Steve Bracciano
Update September 9:
Sadly I cannot recommend the pizza or bread sticks here any more. The pizza is inconsistent every time. This time it was too thin, had an insane amount of cheese and very little flavor or seasoning. The crust flavoring is too faint. Can’t taste or see much of it. I ordered bread sticks which were basically flat and crunchy. They were not the same as the last time. I had to throw them away. I’ve attached a picture for reference. You can see how inconsistent the quality is by looking at the bread stick pictures I’ve shared.
The customer service is top notch but the pizza is not.
Update May 6 2022:
The pizza was much improved last night. Toppings were plentyful and evenly distributed. Flavor was very good, seasoning has improved. The crust was a touch overdone but that is how I like my pizza. A touch crispy. The cheese ratio was spot on and not too thick. Bread sticks were very good as well. Good prices as well. Definitely recommend. Now I’d like to see a Detroit style deep dish pizza from here. Fingers crossed.
Good breadsticks and pizza is good as well but needs improvement. We ordered the veggie pizza. It had plenty of toppings on it. The cheese may have been a bit too thick in parts, drowning out the flavor. Could have used more sauce to cheese ratio. The pizza dough was OK. The crust was good and was flavored with parm garlic but I could not see anything on it, so a bit more would be better. The pizza flavor needs improvement. It needs seasoning. I just tasted cheese mostly. The breadsticks were perfectly seasoned and the dipping sauce (pizza sauce) was tasty.
… moreChristina Laming-Drennen
My brother and I both got a pizza. They were baked to perfection, the sauce wasn’t overpowering it was the right amount to have a delightful bite everytime. With the wide variety of toppings and flavor crust you’ll find the pizza your craving. My only complaint is I didn’t order the largest size.
… moreBrandy Wojtowicz
We’re local to Maybee Pizza Company and love supporting our local businesses. So far we’ve tried the Italian and Antipasto salad and was impressed with both salads. However, our favorite is the Italian salad – it’s packed with fresh greens, meat and cheese. So good! Their pizza is great and our personal favorites are the classic pepperoni and the Bacon cheddar ranch. You can can’t go wrong with their Cheese bread or their yummy calzones. Overall, we love Village Pizza Company!! Give them a try, you won’t regret it!
… moreJustin Burton
Happy to see another great pizza place open in Maybee! Got a couple large one toppers with a side of bread and was very impressed with the taste! Also, very friendly staff! Happy to say I can add this to the list of favorite local places to eat!
… moreAllen Lane
Meat lovers and CBR pizza was really good. We were impressed with the amount of meat. The village spin was disappointing, more dough than anything and no sauce that was ordered for it.
… moreEvan Smith
We had a pepperoni pizza that was very good. I’ll get it again with a salad.
… moreNickie Leach
We love their cheese bread. My bf was slightly underwhelmed with the sub. Stating the chicken itself was bland. But I know their pizza/cheesebread is phenomenal.
… moreCandie Mulligan
Absolutely top notch! Ingredients are fresh and great quality! The crust is simply amazing! The salad was GIANT and fresh! Employees were pleasant and friendly!
… moreKen H
Removing last review I hope. Think is was a first night issue tried again and this time it was a pretty good pizza no complaints nice turn around
… moreLori Nowitzke
Jethro has done it again. We think village pizza will be a BIG hit. The pizza was delicious!
… more