Address and Contact Information
Address: 1431 NY-208, Wallkill, NY 12589
Phone: (845) 895-3122
Website: https://www.toscospizzeriamenu.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Tosco’s Pizzeria – Wallkill, NY – 1431 NY-208 – Hours, Menu, Order
Get 5% off your pizza delivery order – View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Tosco’s Pizzeria in Wallkill, NY. Order online for delivery or pickup …
Tosco’s Pizzeria
Best Pizza in town with 6 locations to serve you in Rosendale, Monroe, New Windsor, Wallkill, Pine Bush and Saugerties for pickup, delivery and dine-in.
Wallkill – Tosco’s Pizzeria Restaurant | Best Pizza in Saugerties
Tosco’s Pizza offers 6 convenient locations in the Hudson Valley: New … Tosco’s Wallkill. 1431 Route 208,. Wallkill, NY 12589. (845) 895-3123. Mon …
Reviews
Tom Tango
Great place – I live very close, so I am in there quite often. Great staff, food is great and I’ve never been disappointed. But….I think it’s time to pay some attention to the store. It could be cleaner, maybe some new ceiling tiles, wall coverings, etc. Some attention to detail cleaning, appearance. I will still go there, I just wish it reflected better on the Hamlet and on itself.
… moreJ Frank (JF1973)
Tosco’s Pizzeria in Wallkill is a local favorite that delivers consistently satisfying Italian-American fare with a casual, welcoming vibe. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or sitting down for a full meal, the menu offers something for everyone—from classic thin-crust pizzas to hearty subs, wraps, wings, and pasta dishes.
The pizza is the star here: crisp, flavorful crusts with just the right amount of cheese and sauce. Specialty pies like the Buffalo Chicken and Shrimp Fra Diavolo add a creative twist to traditional offerings. Their Crazy Chicken pizza and jumbo garlic knots are also crowd-pleasers, perfect for sharing or indulging solo 1.
Service is generally friendly and attentive, with staff members like Kenny earning praise for going above and beyond 1. While the restaurant is small, it’s kid-friendly and offers plenty of parking, making it a convenient stop for families and locals alike.
However, Tosco’s isn’t without its quirks. Prices are a bit on the higher side for a pizzeria, and wait times—especially for salads or phone orders—can stretch longer than expected. Still, the quality of the food and the variety on the menu make it worth the occasional delay.
If you’re in the Wallkill area and craving pizza with personality, Tosco’s Pizzeria is a solid choice. Just be prepared to pay a little more—and maybe call ahead to avoid the wait.
… moreThe pizza is the star here: crisp, flavorful crusts with just the right amount of cheese and sauce. Specialty pies like the Buffalo Chicken and Shrimp Fra Diavolo add a creative twist to traditional offerings. Their Crazy Chicken pizza and jumbo garlic knots are also crowd-pleasers, perfect for sharing or indulging solo 1.
Service is generally friendly and attentive, with staff members like Kenny earning praise for going above and beyond 1. While the restaurant is small, it’s kid-friendly and offers plenty of parking, making it a convenient stop for families and locals alike.
However, Tosco’s isn’t without its quirks. Prices are a bit on the higher side for a pizzeria, and wait times—especially for salads or phone orders—can stretch longer than expected. Still, the quality of the food and the variety on the menu make it worth the occasional delay.
If you’re in the Wallkill area and craving pizza with personality, Tosco’s Pizzeria is a solid choice. Just be prepared to pay a little more—and maybe call ahead to avoid the wait.
Evan Nati
Awesome food, great prices, great service…
Everything I have ordered, the portions have been very generous and filling and the quality has been delicious.
Slices of pizza are literally huge compared to some competitors, $3 for plain.
Their stromboli is awesome… the small is huge for $10 and can nearly feed 2 people.
Their sauce is good too.
I really like the salads as well.
I also have gotten the Rosendale sub which I really enjoyed. Chicken, avocado, beans, and chipotle dressing.
Thank you Kenny, Lauren, and the kitchen staff… keep up the good work!
… moreEverything I have ordered, the portions have been very generous and filling and the quality has been delicious.
Slices of pizza are literally huge compared to some competitors, $3 for plain.
Their stromboli is awesome… the small is huge for $10 and can nearly feed 2 people.
Their sauce is good too.
I really like the salads as well.
I also have gotten the Rosendale sub which I really enjoyed. Chicken, avocado, beans, and chipotle dressing.
Thank you Kenny, Lauren, and the kitchen staff… keep up the good work!
jonsay241
Wow! This place was busy busy! But I know why. So nuch to choose from and everything is delicious. The cold sub was mouth watering. The bread melt in your mouth. The pizzas are awesome too. Even had gluten free for my daughter. If I lived closer I would ve here all the time. Service was friendly and fast too.
… moreJulie Pawson
Always good. I recommend the cheesesteak with Lettuce tomato and mayo. My kids love the crazy chicken pizza and the pepperoni pizza. I’ve never had a bad meal here, and the friendly customer service is great.
… moreKyle L
The dining experience was unsatisfactory, leading to foodborne illness. Additionally, the staff exhibited unprofessional conduct and a disregard for customer well-being. Consequently, I will not be returning to this establishment.
… moreKatie “katiek424” K
Not usually one to complain but we order a couple times a month. Usually pizza sometimes wraps. The slice life/Google food/website ordering is horrendous. I loved the honey mustard chicken wrap. It’s my go to. The last two times I ordered it, it’s been nothing but cut up chicken cutlets tossed in honey mustard and wrapped up. No lettuce, tomato, and cheese. I dont have options on the website ordering platforms to add these when they used to be standard for this sandwhich. Calling can take forever and it’s so much easier to just use the website. This isn’t the wrap I’ve wanted and it just stinks that its happened twice in a row. Please fix this.
… moreWayne Wright
I’ve been getting pizza here every year when I come to visit for the last 5 years. This time is was shit. Tasted like Walmart box pizza..
… moreBrittany Barry
Got the deal for the large pizza penne ala vodka a salad and garlic bread…… Apparently this is not a family deal! One small single salad and a couple slices of garlic bread is ridiculous I can go up the street to Pasquale’s and for a couple dollars more get whole tray of pasta and a big salad and a loaf of bread. They really need to clearly label there deals if its for a single person say so. Food wasnt bad but pizza crust was badly burnt
… moreColie Arrr
This is usually our go to spot but tonight my friend ordered and not only did the delivery take well over an hour but the food was ice cold, the pizza was beyond overcooked so now it was like burnt cardboard, and both heroes were so soggy on the bottom everything fell right through once you picked the sandwich up. Very disappointed, ended up throwing more than half of it out.
Edited: so since my last post this is still our go to spot, my hope was that it was just a bad, off night and it was. We have ordered many, many times since then and the food is always absolutely delicious and on point. The staff is always very friendly as well. I would recommend giving them a shot, even my dad couldn’t stop talking about how amazing his Wallkill special hero tasted last night. We tried the bruschetta pizza as well and it was amazeballs, as always, my kids loved the plain and the garlic knots.
… moreEdited: so since my last post this is still our go to spot, my hope was that it was just a bad, off night and it was. We have ordered many, many times since then and the food is always absolutely delicious and on point. The staff is always very friendly as well. I would recommend giving them a shot, even my dad couldn’t stop talking about how amazing his Wallkill special hero tasted last night. We tried the bruschetta pizza as well and it was amazeballs, as always, my kids loved the plain and the garlic knots.