Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
A no-frills neighborhood pizzeria serving pies, calzones, subs & pastas since 1954.
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Best Pizza in Newark, NJ | Tony’s Pizzeria | Pizza near me
Tony’s Pizzeria: the best Pizza in Newark, NJ. Order directly online today for takeout or delivery. Save money, support local business!
Tony’s Pizzeria Online Menu | Best Pizza in Newark
… Beverages. Tony’s Pizzeria Menu. 59 Pacific St, Newark, NJ. 59 Pacific St, Newark, NJ. ·. Open now. Pickup. Pickup. Delivery. Delivery. Pickup time. ASAP (15 …
Tony’s Pizza – View Menu & Order Online – 59 Pacific St, Newark, NJ …
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Newark, NJ! Tony’s Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy your …
Reviews
John West
Great on getting Pizza delivered! Pizza was real good! Only thing was left off was the extra sauce I requested on the side. Crust good and toppings good as well. Caesar Salad was big and good as well. Delivery, Ordering all very easy!
… moreAmber
After reading so many positive reviews, I wanted to love this place, but it fell short on some areas. First, aesthetically speaking, the pizza LOOKED amazing. The bread rolls also did, at first glance! This is where the problems come in..some of the bread rolls were literally burnt. As in, completely inedible. They gave you a nice tomato sauce which was good, and tasted fresh and handmade. But that couldn’t assist with the fact that some of the bread rolls were burnt. The pizza was good in terms of taste, it had a yummy tomato sauce and an amazing amount of toppings, but..the crust. Maybe it’s a personal preference but the crust and bottom of the pizza were like rubber. I felt like my teeth were going to break with every bite, it was SO tough and utterly tasteless. You had to RIP the pizza apart to be able to chew. I would love to give this place another chance based on the reviews, but not anytime soon.
… moreAdrienne Mc.
I ordered a medium pizza extra cheese half pepperoni other half Italian sausage. It tastes like a salt sandwich. I had to take off all the pepperoni and take a napkin wipe off the remaining salt on that side. Buyer beware.
Too Salty.
… moreToo Salty.
Alan Hilliard
We decided to try a new pizza joint tonight and ordered from Tony’s for the first time. (We are always down to find out next “our place”)
From the moment the driver handed me the box, I knew this was a different kinda place. Beautiful Sicilian-style pizza (buffalo chicken with extra chicken and sauce) awaited us on the run back to the apt to open this beast. Absolutely the best tasting and balanced buffalo chicken pizza I have ever had!!!
… moreFrom the moment the driver handed me the box, I knew this was a different kinda place. Beautiful Sicilian-style pizza (buffalo chicken with extra chicken and sauce) awaited us on the run back to the apt to open this beast. Absolutely the best tasting and balanced buffalo chicken pizza I have ever had!!!
Precious
So this pizza spot is near my place so I’ve been a few times over the past few years. It’s a decent pizza spot, not the best but not the worse. I’m giving it a low rating because it has gone downhill from about less than average to just bad in regards to the attention to detail/service. I came today to get a slice of pepperoni. In the only one there apart from the workers and the woman who took my order still didn’t do it right. She left the pizza in the oven for two minutes. I am reheating the pizza at home because she didn’t want to take the time to leave my pizza in the oven for an extra 3-5 minutes. She looked new. They need to train their staff. I don’t even think the worker wore gloves and she was going in between ringing up the order and putting pizza in the oven. I won’t be back and I’ll probably make a complaint to the health department.
… moreAlex D
You can look at my review history and see that I never leave negative reviews, truly never. But the customer service (or lack thereof) here is deserving of it. Never received the food, after waiting two hours finally called only to be told that it was “next”, didn’t ask my name or my order so I assume she knew that based on my phone number? Then when I asked if the food was going to be cold being that it has been driving around for an hour, l she said “I don’t know”, and hung up. Was really looking forward to trying the food, but I should’ve read the reviews first.
… moreRyan OCallaghan
Delivery was made by a driver of the store. He must have dropped it en route and failed to tell me. I called the store and the girl on the line was useless and said she’d let the owner know and that they wouldn’t replace it.
… moreAlexandra Suszko
The food and pizza is really very good here. I usually get take out but on occasion will pick up. The outside of the building is older which can be misleading but the interior has a modern/updated look and is very clean inside. There are other pizza places in the neighborhood but I’ve been disappointed by them. Tony’s has the most authentic pizza in the area.
… moreRueben Scott
THINK TWICE- We live in the neighborhood and get there pizza all the time – my wife loves it. Today I decide to treat my self to a steak & cheese and was HIGHLY DISAPPOINTED! Literally the SKIMPIEST hoagie ever!!! Way more bread than meat and way more in cheese mushrooms peppers and onions than steak. To top it all off the filling didn’t even reach both ends of the bread and it was flat and not bulging open like one would expect when getting a steak and cheese. Fair to say I had plenty of toasted bread left over. They should take it off the menu. $15 for a hoagie is cool when you get what you pay for but here I seriously got gypted. NEVER AGAIN!!! Save your self the disappointment unless you like skinny sandwiches and love bread.
… moreCody Smith
Ordered delivery to the comfort inn hotel and it was seamless from an order on the phone to delivery. The pizza turned out really good. The garlic knots were good too, just a bit greasy. Would eat here again
… more