high standards which Walter’s completely exceeded. The only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is that the counter lady didn’t give us napkins – even though I asked for some and she said they were in the bag. To the guy making the sandwiches- my compliments !
… moreBob Smith
Pastrami Reuben was excellent. Also had the Godfather which was very good. Just take out but that was fine for me. They do accept Apple Pay
… more