Raymond Suarez
This is like a Time Machine back in time what a environment pizza is unreal and the service is like no other grateful to have tried it and highly recommend it
… moreMaxine Lubow
The margherita pizza (5 star)was outstanding. Imagine my disappointment in the veggie pizza (1 star) when presenting it to my out of town
guests. The crust was soggy probably due to the frozen spinach packed on top. See the photo. Too much. Mama always said end with something nice. Service was great!
… moreTroy James
They don’t treat you like family, when you visit, you ARE family! Asked me what I wanted, made suggestions. Got a personal pan pizza that was fantastic. Fresh and delicious. Staff is wonderful, food matched. Will go again, and again, and again. Love this place!
… moreKing Mike
I ordered a JP chicken sandwich. The sandwich was really good. They were not cheap on cheese and added lots of peppers and onions. The only thing i would’ve liked if the chicken was a little juicer. The lady who took my order was very nice. I would go back to try other meals they have.
… moreTiffany Baez
Amazing cheesy pizza and the flavor as well. Really liked it . I drive 25mnts to go there , but it was worth it.
… moreJR
This establishment has the best pizza I have had in New York outside of nyc . There are many pizza restaurants in the Middletown area , but this is the best I have had yet , and it is amazing . The staff are friendly and welcoming too . I am never disappointed with their food or service!
… moreJames Falce
Excellent pizza here. Definitely the best in this town. Very nice family people running it too.The white pizza is our favorite.
… moreChristina Vega
I drive from Chester for this pizza! The best! They catered my engagement party and it was a hit. I had to have some today and i will definitely be ordering again. Worth the 13 minute drive!
… moreCoty Demers
If you are visiting LEGOLAND I highly recommend ordering for pickup. You can also eat there. Staff was very friendly and the pizza and homemade cannolis are AMAZING. The food at LEGOLAND is expensive and not very good. They are super close and delicious. They have the best Hawaiian pizza I’ve ever had. The chicken, bacon, ranch was also amazing!
… moreD D
Visiting from Chicago on a work trip. Googled pizza in the area and found this gem. Very Authentic. Tastes just like my moms home made pizza. Crust Is perfect. Super friendly Owners.
… more