Holly Smith
Should be Zero stars. Worst pizza and service ever. They must cater to the locals. We should have walked out. Only group (4) in the restaurant at 5 on a Friday. Lot’s of locals wandered in to pick up take out who obviously called ahead. 60 minutes of waiting and the waitress throws a plate with 4 slices of cold burnt toast on the table, apparently it is garlic bread? No offer of how much longer or drink refills or do you need anything else? 90 minutes of waiting and we ask how much longer for our pizzas and “oh, just a few minutes”. We ordered 4 different mini pizzas and left hungry and disappointed. Canned mushrooms, no flavor or seasoning, hard as a rock crust that couldn’t be cut or eaten. No apologies for the wait not a single thanks for coming.
I think they were unloading the delivery truck instead of cooking our food.
We were there from start to finish for 2 hours. When we left, the place was packed with local families, so they must take care of them?
Never been to Buhl, should have driven in to town to find something else.
… moreDenna M
It took my family a while but we finally found delicious pizza in the Magic Valley. The quality is great. From a regular sourdough pep to a skillet pizza you can’t go wrong. The staff was friendly and everything taste like it’s made from scratch including the salad dressings.
… moreBrian Bucklew
A very nice old style pizza place, old pictures from when it was made. They serve beer and I may have spilled one! Sorry! But the cast iron pizza aka the skillet pizza is what we ordered and it was the best pizza pie I have ever eaten in my life. I just had Marco’s pizza like 2 weeks before and I swore that was the best! If you are in town or nearby you MUST stop by and eat! You will agree with me.
… moreSamantha
I wish I could give 10 stars! As someone who doesn’t like pizza that much, this is the most phenomenal stuff I’ve had in awhile. The menu is pretty large, you can customize a pizza for yourself that comes in 5 sizes, the service is UH-MAZING!! I will absolutely bring my friends here, it’s family friendly and they also offer beers and wine. They also have a dessert menu, which is TOTALLY WORTH IT. It’s not too pricey, either! You can get a small, 10 inch pizza for around $7. Good food, good place, I’m fat and happy!
… moreS Really
We were in here by ourselves . But it was super comforting. Staff is great friendly and polite. Pizza was great very cheesy and tasty . Chicken parm was outstanding. And blt was to die for . Thank u so much
… moreChar Herd-Shallenberger
Friendly service and delicious pizza! We had the traditional white crust Caboose and Canadian Railway. Both were delicious! We are going to go back to try their sourdough crust! Besides my husband’s homemade pizza, this is the best pizza I’ve had in the Magic Valley in a long time.
… moreJackie G
I had a Canadian Bacon and pineapple calzone in a sourdough crust which is my new favorite thing! I will definitely be coming back and would happily recommend to anyone. Excellent, friendly service, 80s tunes playing in the background overall an excellent experience.
… moreTim Clark
Selected for their gluten-free pizza and I wasn’t disappointed. Food portions were great and the atmosphere was laid back. I was impressed that they honored veterans and those who served. Highly recommend.
… moreMichael Leazer
Very good pizza and great employees, make it a point to stop here whenever I am passing through.
… moreBeth Steen
Food was great. Atmospherr was nostalgic. Server was rude. Two separate groups walked out because he took forever to greet them. We had almost walked out as well waiting to be greeted. Even though there was only one other table when we arrived. He also acted like any questions we had were and inconvenience. Plus acted upset when asked for a side of jalapeños.
… more