SONILA DAFKU
I had a great experience at this pizzeria. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and made with care.
But I have to specifically mention the Grandma Pizza it was absolutely delicious. The crust was perfectly crispy, the sauce was rich and well-balanced, and the cheese tasted amazing. You can really tell it’s made with quality ingredients and love.
The atmosphere is welcoming, and the food feels homemade, like real comfort food.
If you come here, don’t miss the Grandma Pizza it’s a must-try.
I will definitely be coming back and recommending this place to everybody
… moremelina
Good food with many choices on the menu. Everything we tried tasted really good and was well cooked. The place is clean and comfortable, and the staff is kind and helpful. Prices are fair for the quality. Overall a nice place to eat, and I would definitely go again.
… moreFani Petrou
A very nice pizzeria with a warm and friendly vibe. There are many food choices, so everyone can find something they like. The food tastes great and feels fresh. The staff is kind and welcoming, and the place is clean. Good prices and a great spot to enjoy a relaxed meal.
… moreBrooke Rings
Rating one star because I can’t rate any lower. I called to place my order and someone picked up the phone immediately, however all I heard was giggling and talking in the background while someone banged pots and pans together like they were in a band. Someone finally responds to me after I’ve said “Hello?” About 8 times. I honestly should have just hung up, as it would have saved me some pain and disappointment later. My boyfriend ordered chicken Alfredo and after the woman said they didn’t have what I wanted anymore I caved and got the same thing. We get there and they tell us it’s $47… for two Alfredo’s. Now I’d probably pay that for Alfredo at a really nice fancy restaurant, but this ain’t the place. Whatever we pay, we get in the car and drive home. As we open our Alfredo’s were met with noodles and freezer burnt chicken DRENCHED in oil with some separated Alfredo sauce. Ladies and gentlemen, children of all ages- I beg you NOT to order this meal because not only does it not taste good and literally taste like oil that has been sitting in a container, probably marinating for about a week. As I write this, my boyfriends butt cheeks are quivering over the porcelain throne, stomach churning, a wave of nausea washing over him as he clings onto the bathroom counter praying to god that the volcanic eruption that is happening ends soon. And I fear I may be this Alfredo’s next victim. The only thing good about this meal was the tiny side salad with the one tiny tomato, one cucumber and one tiny olive it came with. Luckily, with it being so terrible, we couldn’t eat much of it, so I hope this nightmare will be over soon for the sake of our bowels. We have two not even half eaten meals that I wouldn’t even feed to my chickens, going right in the garbage. I most likely will not be coming back here for the sake of my health. Now please excuse me, I have to bring my boyfriend more toilet paper.
… moreEric Helin
10/2/2025 My wife and I stopped for dinner here tonight for the first time after driving by for years. The atmosphere is not elegant but warm, friendly and plenty of room between tables. Seats were comfortable. Our waitress, Billi Jo, was helpful and friendly. Meatball hero was as good as I’ve had, especially the cheese which is how I imagine mozzarella from Italy tastes. My wife had ravioli which she liked. To me the prices were reasonable.
… moreRea
Haven’t been there in many years, it is clean, service is fast & friendly, but the pizza was tasteless, I had a tom/basil, one almost invisible slice of tomato, I like thin crust, but this was almost like a cracker. Not like it was years ago.We used to go there whenever we were in PJ.
Not their issue but the water has an awful taste. Maybe they should have a filter.
… moreTakeTheScenicRoute
So grateful for this to be our first stop traveling home for the holidays in New York! Great pizza with great people! Recommended!
… moreVenus W
These are supposed to be Garlic Parm wings…it looks like it was an afterthought. Not sure what type of sauce this is…garlic parm not so much
… moreMick Holt
We had lunch driving south after a week in the Adirondacks. I was aiming to collect another state tri-point, and we chose to stop here for lunch. Great choice and a great pizza!! First time in Port Jervis, but what a great meal!
… moreJohanna LjungQvist-Brinson
Wow. When you need to power up on good Italian food and on a budget…I had a slice of Pizza with mushrooms and pepperoni…Homemade Chicken, pasta and carrot soup and great Caesar Salad, with plenty of dressing plus nicely shaved Parmesan Cheese with plenty of crunchy croutons…really good meal and soda for under $20! I like their outdoor seating. Very nice service.
… more