Isabel
We wish we found this place sooner! We got takeout and the pizza was 10/10. Salad was nothing special but what you would expect from a pizza place and fresh! We got the hot honey pepperoni pizza and added ricotta & a grilled chicken salad.
… moreАндрей Шумеляк
An absolute gem of Italian cuisine. From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere wraps around you like a warm Tuscan evening. The service is attentive without hovering, knowledgeable without rehearsed speeches.
The pasta tastes like it remembers its grandmother. Even the bread felt intentional, crusty outside, cloud soft inside.
If you’re looking for authentic flavors, elegant ambiance, and a dining experience that feels both refined and welcoming, this place delivers.
… morePamela Lyle
Nice quiet place to have an early dinner on a Saturday afternoon. Nice and friendly staff. Really good thin crust and plenty of Toppings. We even ordered a small one to go and, of course, a slice of lemoncello to take home. Will definitely add this to our local pizza restaurant list
… moreMichael Jones
We went tonight for dinner and tried a variety of things on the menu. The food was AMAZING. Our whole family loved it. The Spinach Roll was my favorite. Generous portions too – we took a lot home, but not for lack of trying! Great atmosphere, great food, what else can you ask for? The new owners are doing great!
… moreSuzanne Goss
Absolutely Outstanding!
We had such a great experience at Troni’s! The pizza was perfectly cooked — crispy on the outside, soft in the middle, and full of flavor. You can really taste the freshness of the ingredients, especially the homemade sauce and hand-tossed dough. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the staff went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect. This place truly feels like a little slice of Italy right here at home. Highly recommend for anyone who loves authentic Italian food and genuine hospitality.
… moreAshley Campbell
I was just grabbing a late night but before meeting some friends for Karaoke & was blown away! Perfect crust, cheese, sauce spice profile, pep, cook & service! Gina was sweet to chat with about allll things pizza & I can’t wait to grab a pie for the fam soon. My tipsy friends at the karaoke bar even paused to comment about how amazing the pie was. Thank you, Gina!
… moreSamantha Spychalla
Great crust. Excellent customer service, we brought a big group and they accommodated us with no problem. Very kind staff.
Nona pizza with fresh mozz and basil was
… moreElizabeth McLaughlin
Great food. The new owners have done a wonderful job updating the interior and making it very welcoming and comfortable for dine in. Pizza is still the best around and other dishes are definitely worth trying too! Desserts and gelatos are amazing as well. An excellent little place that really delivers every time
… moreEvan Keaton
This was the first time me or any of my friends had pizza from Troni Brothers. I’ve picked up orders for Doordash multiple times here, and just really wanted to try it. So I ordered two 16″ pizzas for carry-out for me, my girlfriend and my 3 friends to review. Service was good, nothing wrong there. The pizza though…nothing to brag about. We all had different opinions, but none of us were really blown away or even really like it that much. My GF only ate one slice, and honestly didn’t care for it. My friends and I all agreed it was a give or take 3/5. I didn’t take any pictures, but I thought the crust was too thin…and was kind of bland, not much flavor and a little on the dry side. The cheese was lacking, and so where the ingredients on the deluxe I ordered. I personally enjoy a pizza sauce that’s more on the “sweeter side” which I’d say Troni’s is not sweet at all, very much the opposite. Also for the $45 I paid for it, I just think that was a lot of money for such a lacking pizza. It was Not very “Bold” meaning…it wasn’t very filling. My girlfriend only ate 1 slice and between 4 men…we ate both 16″ pizzas fairy too easily. My final thoughts: Troni’s Pizza is not a bad pizza…just not my kind of pizza. I’ve tried a lot of different pizza places around Dayton, and I think you could easily pick 10 different places that are much better for the price. If I’m gonna spend $45 for 2 large “16 pizzas…they better be 5/5! I can’t say anything about the pasta, it looks really good! I just haven’t tried it yet…but as far as the pizza, I’ll pass.
… moreLiz
Troni Brothers Pizza. 16″ Nona pizza, (traditionally known as Gramma’s Pizza, for those who like that style of pizza), pepper jack cubes, and trio pasta, (manicotti, stuffed shells, ravioli, side salad, and garlic rolls).
Holy yum!!
Everything was so freaking good! My only small criticism, is that I should have gone with the 12-in pizza instead of the 16-in. The 16-in was just a little too big, and not quite done in the center. But other than that, everything was absolutely amazing! ☺️
… more