Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Family Owned Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria offering the widest selection of Pizza and Italian Food in the area. Serving Lunch and Dinner with Full Menu with Beer and Wine. Wide selection of Gluten free items including pasta and pizza as well cauliflower pizza and whole wheat pasta. We also have large selection of popular American favorites from Burgers, Cheese Steaks and Salads to Steak, Chops and Seafood.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1199 Texas Palmyra Hwy D, Honesdale, PA 18431
Phone: (570) 253-2613
Website: https://www.twoguyshonesdale.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Two Guys from Italy
We are Two Guys from Italy and we’re here to offer those in Honesdale an amazing selection of pizza, sandwiches, and classic Italian fare all in a fun and …
Two Guys from Italy | Honesdale PA – Facebook
570-253-2613. Plan ahead for your pizzas for later. Order online or call ahead and don’t forget our full menu! #honesdaleats #honesdale #honesdalepa.
Choose Order Type – Two Guys from Italy (Shift4) – ToGoOrder.com
PLEASE VERIFY AT TOP OF SCREEN THAT YOU ARE ORDERING FROM CORRECT LOCATION! THANK YOU! Take Out; Delivery. Order My Usual. © 2026 – ToGoTechnologies, LLC.
Reviews
Nancy Ann Reina
I would like to thank the Staff for making a great night even GREATER we had a get together of family lost and now found. Without realizing,We stood past closing and they did not come to tell us to leave. When we realized we got up and thanked them very much for their patience. All I can say is THANK U TO ALL THAT HAD TIME TO MAKE OUR NIGHT A SUCCESS♥️❤️
… moreMelanie Cardenas
We JUST picked up food from here. The calamari was cold, smelled off, and doesnt look particularly appetizing. Barely any sauce on the pasta, or runny at the bottom. It just tastes like the pasta. Would not order from here again, how disappointing for $45.
… moreMatthew McKenna
Ordered an Angel hair carbonara with sausage. What i received was a side of sausage in red sauce, and a dish or my carbonara swimming in atleast a cup of grease. The sauce had broken, honestly from the texture of the pasta it wouldn’t surprise me if the microwaved my food and put it in the to go box. Also the side of sausage was interesting. I dont know anyone that would recieve my order and not understand I wanted sausage IN the carbonara, like im going to mix sausage and red sauce in a carbonara. But the pasta was so bad, I was glad to have the side of sausage so I could try to enjoy some food other than the salad my dinner came with. This was a to go order, if I ate in the resturant I absolutely would have sent my food back. Would not reccomend, would have been better off with one of the fast food places near by.
… moreLinwan Feng
Two Guys from Italy is better than my favorite pizza place in NYC – Sacco on 9th Avenue. And I’ve lived in NYC for 10 years.
I was surprised how good everything was.
… moreI was surprised how good everything was.
Florian Wolf
Got take out from here. The waiting time was a bit higher than initially told (about 40 minutes instead of the stated 20-25) but it’s still tolerable. It’s a busy place, after all, and for good reason.
Even just waiting for our take out, the comfortable and cozy atmosphere paired with lots of friendly, smiling faces gave me a happy feeling.
The food itself – classic American-Italian cuisine – ranges from pasta to pizza, and is not missing anything you’d expect. We also got wings, both of the bone-in and boneless variety, to go with our pizzas. Prices are a bit high but honestly, a personal pizza each is more than enough to satisfy.
I wasn’t sure whether I want to rate Two Guys four stars because of high prices and very greasy wings and pizza or if the flavours win me over – but they did. In this area of the county, you probably can’t get a better tasting pizza. And it does taste phenomenally satisfying. Next time I’d forgo the wings and focus on pizza alone.
… moreEven just waiting for our take out, the comfortable and cozy atmosphere paired with lots of friendly, smiling faces gave me a happy feeling.
The food itself – classic American-Italian cuisine – ranges from pasta to pizza, and is not missing anything you’d expect. We also got wings, both of the bone-in and boneless variety, to go with our pizzas. Prices are a bit high but honestly, a personal pizza each is more than enough to satisfy.
I wasn’t sure whether I want to rate Two Guys four stars because of high prices and very greasy wings and pizza or if the flavours win me over – but they did. In this area of the county, you probably can’t get a better tasting pizza. And it does taste phenomenally satisfying. Next time I’d forgo the wings and focus on pizza alone.
The OHalloRANT
This pizza take out and Italian restaurant is incredibly affordable and the food is absolutely delicious! Trinity our server was delightful!
We didn’t order the pizza, but the table next to us did and they still make a LARGE pie, not these medium size pizzas being sold as large at other places. Highly recommend this place,
… moreWe didn’t order the pizza, but the table next to us did and they still make a LARGE pie, not these medium size pizzas being sold as large at other places. Highly recommend this place,
DeBbIe A. LyLe
Upon entering we were greeted with a warm Hello and Welcome. Orders were taken quickly and advised as too how long it’d take to receive our orders. Food was prepared in site. Fresh… So good and yummy. I even bought a pound variety of cookies to take back to Florida ️
Both Indoor & Outdoor seating was available. Upon receiving our food we chose to sit outside the weather was cool despite the rain. Everything tasted great, large portions and freshly baked bread was given as well. Highly recommend.
… moreBoth Indoor & Outdoor seating was available. Upon receiving our food we chose to sit outside the weather was cool despite the rain. Everything tasted great, large portions and freshly baked bread was given as well. Highly recommend.
Melissa C
I had recently inquired about having a pizza party with 8 pies for pick up to one of the local schools with Local Pizza in Callicoon. I called on a Friday morning ahead of time, that Saturday and then again Sunday trying to get ahold of the manager, who I was told would reach out to me to take our order. When I couldn’t get ahold of her by Sunday afternoon the employee was so kind to take that order for us. The manager texted us at almost 8pm Sunday night canceling for that Monday morning order. It was very disappointing and frustrating to scramble and find an open pizzeria on a Sunday night.
Thankfully Two Guys from Italy were more than accommodating for us, allowing my daughter’s entire 8th grade class to enjoy a fun start to their week with a pizza party.
So thankful for them being able to do this last minute and to have them ready first thing in the morning when they opened in order to have them picked up and delivered to the school for lunch time.
… moreThankfully Two Guys from Italy were more than accommodating for us, allowing my daughter’s entire 8th grade class to enjoy a fun start to their week with a pizza party.
So thankful for them being able to do this last minute and to have them ready first thing in the morning when they opened in order to have them picked up and delivered to the school for lunch time.
Jei Filipino
Place was pretty nice, they set the mood once you enter with their dim light. Ordering seems so organized and they were full when we went there. We supposed to do takeout changes our mind and seat outside instead.
We had a lot of food and no kidding they have big serving. We enjoyed evey bite especially their calzone was really good. This place is really good for family event. Their fish and chips was just normal nothing special. We ordered other fried food but for me the pasta and calzone stand out.
… moreWe had a lot of food and no kidding they have big serving. We enjoyed evey bite especially their calzone was really good. This place is really good for family event. Their fish and chips was just normal nothing special. We ordered other fried food but for me the pasta and calzone stand out.
MIchael Selvaggi
I like the fact that it is inside an old mall. There is an old Italy ambiance to it the further back into the restaurant you travel. The food is pretty good. I like their pizza. It’s not doughy or too thick. If thin and crispy is what you wanna going for, you have a better chance with Two Guys than you do with Elegantes. Service was pretty standard. No complaints other than I remember the table being a little sticky one time. May have been a freak occurrence… Solid restaurant. Period.
… more