Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 25 E Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
Phone: (516) 922-0434
Website: http://www.umbertosoysterbay.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Umberto’s of Oyster Bay – 25 E Main Street, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
The Original Umberto’s in Oyster Bay, New York. Specializing in Italian dishes, grandma pizza, sicilian pizza, Neapolitan pizza, New York Style Pizza, …
Umberto’s of Oyster Bay has officially closed as of February 1, 2026.
Umberti Bay Oyster Umberto’s of Oyster Bay has closed as of February 1, 2026. Join our email list at: www.umbertosoysterbay.com We look …
Umberto’s of Oyster Bay (@umbertosoysterbay) – Instagram
Photo by Umberto’s of Oyster Bay in Oyster Bay, New York. Umberto’s of Oyster Bay has officially closed as of February 1, 2026. We are so grateful to the …
Last Updates
Reviews
49er Nyc
Best pizza in Long Island hands down I am not from Long Island but when I go there I have I stop in. Better than new park
… moreAdriana Rexach
Ordered a meatball hero on uber eats, The bread is like rubber, no sauce on the meatballs and all my extra cheese I paid for was all over the foil and not in my sandwich like really??? Horrible and inedible I was trying to support small local business but this is the Last time I order from them.. Do better Umberto’s!!
… moreBryan B.
Ordered a personal chicken bacon ranch pie from Umbertos. Total came to $16 with no drinks or sides. A little steep in my opinion if they want to stay competitive in this market.
The personal pie was of good portion, if not larger than other establishments. They slice it in large quarters.
The best part of this pizza was the crust by far; I’m assuming they use some sort of pan because it was super crispy & delicious !!
However, the pizza itself did taste a bit bland. It lacked salt and that robust flavor you would expect from anything ranch. Adding salt & red pepper (myself) did bring it up to par.
Overall I’d give this place a 4/5. Crust & dough were great but they can certainly improve in the “seasoning department.” Heavier in flavor can be better than lacking in flavor , disregarding anchovies (haha).
I’ll buy from here again if they improve getting to/surpassing Mario’s level. Thanks !
-Bryan B. (customer)
… moreThe personal pie was of good portion, if not larger than other establishments. They slice it in large quarters.
The best part of this pizza was the crust by far; I’m assuming they use some sort of pan because it was super crispy & delicious !!
However, the pizza itself did taste a bit bland. It lacked salt and that robust flavor you would expect from anything ranch. Adding salt & red pepper (myself) did bring it up to par.
Overall I’d give this place a 4/5. Crust & dough were great but they can certainly improve in the “seasoning department.” Heavier in flavor can be better than lacking in flavor , disregarding anchovies (haha).
I’ll buy from here again if they improve getting to/surpassing Mario’s level. Thanks !
-Bryan B. (customer)
jessica sarter
I only gave the service of four because they stopped delivering to my area! They have such great vegan options and they have this vegan grandma pie that I served to all my guests last summer even though I’m the only vegan everyone loved it and today was the third time somebody asked if we were gonna be ordering “that pizza that we got last year” again. I have absolutely hated not being able to get food from here this year, I had to be their biggest vegan pizza customer lol! But if you’re looking for vegan options I would definitely recommend it, I just hope one day they expand their delivery area out to me again!
… moreBMW8#1 !
No matter what pizza you get, it’s always dry, there’s barely any sauce & it’s black on the bottom like the oven needs to be cleaned. The pizza’s so dry you can choke on it & it’s so black you can taste the char! Same thing w the pasta dishes, there’s a spot of sauce so you choke on pasta!
I also had a grilled chicken w avocado hero & 1 thought it was ok to put a piece of raw garlic on it!
If it wasn’t for the customer service, I would give 1 star bc it’s been 3 yrs of awful pizza, etc
… moreI also had a grilled chicken w avocado hero & 1 thought it was ok to put a piece of raw garlic on it!
If it wasn’t for the customer service, I would give 1 star bc it’s been 3 yrs of awful pizza, etc
Lori Hellen
I ordered $185 worth of food. 3 pizzas and an order of garlic bread with mozzarella cheese arrived so burnt that we had to dissect them to eat them and a lot of it went in the garbage. I contacted Umberto’s through the slice app i ordered it on and they only issued me a $10 credit. i asked them to please reconsider the small amount of the credit and they refused.
… moreStefanie D
I live in NJ but whenever I’m in Long Island I make it a point to stop at umbertos and buy a few pizzas, and freeze them since I don’t have the luxury of living near a location . The Sicilian slice is the main thing that sets them apart from other pizza spots
… moreDonna Cardillo
Simply put……..best grandmas pizza on long island. I live a few towns over, but never stopped in this umbertos in my life … Its a small pizzeria, but maybe that is why the pizza is outstanding. Sat at table outside….. Quality ingredients, best crust, sauce, etc . this will be my new pizza- go- to- place. Try one slice, and you will be hooked.
… moreJulie Taylor
Ordered 2 regular pizzas to go. They were huge – seemed even bigger than stated 18”. Unfortunately, although we pickup up in exactly 25 min as instructed, and started eating 10 min after that, the pizzas were already luke warm and seemed a bit stale. We wonder if toppings were added and pre made pizzas reheated? I ordered black olives for 5.25 and got calamatas instead. Huge taste difference. Disappointed for $68 for two pizzas Not recommended, sadly
… moreJennifer L
I don’t live in the area but whenever I visit, this is a really solid pizza spot. Long Island is certainly full of great options but I found it to be very consistently good and the guys that work there are so nice. This will always be my go-to whenever I’m in town. I love a good grandma slice and you can’t find it like this anywhere else. I wish I could post a picture, but I never remember to take it before I inhale it lol.
… more