Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
We are a family owned pizzeria/Italian eatery. We endeavor to offer the freshest ingredients to our patrons. Having a Silician heritage has made me passionate to creating delicious meals with a NY twist. Give us a try! Our thin style pizza and homemade bread baked daily will keep you wanting more.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 16520 S Tamiami Trl #148, Fort Myers, FL 33908
Phone: (239) 489-1115
Website: https://www.vincenzospastaria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Vincenzo’s Pastaria – Authentic NY Style Pizza in Fort Myers
Experience authentic NY style pizza at Vincenzo’s Pastaria in Fort Myers, FL. Visit us at 16520 S Tamiami Trail for delicious food and great service!
Vincenzo’s Pastaria | Fort Myers FL – Facebook
Vincenzo’s Pastaria is now on DoorDash! Your favorite New York–style pizzas, homemade pastas, and classic Italian dishes can now come straight to your …
Menu | Delicious Pizza at Vincenzo’s Pastaria
Four Lightly breaded eggplant filled with Ricotta and Mozzarella cheese topped with sauce. Chicken Tenders 10. 4 Pieces …
Reviews
Ricardo Jaramillo
Vicenzo’s Pastaria has a cozy, conventional vibe—it’s not massive, but it’s definitely comfortable enough. The staff is friendly, but you can tell they’re swamped with orders, which makes the service feel a bit impersonal. However, the pizza is the absolute highlight; the crust and ingredients are top-tier and seriously delicious (you can even see the steam in the photo!). Even though the menu is a bit limited, what they do offer is honestly fantastic.
… moreSWFL Broker Greg Demaras
A regular lunch stop for me. Their giant thin crust NY style pizza is a no-brainer for the on-the-go hungry SWFL business man. One day I will try one of their many other offerings, but honestly, it’s the classic pizza slice that draws me back time and again!
… moreSandra M
Fabulous pizza and salads! We had a take out order of 4 pizzas and 2 salads for a party. The pizzas were huge and delicious (a variety of toppings, I personally loved the Bel Caprese). The Antipasti salad was also large, had a generous helping of meat, and was so flavorful. Our favorite Italian restaurant for sure!
… moreMaria Behnke
What a great Italian/New York style pizza restaurant. If you don’t try this pizza you are missing out! We are frequent customers with our friends and everyone always just raves about the service and great food. Can’t say enough about it.
… moreChris Weiss
Changing from 5 stars to 2 stars.
After coming here for over ten years we got two bad pizzas in a row. Store manager said we would get a credit for the first one but we were never compensated in any way. We asked for extra sauce on the pizza and the manager poured a ladel full of sauce over our pizza after it came out of the oven. He was also rude over the phone. We won’t be back because they can’t make good pizza anymore. It looks like the new store manager is altering the pizza and ruining this places reputation. It went from great pizza to bad. What a shame.
… moreAfter coming here for over ten years we got two bad pizzas in a row. Store manager said we would get a credit for the first one but we were never compensated in any way. We asked for extra sauce on the pizza and the manager poured a ladel full of sauce over our pizza after it came out of the oven. He was also rude over the phone. We won’t be back because they can’t make good pizza anymore. It looks like the new store manager is altering the pizza and ruining this places reputation. It went from great pizza to bad. What a shame.
Fred D
I had the new York style pizza, it was excellent! Thin crust, nice chew, great sauce, plenty of toppings, As a matter of fact when I was there the table next to me complained there was too many toppings on their pizza .. never heard that before… mine was perfect though. I also had a house salad, fresh and appropriate size for the price. They serve beer and wine along with fountain drinks. Service was a little slow, only one waitress for the entire place, had to flag her down to get a drink refill but all in all a good experience here. I’ll be going back to try some of the other things on their menu. I do highly recommend the New York style pizza!
… moreJeff Barnes
Best Pizza in SWFL. This is real Brooklyn thin crust, NY style pizza. Nobody in town comes close. It’s like going home again to the old neighborhood and experiencing the best flavor in the world at the place you and your friends craved all week long. It hits so close to home they even have the old faux brick paneling my parents had in the basement. I haven’t tried the other menu items because I can’t wast a trip here without having pizza.
… moreJohn T
I finally found my pizza place. Absolutely delicious pizza at a good price. Everything tastes very fresh. The crust is perfect and with a really nice sauce. These are really nice people as well.
… moreSusan Bishop
I don’t know if they are under new management or have a new chef but the eggplant parm and hot sausage peppers and onions sub were totally subpar. I’ve been going here for 5 years and this was terrible. Could get as good food at Wawa. Never going back. Other places to spend my money
… moreGage and Marcia Rooney
Ordered pepperoni and ham and theire was virtually no ham!! Callled the manager and he said that is the way the owner asked him to serve it. Amazing how cheap the co wrings were and offered no concession. Took pictures and he declined to see them and referred to the owner. Won’t order from them again $26
… more