Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Classic & white pies, plus slices, subs & salad are found at this snug pizzeria with sidewalk seats.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 90 Main St, Keene, NH 03431
Phone: (603) 355-3535
Website: https://theunderdogpizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Underdog Pizza
Keene, NH 03431— Copyright © 2022 Underdog Pizza — All Rights Reserved. (603) 355-3535. Powered by GoDaddy. This website uses cookies. We use cookies to …
Underdog Pizza | Keene NH – Facebook
We are open 11am – 8pm 603-355-3535 #underdogpizza #pizzaandwings #pizzanight #pizzadelivery #keenestate · .
Underdog Pizza: Authentic NY Style Pizza More in Keene, NH
Underdog Pizza, located at 90 Main St, Keene, NH, is a delightful haven for pizza lovers seeking authentic New York-style cuisine. Renowned for its crisp, …
Reviews
J-Dub
Amazing NY style pizza in the middle of Keene, thin hand tossed crust in the center slowly and proportionally thickens to a perfectly crispy crust, they achieve that potato chip crunch without burning which is so common, incredibly delicious, we were traveling through but now my family is trying to get me to drive back for more. Fun dark themed interior with a diverse collection of toys. Also great to stretch your legs in the down town strip, lots of shops to browse.
… moreskuzz Cuzz
Might very well be the worst pizza I’ve had in my life.. No exaggeration. Bottom of the whole pizza was soaking wet? Veggies were clearly cut days ago and were soggy as all get out. Couldn’t stomach even one slice.
… moreLynn Magennis
Was looking for a quick lunch in Keene and thought we’d try this pizzeria. We only tried the cheese steak or steak with cheese as it’s called here and it was excellent. The steak was seasoned well and it was a very generous portion. Recommend highly.
… moreGretchen Jackson
Ordering a garden salad that claims in the add made fresh daily, should not have the appearance of rusty lettuce at noon. Spending that kind of money purely out of convenience only solidifies why most people don’t order salads out. I would rather pay more for quality over quantity. This was the first time I had ever been there. Otherwise staff seemed friendly.
… moreDaryl Hastings
Absolutely delicious! We got the cheese pizza with ricotta and the maple buffalo wings and couldn’t be happier. The wings have got to be some of the best we’ve ever had and the pizza was just what we were looking for. Not greasy and the crust was flavorful. The service is great and we even got a courtesy call to clarify my order. That spoke volumes about the attention to detail and just plain good service. We found our new favorite pizza shop.
… moreDebra Potts
As a native Bostonian I consider myself to be a good food critic and in my opinion there is no one like Underdog pizza for that classic, thin with crispy & delicious crust and real mozzarella cheese. Amazing flavor and sauce. They are truly a gem. There are tons of pizza places around but everything is bready, with fake cheese etc. For me there is only one place around to get the freshest, best, truly the NY style that I grew up with kind of pizza. Not to mention the owners are wonderful, friendly and go above and beyond to make sure their place stands above the rest. I always get the garden salad and fries too. Big, fresh salad with great, real blue cheese! I normally have to have my Underdog pizza at least once a week. If you are looking for NY style pizza, look no further. Give them a try and you will not be disappointed! Just look at the picture I posted!
Deb Carroll
… moreDeb Carroll
Zach Knutsen
Amazing food, however the online ordering site is absolute garbage. 3 years, 3 different debit and credit cards and it’s only ever processed and gone through once. If not for that little nuance, this place would be 11/10, the food truly is that good!!
… moreKris A
I’ve been a loyal customer at this incredible pizza spot for years, and it’s safe to say it holds a special place in my heart. Whenever I’m craving a truly amazing calzone, this is the only place in the area that gets it just right. The dough is perfection—always crisp on the outside yet soft and pillowy on the inside. The cheese is melted to creamy, gooey perfection, and the toppings are always hot and flavorful. It’s the type of meal that you can’t help but savor bite after bite.
Every time I have friends visiting from out of town, I make it a point to bring them here, and they all agree—this place is a gem. It’s become my go-to for not just the food but the overall experience.
Speaking of experience, the decor here is absolutely one-of-a-kind. It’s a quirky mix of nostalgic 80s cartoon figures, skateboard decks, and all sorts of other cool, eclectic items adorning the walls. It’s impossible to walk in and not feel a sense of wonder as you take in all the unique pieces of decor.
The staff here is another highlight. They’re always warm, friendly, and seem genuinely happy to be working. You can tell it’s a positive environment, which really adds to the welcoming vibe of the restaurant.
And let’s not forget about the pizza—it’s just as delicious as their legendary calzones. The crust is always fresh, light yet satisfying, and the toppings are always high-quality. Every bite is a little taste of heaven.
If you happen to be in the area, do yourself a favor and order my usual: a buffalo chicken calzone with jalapeno peppers and ricotta cheese. It’s a flavor combination that’s unmatched and will have you coming back for more.
… moreEvery time I have friends visiting from out of town, I make it a point to bring them here, and they all agree—this place is a gem. It’s become my go-to for not just the food but the overall experience.
Speaking of experience, the decor here is absolutely one-of-a-kind. It’s a quirky mix of nostalgic 80s cartoon figures, skateboard decks, and all sorts of other cool, eclectic items adorning the walls. It’s impossible to walk in and not feel a sense of wonder as you take in all the unique pieces of decor.
The staff here is another highlight. They’re always warm, friendly, and seem genuinely happy to be working. You can tell it’s a positive environment, which really adds to the welcoming vibe of the restaurant.
And let’s not forget about the pizza—it’s just as delicious as their legendary calzones. The crust is always fresh, light yet satisfying, and the toppings are always high-quality. Every bite is a little taste of heaven.
If you happen to be in the area, do yourself a favor and order my usual: a buffalo chicken calzone with jalapeno peppers and ricotta cheese. It’s a flavor combination that’s unmatched and will have you coming back for more.
Jake Nelson
Ordered pizza and wings. The pizza is thin and also crispy, easily foldable, great undercarriage. Ordered maple buffalo wings and that didn’t disappoint as well. I’ll be back for sure.
… moreDevin Lounder
Ordered garlic knots, onion rings and a cheese pizza for takeout. Pick it up and head home. Open it up garlic knots were burnt, onion rings were wrapped in a sandwich parchment paper and completely soggy and pizza was meh. Another takeout place added to the I thank you list.
… more