Founded in 1968 by Uncle Joe Sciara, Uncle Joe’s Famous Pizzeria is one of Long Island’s oldest pizzerias and red sauce joints. The Hamptons Institution, a beacon of tradition and culinary excellence, has served millions of New York residents and tourists from around the world for over half a century. Uncle Joe’s serves Original Long Island Panko pizzas, Classic New York Style pizzas, and Italian specialties, such as its famous Vodka sauce dishes, Parms, Original Sauce Wings and signature Dolci Doughknots.
morgan c
ordered a 10inch eggplant parm pie and a pint of soup at 8:30.
they charged me 36.96 when online it’s only 30 dollars. the lady on the phone asked me the order like 5 times and even REPEATED IT BACK TO ME yet OVERCHARGED me and then i receive the order and it’s WRONG.
She never gave me a receipt or anything either which is crazy. She gave me an 18 inch PLAIN pie with pieces of eggplant thrown on top. then it was too late to even fix my order because they were closing.
also online it says the soup comes with focaccia but it’s just a random piece of bread.
… moreOscar “Kokito” Gonzalez
Great pizza and salad. Good service. I like the modern atmospheric vibe. A must visit. Different then the competitors. I will say, there needs to be an option for how much to cook the wings. Regular, well or crispy. I like mine crispy but they were cooked barely enough. It’s my fault for not adding cooking potion to notes but I didn’t think barely enough is not great either. Other than that upgrade, good choice.
… moreyossline herrera
Amazing food and even better service! We started with the bruschetta—crispy, fresh, and full of flavor. The chicken parm was perfectly breaded and smothered in rich marinara and melted mozzarella, and the pizza had that perfect fresh taste. Our server, Samantha, was so friendly and attentive—she made the whole experience even better. Can’t wait to come back!
… moreMichael Sinensky
Beautiful upgrade to our fav pizza spot in the Hamptons. Went with a group of 8 and ordered
All the salads, a pie of grandma slice, eggplant parm platter with spaghetti (best), buffalo wings (awesome), garlic knots which I didn’t get to try because I had pasta. Was super happy with everything. We ate in the back room which was stunning for events and large parties. Wish I took more pics of the room and food but we were hungry and attacked it when it came out. For 8 people it was $120 + tip which I thought was super reasonable for a sit down part of a slice restaurant
Looking forward to our next visit
… morePinky
This place has the best tasting and FRESHEST food EVER and the kids at the counter are sweet! LOVE THAT! Been going here for yrs even when they were by the WBN! They ALSO have great specials too!
… moreAiden Jimdar
The pizza was really not that great: bland, forgettable, and nowhere near the hype for Long Island . For a place in Southampton, we expected way more flavor and care. Instead, it felt rushed bland. Wings were alright. My uncle wouldn’t eat a second slice of the chicken beacon ranch and he will eat anything. Disappointed.
… morealex treyger
ordered a few slices ( plain and buffalo chicken), both tasted dry and stale, like they had been reheated more than once. the buffalo chicken was buffalo in name only, barely resembled what it should taste like. very disappointing.
… moreSamuel M.
This place has amazing pasta and other food like pizza, salad, and dessert, the atmosphere is very nice with wine on the walls and pictures of our Uncle Joe
Overall with good service, I loved this place and I would recommend it for anyone passing through or staying
… moreJoe Rincon
Great rental room for parties!!! The food was spectacular and really hot and very good.. very clean restaurant, open kitchen and great service.
… moreAbhidha Saluja
Good place. The best thing about it, open till 10.00pm while all other eating places around close by 9.00pm. When we reached there at 9pm, we were the only ones. Staff was helpful and cheerfull. We didnt have much variety in veg but got something to eat. Thankful for that.
… more