Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Two Brothers Pizza brings a fresh twist to Cleveland’s pizza scene. We are first Halal pizza in Cleveland. Locally owned and passionately crafted, our newest signature flavor hits different — bold, craveable, and loaded with unique ingredients that set us apart from the rest. We’re proud to bring real flavor to The Land with every slice. Come taste what everyone’s talking about.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5766 Mayfield Rd, Mayfield Heights, OH 44124
Website: https://2brospizza.online/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
TBD – Mayfield Pizzeria
See our latest menu, find our hours, and order online directly from us. Locations in Mayfield Heights, OH.
Review of new Two Brothers restaurant in Mayfield Heights
OCR: GRAND GRAND Two OPENING! OPENINGI PIZZA Brothers SUBS SUBS 5766 AND Heights, Mayfield Rd, OH 44124 Mayfield Mayfield Fri Sun- 440-566 …
Order Online – TBD – Mayfield Pizzeria
Come Experience Two Brother’s Pizza: You’ll Want More! … TBD – Mayfield Pizzeria Location and Hours. (440) 566-0171 · 5766 Mayfield Rd, Mayfield Heights, OH …
Reviews
John H
Service was very nice. Food was good got two small pizzas one gyro and pepperoni both were good better than a pizza hut or papa johns if your looking for a different type of taste. I got wings 6-garlic parm 6-honey bbq, size of the wings are good size not small or too big and they were good! Price i spent was about $35 but, I would definitely recommend.
… moreJared Thomson
I got the veggie, a cheese, a pepperoni and the cheese and garlic breadsticks. The pizza is tavern style (thinner crust). The sauce is very flavorful, you get a big hit of tomato and Italian spices. It’s very nice. The staff was friendly, and have that locally owned mom and pop shop vibe. I highly recommend giving them a try.
… moreBert Jenkins
This was my first visit although I had ordered for delivery previously. I ordered 12 wings w/BBQ sauce and regular potato wedges. Both items were baked, not fried and my order was ready when I arrived and piping hot. I was pleasantly surprised by the size of the regular potato wedges. They were definitely worth the price. The staff was friendly and courteous. I plan to pay them another visit in the near future.
… moreRoseanne Greggor
Very good pizza! Try it! A little different, but very nice harmony of ingredients. Get it more than once to decide if you like it & what you like about it. Highly recommend. More of a take out place, but there are a few tables
… moreCharles
Worst pizza I think I ever had that was made for me. You can tell its pre-made crust and to be honest it taste identical to tostitos frozen pizzas or toni’s
… moreray pritchett
The pizza was too thin and hardly any flavor. Purchased two pasta bowls and couldn’t eat them. They were obviously made much earlier than reheated. The cheese was solid not hot and not melted at all. Would have been eatable if frehly made with hot meling cheese. Won’t order again
… moreBob the Raptor & Joe
I was very impressed by my first visit to Two Brothers Pizza in Mayfield Heights. The owner and his staff were kind. Service was very prompt and friendly. I ordered a Philly Cheesesteak Calzone… it was very tasty… ingredients were fresh, and the cheese was fresh. I was also surprised that Baklava was a desert option here. I really enjoyed my experience and will definitely be back.
… moreErica Seiler
In summary, YUM YUM! Everything is amazing tasty and great!! Plus the people were very friendly
I’ve been working crazy hours and was in a pinch food wise. I’ve been wanting to try this place so I ordered a veggie pizza, an Italian sub, and meatball pasta. Food for tonight, work lunch, and dinner tomorrow! Well, of course I had to try a bite everything once I got it.
I love Italian subs, and let me tell you, this one has to be one of the best! Holy cow, so good! I was going to save it for lunch, but ate half for dinner instead.
The pizza was also great! The crust was so perfectly crusty and garlicky. Very yummy. Ate a piece of that with my half sub for my dinner LOL.
I only tried a bite of the pasta before I saved it, but it also tasted delicious, I’m sure once I really dig in I’ll be doing the yummy happy dance
… moreI’ve been working crazy hours and was in a pinch food wise. I’ve been wanting to try this place so I ordered a veggie pizza, an Italian sub, and meatball pasta. Food for tonight, work lunch, and dinner tomorrow! Well, of course I had to try a bite everything once I got it.
I love Italian subs, and let me tell you, this one has to be one of the best! Holy cow, so good! I was going to save it for lunch, but ate half for dinner instead.
The pizza was also great! The crust was so perfectly crusty and garlicky. Very yummy. Ate a piece of that with my half sub for my dinner LOL.
I only tried a bite of the pasta before I saved it, but it also tasted delicious, I’m sure once I really dig in I’ll be doing the yummy happy dance
Amanda L
Our first experience was really great- warm subs on fresh italian bread. The subs come with seasoned wedge fries, and they were good too! Will try again.
… moreKg
Two brothers must be the cousins of Hunt Brothers. This is the MOST mediocre at BEST pizza in town. There is LITERALLY nothing special about this sauce. The sauce has not much flavor if any at all. Left me feeling like it was cafeteria style sauce from the lunch room as a kid. Cheese was nothing special and the crust was NOT tavern style as stated in other reviews.
The wings were NOT crispy and could have TONS of potential if cooked to the point of being crispy. I asked for hot garlic Parm and instead got some sweet Parm sauce which was not good. The wings were bigger wings than most places but again the lack of crisp just made them feel awkward (like fatty) when you touch them. The sauce was sticky and flavorless which was weird as well for they smelled good for not being the sauce I asked for.
The cheesy breadsticks were not cheesy. They were thinner dough than the pizza which was weird. They came with no dipping sauce. Nothing special, unique or exciting about these.
The best thing that came with the meal were the chocolate chip cookies. Even the cookies though are dry, fairly flavorless and again not spectacular or even good.
Service was Meh at best when you take into account the order was missing items and I was provided wrong items as well. This was On top of entering the store with a girl sitting on top of a table. She had not much care to say hi. Even once I was in the store she had no care to come down and at least act like she cared to be there. The lady at the counter was very pleasant and kind though. I do have to comment to her to not be telling people they are the best wings when they definitely are not.
For $50 in today’s economy…….There are many many other places I would go instead of here for pizza and wings. They are new to the area and hopefully they improve and I can change this review to a positive and highly rated review. I truly went into this experience open minded. I am not trying to bash this business. However I do feel that it is important to give a fair and honest review about all aspects of this experience.
… moreThe wings were NOT crispy and could have TONS of potential if cooked to the point of being crispy. I asked for hot garlic Parm and instead got some sweet Parm sauce which was not good. The wings were bigger wings than most places but again the lack of crisp just made them feel awkward (like fatty) when you touch them. The sauce was sticky and flavorless which was weird as well for they smelled good for not being the sauce I asked for.
The cheesy breadsticks were not cheesy. They were thinner dough than the pizza which was weird. They came with no dipping sauce. Nothing special, unique or exciting about these.
The best thing that came with the meal were the chocolate chip cookies. Even the cookies though are dry, fairly flavorless and again not spectacular or even good.
Service was Meh at best when you take into account the order was missing items and I was provided wrong items as well. This was On top of entering the store with a girl sitting on top of a table. She had not much care to say hi. Even once I was in the store she had no care to come down and at least act like she cared to be there. The lady at the counter was very pleasant and kind though. I do have to comment to her to not be telling people they are the best wings when they definitely are not.
For $50 in today’s economy…….There are many many other places I would go instead of here for pizza and wings. They are new to the area and hopefully they improve and I can change this review to a positive and highly rated review. I truly went into this experience open minded. I am not trying to bash this business. However I do feel that it is important to give a fair and honest review about all aspects of this experience.