4.3 – 211 reviews • Italian restaurant
Valentino’s Pizzeria was founded November 18th, 1963 by Uncle Joe Valentino and his wife Sylvia. After 30 years of building the business, nephew Martin Barcellos and his wife Dawn purchased the well established eatery which is now known as Valentino’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant. The restaurant is known for its authentic Italian food.
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
Hours
| Saturday | 4–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: valentinositalianrestaurant.com
valentinositalianrestaurantreedley.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Reviews
Jessica Borges
It was our first time here and with it being just a 30min drive from where we live, we will definitely be dining here again! When we walked it was a simple yet home feel vibe. We were seated quickly on Friday evening at 7pm. The service was excellent and everyone was working together to be sure we were taken care of. Then our food came and it was even better. Fresh and delicious! We had the garlic bread appetizer, it was homemade to the perfect toast and flavor! I had the fettuccine Alfredo, it was creamy and light, not really heavy. We ended with tiramisu for dessert and it’s by far the best I’ve had in our area! So grateful for a wonderful dinner!
… moreEdgar Martinez
Service was a bit slow for me, I am a bit impatient. It was worth the wait. HOLY MOLY. The food was 10/10 and the Tiramisu was 9.5/10. Worth the drive and time.
… moreOscar Gonzalez
Amazing service. The food is great . My kids asked me to take them back tomorrow. This is a family owned and operated restaurant by people that love what they do.
… moreKristine P
We ate at Valentino’s last night and had such a great experience. The owner personally came to our table, took the time to talk with us, and was incredibly kind and the staff is welcoming. The food was absolutely delicious. You can truly taste the quality and care put into it fresh, well-prepared, and clearly not frozen or mass-produced. Everything tasted thoughtfully made. Will definitely be back!
… moreLeslie Loewen
We love this local treasure. Great family, food, and community servants. They work hard to make fresh tasty food! This is a weekly staple!
7/17/2025
We recently found out that my husband has T2 diabetes. Dan just made him the best dinner. No pasta, but all the veggies,
chicken, and great seasoning. He is so great. Loves his customers and does all he can to take care of us. Thank you to the whole team!!
… moreAlex Ledesma
After nine incredible years of dining out with my wife, I can confidently say that this restaurant offers the best service we’ve ever experienced! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with warmth and efficiency, and I was seated almost immediately.
While researching the restaurant, I noticed a lack of recent food photos, but I completely forgot to snap one myself. The dishes arrived looking so mouthwatering that they vanished before I had a chance! I ordered a calzone customized to mirror “The Works” pizza, and it was a flavor explosion. My wife indulged in the tortellini pesto with steak, which she raved about throughout the meal.
The service was truly exceptional, creating an inviting atmosphere that made our dining experience memorable.
I can’t imagine any other restaurant surpassing this level of care and attention. I will definitely be back try the rest of the menu
Don’t listen to any of the lower star reviews hahahahhah
… moreooof
Wish I could give them more stars. The margarita pizza and pastas are so good. They make everything from scratch and you can taste the difference. And, the staff make you feel at home and clearly care about the food and their customers. I’m visiting my aunt and coming here made our night.
… moreJessica Gomez
amazing good! I can’t even eat Olive Garden anymore because I’ll just end up regretting it and wishing I came here. Food is fresh, made from fresh REAL ingredients. Prices I can’t even say are fair. They’re not fair to the owner. Big advantage for guests there. The owner is the kindest. Top 5 date night place for my husband and now. Nothing else compares to the flavor here.
… moreKathryn Fink
We had a private event here. This is a Reedley staple, everything is made from scratch. Dan, the owner and his incredible team really made our family gathering extremely special. Really personable, easy to work with, no fuss. Prices were amazing too! The staff is passionate about their work, food, and industry culture. This restaurant has a reedley historical charm to it and we are so happy to see it open and thriving! Highly recommend – next time I travel here I will be back! Good beer selection and they offer buffet style for special events. Honestly, they should charge more!
… moreDAVID MORENO
1st time trying the pizza and restaurant. It just wasn’t good . Sauce and toppings ended 2 inches from the edge the crust was really thin and hard at the edges. Most toppings were under the cheese sandwiched between sauce and cheese so when you got a piece from box or even bite into it everything slipped off and you were left with sauce covered crust. Was expecting better. Very disappointed
… more … View more