Linda M
Fast and friendly service. Nice variety of Pizza choices. Their pizza is medium thickness and loaded with cheese! The Buffalo Chicken Pizza has a nice bite but not overly spicy. Definitely one of the best pizzarias in New Hartford.
… moreBlue Feather 803
I was craving garlic pizza & got a small size with onions for pick up. It was superb!! It was thick,crunchy, and loaded with cheese!! It definitely hit the spot. And happy to have it for several meals!!
Also, grab a huge chocolate chip cookie to which was delicious too!!
… morePatty Bosshammer
Stopped in here with a hungry crowd of 48 people. It was a planned buffet and it was absolutely amazing!! Spot on in every aspect. Baked Ziti had excellent flavor, toss salad not only was presented beautiful , but tasted so fresh . Chicken tenders were a very good quality and cooked to perfection. The owner was extremely attentive and so professional. I was so impressed with the food, the service, and the clean up . I have never seen a food service establishment run so smooth and professional. People if you are looking for top notch service for a hungry crowd this is the place. Thank you to Tony’s Pizza.
… moreJessica Faith
Pizza is fantastic. I came here today however, for the pistachio canoli ! Good food, friendly staff, decent prices, highly recommend.
… moreTravis Eaton
Easy ordering and pizza and wings were ready when we arrived. Staff was super polite and quick to help customers as they walked in with a positive attitude and smile on there face. Food was delicious and family loved it.
… moreChristopher Graham
Got two plain slices. Already made in display case. Thicker type dough, no real taste to it. Sauce average at best, that’s being nice. Overall I say drive past try another place. Floppy crust, no true taste to it. 4.3 rating
… moreTom & Denise Carella
I was staying at a hotel and ordered a small pizza, was delivered 50 minutes later, I paid the delivery guy and when I opened my pizza box I got a large pizza NOT a small, I am in a hotel room, not at home, don’t have the option of leftovers the next day, I called back to let them know the mistake, but they would not do anything since I accepted the order and paid for it. Now, I am throwing out 2/3rds pizza for their mistake. Pizza was great but would not order again if I am in a hotel room and have to pay for their mistake and throw away food
… moreJoe L
This is the best out of the Tony’s Pizzas. Consistent food and service. Downgraded to 2 stars the pizza was over sauced which is a common mistake at all Tony’s pizzas. The cheese slides of and it becomes a sloppy mess.
… moreJimmy Dean
Subs are inconsistent, one day subs are great next day they’re terrible. Pizzas not great either, calzones are awesome tho. Some of the counter help are more worried about there phones than helping the customers.
Edit: Calzones aren’t great anymore … last 3 calzones I got not good, way under cooked, I even asked for extra crispy and still it was under cook. Man the last thing that I really enjoyed from this place gone to crap
… morePhilip Ogopogo
The staff was knowledgable and wicked friendly. Pizzeria was super clean and well lit. Pizza was amazing! Hot and fresh even after my 10 minute drive home.
… more