Craig Gerber
Stopped in for evening Ice Cream. Employees were friendly, atmosphere was clean and pleasant. There were 4 of us so we had 4 flavors all were good, one was maybe a little old with Ice crystals. That and a flimsy spoon was my only complaint. We will visit again on my next trip to Buckeye Lake.
… moreCaitlin Bowman
First glance it was cluttered. Good costumer service. It was a little pricey for it being a scoop of ice cream and a milkshake, with it being a hair over $12. Flavors were on point! The peach ice cream had a entire peach in it and the peanut butter shake was packed full of peanut butter. I think I would come back, but to try what they’re are known for, which is their slushies.
… moreElizabeth Allen
This place is such a hidden gem! We always go fishing at Buckeye Lake and we’re so surprised to have the best slushies in the central Ohio area! We got the mango & peach slushies and they were the perfect end to a day at the lake. The staff was super friendly. Can’t wait to go back.
… moreJuly Girl
Its Friday night and my husband had a taste for ice cream. So we went online to see what time WHITTS in buckeye lake is open til. Its posted till 9pm. We had time. Head over there and go inside and place my regular order. I was surprised what they handed me. They were little cups. The staff was very nice and asked if I knew this wasn’t WHITTS anymore? I was like what?? No I didn’t. After eating the soft serve it was horrible tasting. Definitely not a creamy ice cream. My husband threw his away. 15 dollars for such a small portion. Now last year I would go to the slushy bar which use to be in a different location. I love the blushes. BUT the ice cream no thanks.
… moreNichole Savage
Even though it says they are open, they never are when I attempt to stop in.
What are your actual hours?
I noticed you took the posted hours off of the door.
… more