Christian Johnson
Completely in the conservation for the top twenty best pizzas in Connecticut. Finding a quality pie outside of New Haven or Fairfield County can prove difficult, this makes it easy especially for myself/those of us who live in the part of Connecticut that is closer to Rhode Island than to New Haven. Fantastic char, crisp, and texture on the dough with the sourdough pizza dough. The sauce is extremely flavorful and has a nice sweetness, which works very well with the fattier cheese (cheese to sauce ratio is fantastic). I would give the pizza an 8.6 on a 0-10 scale. Great service great food overall
… morecolin asby
The pizza here is off the chain, sourdough crust and top notch toppings made this one of the best pies I’ve ever had, I had fresh rosemary on my pepperoni just awesome, our waitress was very attentive
… moreChristopher Parker
Out of towners visiting and we were impressed! The staff was super friendly and made us feel welcome right away. The pizza was fresh, hot, and packed with flavor. You can tell they care about what they’re serving. Would recommend!
… morePatrice Gilbert
Came here for the Clam chowder. My husband was told its the best. They had just run out of it and we decided to try the pizza. The pizza was great. It’s better than Sally’s Apizza. The waiter was nice and super attentive. Glad we stayed for the pizza.
… moreKirk Engel
Although Vincitori’s pizza is a bit more expensive than some pizza restaurants in our area, their product is unbelievably good and a good value. This is our “go-to” restaurant for outstanding (New Haven style) pizza in our town. Their toppings are all incredibly fresh and delicious – no skimping here. Their “classic” pizza is our favorite and if you like garlic, their roasted garlic topping is fantastic. Mushrooms, jalapeno, spinach, and tomato sauce are all fresh and excellent. Salads are also very good. They also have table service and we hope to try some of their other dishes in the future. If you want the best pizza in Niantic/East Lyme, this is the place to go!
… moreMarilyn Arroyo
I’m giving a 3 star pizza it had good state however the crust supper flimsy and saggy making you have to chew a bit more than you would usually would. I’m used to eating a thin crust pizza that is crispy. The bottom was kind of burnt as well. I can’t rate the service nor atmosphere as this was a take out order.
… moreDuke Cook
Had a great experience tonight with another little gem of a restaurant in Niantic! Didn’t even know you could do a 50/50 pie until tonight. Food was fantastic and the atmosphere was even better. Friendly staff and super clean little place. Next time I’m here, I’m definitely coming back!
… moreTina S
We love eating at this pizza place in Niantic! It’s a cute little restaurant and it’s enjoyable to sit down and grab some delicious pizza! We always enjoy their garlic focaccia bread and their pepperoni pizza. Their pizza isn’t super greasy and love the nice chewiness of it! I also enjoy their house red that they offer. We tried the circa 1985 that was a special the other day and enjoyed that pizza too! The tiramisu for dessert was delicious too! Baked goods are okay. Service is always good too! I don’t think you can go wrong with any of their pizzas and a special dessert!
… moreBonnie Reynolds
Amazing pizza. And I’m not one to sing praises of pizza. We got the Vincitori and the meatball amore. Both excellent—the meatball amore was a standout. We also got the butternut squash arancini which was so so good, and my son had the seafood chowder which he said was really delicious. Highly recommend this place. I wish we lived closer.
… moreLauren Whitmore
Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!
Food: …
… more