Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Best locally owned New York Style Pizzeria in Haymarket! Serving authentic recipes using only the freshest ingredients. Get the best Pizza near you! Every dish made with love and care to give you a great tasting and unique experience every time. Come taste the difference.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 6402 Trading Sq, Haymarket, VA 20169
Phone: (703) 445-3130
Website: https://valentinosnypizzeriava.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: valentinosnypizzeriava.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Valentino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant Online Menu | Best Pizza in …
Valentino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant Menu. 6402 Trading Sq, Haymarket, VA.
Best Pizza in Haymarket, VA | Valentino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant …
Valentino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant: the best Pizza in Haymarket, VA. Order directly online today for takeout or delivery. Save money, support local business!
Valentino’s NY Pizzeria – A True Slice of New York Pizza in …
VIRGINIA LOCATION. Whether you dine in, carry out you will see why Valentino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is one of the best in the Northern VA area. Alexandria, VA.
Reviews
Big Pooch
We get the following order everytime: 1x Sicilian Pizza (16×,16)
+ Specialty Topping 1/2 6 ($6.00)
+ Sausage ($3.00)
+ Pepperoni ($3.00)
+ Black Olives ($3.00)
We have nicknamed this pizza “The Thing Of Beauty”, because it is just that! AWESOME! The only way they could possibly make it better is to get chunk sausage instead of sliced, but either way it is a fantastic pizza! HIGHLY recommend it!
… more+ Specialty Topping 1/2 6 ($6.00)
+ Sausage ($3.00)
+ Pepperoni ($3.00)
+ Black Olives ($3.00)
We have nicknamed this pizza “The Thing Of Beauty”, because it is just that! AWESOME! The only way they could possibly make it better is to get chunk sausage instead of sliced, but either way it is a fantastic pizza! HIGHLY recommend it!
John Spangenberg
If you live in the Gainesville/ Haymarket area, it is really hard to beat some made from scratch authentic Italian food! I have been coming here for years and it is the same food without change each time. So good! The brothers are extraordinary crafting their dishes. This place is a staple for our family and we find value in supporting our locals in the community!
… moreCarolina Swigart
Really delicious food. The staff member was funny, kind and engaging. Pizza is unbelievably good. The crust is amazing and the subs are served on amazing and fresh bread. We didn’t try the garlic knots but a patron came in and ordered some and said they were the best around…so next time, for sure.
… moreSamantha Jorgensen
Since moving to VA from Long Island, NY it has been difficult finding a great pizza similar to the ones back home. That all changed when we moved to Haymarket and started going to Valentino’s! The deep dish Sicilian is the softest and true to NY taste. Our family who come to visit and are also from NY always comment on how they love this pizza as well. We love the staff and owners, they always make a point to get to know their customers which gives the restaurant a family feel.
… moreAM M
Valentino’s is my favorite Italian restaurant in Haymarket. Their pizza is fresh and delicious and the Stromboli‘s and calzones out of this world. If you’ve never tried a slice of grandma Pizza, you don’t know what you’re missing. The other night I decided to venture out and try the eggplant Parm with a side of fettuccine Alfredo… To die for! Can’t say enough about this restaurant and the guys that work there are so friendly and really care about the customers and the food that they serve. Keep doing what you’re doing guys and I’ll keep coming back.
… moreJason Rivers
This is an absolutely delicious pizzeria! Everything is incredibly flavorful, tastes delicious and worth driving for (we are 30 minutes away). Highly recommend! The gnocchi with bolognese is one of our favorites!
… moreHenry Gruner
We were traveling through the area and were starving for a decent meal. The restaurant looked clean and inviting from the outside but once we walked in and saw a huge selection of pizzas sitting on the counter we were skeptical.
The menus are pamphlets located next to the register and are not displayed anywhere else that we saw in the restaurant.
We ordered a small pepperoni pizza, a meat filled calzone and an order of fries.
The fries came out first in a basket with a few ketchup packets tossed on top of the fries….no plates were brought out at this point.
The fries were mediocre at best in our opinion. Tasted like they were air fried…maybe?? Just not very good texture or flavor.
The calzone and pizza came out a few minutes later with a single thin paper plate and plastic cutlery. (I could not use the plastic cutlery to cut through the calzone and had to use my hands to eat it) The calzone was odd….. it tasted like unidentifiable meats and was over flowing with cool ricotta cheese. It seemed to have been unevenly heated in the microwave and put in the oven to finish it off.
The pizza was extremely greasy as seen in the pictures and had a strong taste of salt. Overall a very disappointing meal. I read all the reviews after getting home and hope we just had a bad night. If this restaurant were closer to us, I’m sure we would give it a second chance before deserting it. Hopefully they change things and get it together.
… moreThe menus are pamphlets located next to the register and are not displayed anywhere else that we saw in the restaurant.
We ordered a small pepperoni pizza, a meat filled calzone and an order of fries.
The fries came out first in a basket with a few ketchup packets tossed on top of the fries….no plates were brought out at this point.
The fries were mediocre at best in our opinion. Tasted like they were air fried…maybe?? Just not very good texture or flavor.
The calzone and pizza came out a few minutes later with a single thin paper plate and plastic cutlery. (I could not use the plastic cutlery to cut through the calzone and had to use my hands to eat it) The calzone was odd….. it tasted like unidentifiable meats and was over flowing with cool ricotta cheese. It seemed to have been unevenly heated in the microwave and put in the oven to finish it off.
The pizza was extremely greasy as seen in the pictures and had a strong taste of salt. Overall a very disappointing meal. I read all the reviews after getting home and hope we just had a bad night. If this restaurant were closer to us, I’m sure we would give it a second chance before deserting it. Hopefully they change things and get it together.
Lisa Engelhardt
Best Pizza in Northern Virginia! Gluten-free crust at no extra charge, too! I love the friendly service, ease of ordering online, and the fresh ingredients. ❤️
… moreNavid J
We are pizza connoisseurs and tough on judging a great slice. When I say this was a heck of a good pizza, I mean it. I’ve been to NY and have tried many famous spots like Lombari’s but this was much better. The best NY slice I’ve had to date. Keep up the great work!
… moreReal BBQ Dude
Valentino’s is a typical NY pizza joint. I tried a
slice of cheese. It was good. The crust was thin with a good mix of chewy and crunchy. You have to try the pepperoni pinwheels. They were amazing! These are soft, cheesy, gooey goodness! We liked them so much we went back the next day for more. The marinara and ranch were solid too. They have a good
variety of pizza,salads and rolls. Definitely will go back. My only complaint was they used a microwave to help warm up the food prior to putting it into the pizza oven.
… moreslice of cheese. It was good. The crust was thin with a good mix of chewy and crunchy. You have to try the pepperoni pinwheels. They were amazing! These are soft, cheesy, gooey goodness! We liked them so much we went back the next day for more. The marinara and ranch were solid too. They have a good
variety of pizza,salads and rolls. Definitely will go back. My only complaint was they used a microwave to help warm up the food prior to putting it into the pizza oven.