Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Pizzeria chain making pies with unusual toppings (wings too), offered at counter or via delivery.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 325 W Center St, Whitewater, WI 53190
Phone: (262) 473-4343
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Whitewater WI Restaurant – Toppers Pizza
Welcome to your local Toppers Pizza! We believe better doesn’t have to cost more. Our dough is made from scratch every day. We use 100% real Wisconsin …
Toppers Pizza: Crave-Worthy Pizza Delivery & Carry-out
Delivery or carry out, late night or right now – Toppers Pizza has you covered. Try our famous Topperstix cheesy bread or one of our specialty pizzas now.
Toppers Pizza | Whitewater WI – Facebook
Bracket Season just got tastier! Get 50% OFF ALL Pizza & ‘Stix Thurs–Sun | March 19–April 5 https://www.toppers.com/deals/.
Last Updates
Reviews
Oblivion
I’ve had an amazing experience with Toppers during the two years I’ve been at Whitewater, great deals, great pizza, and super kind staff. I always get carryout because the deals are amazing, but this time when I placed my order and got to my car, it wouldn’t start. I called them, and they delivered the pizza with no extra charge. I made sure to tip the driver well.
11/10!
… more11/10!
Michelle Berry
We just had an unfortunate pizza ordering situation, and the manager was super accommodating. We will be back. We really enjoy the food from this location. Thank you sir!
… moreSavage PZZA
Fast piping hot out of the oven pizza! Obviously many “Toppers” to choose from that makes this a fun college and family spot to enjoy a couple of ZA’s and soda if you choose. Great service and clean tables, floors and bathroom.
… moreFerretti Farmer
As a 2002 UWW grad I’ve been coming to Whitewater Toppers since the original location on Rt. 12. I have a special liking for the Triple Order of Oringinal Toppers Stixs. Pretty much what I order every time. Especially with nacho sause. My only critique is that the nacho sauce seems to have changed a bit in recent years. I liked the old version better.
It should be noted that the pizza and many other choices for snacks/dinner are also awesome. Go Toppers!
… moreIt should be noted that the pizza and many other choices for snacks/dinner are also awesome. Go Toppers!
Samantha La Breche
Ordered a pizza through Doordash, my pizza was missing half of its toppings and the crust seemed undercooked though it had clearly been through the oven and was warm. My mac n cheese was fine. I’ll probably stick with ordering Domino’s in the future.
… moreSnagalishus Man
Note: This review is only for the chocolate baconstix, all my other toppers experiences have been very good. All the pictures showed a light chocolate drizzle that seemed like it might be good. What I got was topperstixs drowned in chocolate. All I could taste was the chocolate and the bread, not good. Complained to the site a week ago and they still haven’t responded. Poor customer service.
… moreKyle S
Customer service and delivery was timely and excellent. They keep changing the nacho cheese.
Edit: They have been late on getting me my order more times than not. My last triple order of topper stix looked like a double order…
The only thing that has been good is the taste of their topperstix.
8.10.21: Been here a handful of times since. Service is awful. You never get your order on time. The headquarters are right next door. You think they’d take some pride in their work. I don’t ever expect things to go correctly when I order.
… moreEdit: They have been late on getting me my order more times than not. My last triple order of topper stix looked like a double order…
The only thing that has been good is the taste of their topperstix.
8.10.21: Been here a handful of times since. Service is awful. You never get your order on time. The headquarters are right next door. You think they’d take some pride in their work. I don’t ever expect things to go correctly when I order.
Eleanor Zutz
I had to update my review from 2 years ago because, tonight, I just had my life changed. I ordered from the store in Whitewater and my life has forever been altered. My perception of what good pizza is is changed. I’m crying. Tears streaming down my cheeks at the glory of what I recieved; a slice of heaven served in a cardboard box. To the young men and women, working their hardest to kill it on every level of the customer’s experience, you’ve done it. I’ve reached nirvana. From the amazing woman who took my order to the extraordinary man who took my money, thank you. All of you. I will never again let my eyes or tongue commit adultery with any other company. I am fully committed to Toppers for the rest of my life. Not a piece of cheese out of place, the pieces cut so evenly. This is truly the epitome of perfection.
… moreAnne indermuehle
Pizza is Usually always pretty good from here. A bit pricey without a deal. Deals usually aren’t that great. Definitely disheartening to see the fake dyes and artificial crap in their nacho cheese dipping sauce. Especially when their headquarters is in Wisconsin!
Makes one wonder how much other artificial Ingredients in their food!
… moreMakes one wonder how much other artificial Ingredients in their food!
Rev J
Great people. The specialty pizzas, especially the one with tots and chives, was excellent. The mundane pizzas are more so-so. The Garlic Cheese bread is absolutely amazing. The people are super friendly. My only complaint is that it’s pretty expensive for pizza, but if you find the stuff you like there, it’s worth it.
… more