Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Tony’s Pizzalicious, you can find a variety of cuisine such as Veggie Salad, Steamed Shrimp Salad, Greek Gyro Salad, Oven-Baked Spaghetti, and Fried Chicken Breast Sandwich. We are conveniently located on Knox Abbott Drive. Order online for carryout or delivery!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 975 Knox Abbott Dr, Cayce, SC 29033
Phone: (803) 794-5469
Website: http://tonyspizzalicioussc.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: spotapps.co
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tony’s Pizzalicious – Cayce, SC
At Tony’s Pizzalicious, you can find a variety of cuisine such as Veggie Salad, Steamed Shrimp Salad, Greek Gyro Salad, Oven-Baked Spaghetti, …
Tony’s Pizzalicious | Cayce SC – Facebook
Tony’s Pizzalicious. Since 1967, we’ve been proud to serve some of the most delicious and heartwarming Italian food in town. Pizza place · $$.
Order Tony’s Pizzalicious – Cayce, SC Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Tony’s Pizzalicious at 975 Knox Abbott Dr in Cayce. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Reviews
Quintin McFadden
I love this place. The food is yummy and worth the money. The owner and his family were so nice to me and I will definitely come back. Everything was homemade.
… moreWill Marshall
I ordered two pizzas recently — the Greek Gyro Pizza and the Meat Lovers — and both were absolutely incredible! The Greek Gyro Pizza truly captured the essence of a traditional gyro, with all those bold, authentic flavors perfectly reimagined on a pizza. It’s not easy to pull off something so unique, but they nailed it. The Meat Lovers was just as impressive, packed with hearty toppings and cooked to perfection.
What really makes this place stand out is that it’s family-owned, built on tradition, and you can tell they genuinely care about the customers. On top of that, I had a great 20-minute conversation with the owner about how the restaurant began, his family’s history of running other spots in town, and even swapped stories of back home and unique pizza creations we’ve seen at the shore boardwalk. You can feel the tradition, passion, and genuine care here. Hands down, this place blow all other pizza places out of the water. I can’t recommend them enough! I have now decided to make myself a regular because even after just my first visit, I feel like family! ♥️♥️
… moreWhat really makes this place stand out is that it’s family-owned, built on tradition, and you can tell they genuinely care about the customers. On top of that, I had a great 20-minute conversation with the owner about how the restaurant began, his family’s history of running other spots in town, and even swapped stories of back home and unique pizza creations we’ve seen at the shore boardwalk. You can feel the tradition, passion, and genuine care here. Hands down, this place blow all other pizza places out of the water. I can’t recommend them enough! I have now decided to make myself a regular because even after just my first visit, I feel like family! ♥️♥️
Harold Brown
Their house special Stromboli was absolutely awesome. It was so big I had to take half of it home with me. My daughter had the shrimp fettuccine alfredo and she said it was an 11 on a 1 to 10 scale. Our waitress was very nice and quick to bring drink refills. Overall a great little place to eat. The only reason I gave it a four-star for atmosphere is the interior is a little dark and outdated.
… moreKimberly S
Edit: Yikes! Just reading the snarky responses from this restaurant’s management on customer reviews tells me everything I need to know about this establishment. I will never return. That’s wildly unprofessional and just all around odd behavior.
—
I tried this place based off the reviews and was really disappointed. When I arrived at the restaurant, the initial young lady with whom I was speaking was pleasant, but there’s an older gentleman there (I assume the owner) who’s just downright rude for no reason. I don’t care as much about service, if the food is good so I proceeded to get take out.
When I got my order, it smelt great and was piping hot. But the flavor just wasn’t there for me. I ordered pizza & stromboli & hated the sauce on both. The sauce was bland but had an odd aftertaste. Both of my items were greasy and soggy on the bottom. The stromboli had very little cheese and too much sauce. My BF and I tried to salvage it the best we could. We ended up placing both items on paper towels for a while to soak up the oil, I seasoned them and reheated in my oven. That made them more palatable, but we ended up tossing much of it in the trash.
Perhaps, I got them on a bad day. Still debating on whether I’ll ever return. If I do, I’ll update my review accordingly.
… more—
I tried this place based off the reviews and was really disappointed. When I arrived at the restaurant, the initial young lady with whom I was speaking was pleasant, but there’s an older gentleman there (I assume the owner) who’s just downright rude for no reason. I don’t care as much about service, if the food is good so I proceeded to get take out.
When I got my order, it smelt great and was piping hot. But the flavor just wasn’t there for me. I ordered pizza & stromboli & hated the sauce on both. The sauce was bland but had an odd aftertaste. Both of my items were greasy and soggy on the bottom. The stromboli had very little cheese and too much sauce. My BF and I tried to salvage it the best we could. We ended up placing both items on paper towels for a while to soak up the oil, I seasoned them and reheated in my oven. That made them more palatable, but we ended up tossing much of it in the trash.
Perhaps, I got them on a bad day. Still debating on whether I’ll ever return. If I do, I’ll update my review accordingly.
Raven Blair
Food: we ordered the Dimi’s Deluxe & a pepperoni and bacon pizza, spinach artichoke dip, and a side of garlic bread. The dough on the pizza was light and fluffy, delicious and filling. The spinach artichoke dip was really good, and it’s served with hot pita bread! Packing the leftovers got a little messy, as there were so many topping on the Dimi’s Deluxe pizza everything started falling off! A small price to pay for the value of the food we ate!
Price: you can easily get away with $10-20 per person, with our appetizer, extra side, & drinks, it was closer to $25 per person ($30 if you include the tip). Pricing was similar to other dine in restaurants, and you get a lot more food to bring home!
Service: the waitress also worked in the kitchen, so service wasn’t the fastest (but also wasn’t slow) while dining in, but she was so polite and patient as we looked over all of the choices and answered all of our questions. As we paid to leave, we had a nice conversation with the manager/owner? I’m not sure of his title, but he mentioned hearing good things about eating the leftover pizza for breakfast due to his sauce recipe. We tried it this morning & he was absolutely correct; the pizza was just as good the next day!
Atmosphere: good music & kind people. There weren’t many other people in the dining room with us, but everyone seemed kind and respectful. You can see into the kitchen area & see them making your food which was cool. It felt like a homey mom & pop pizza shop.
I look forward to trying more of their menu in the future!
… morePrice: you can easily get away with $10-20 per person, with our appetizer, extra side, & drinks, it was closer to $25 per person ($30 if you include the tip). Pricing was similar to other dine in restaurants, and you get a lot more food to bring home!
Service: the waitress also worked in the kitchen, so service wasn’t the fastest (but also wasn’t slow) while dining in, but she was so polite and patient as we looked over all of the choices and answered all of our questions. As we paid to leave, we had a nice conversation with the manager/owner? I’m not sure of his title, but he mentioned hearing good things about eating the leftover pizza for breakfast due to his sauce recipe. We tried it this morning & he was absolutely correct; the pizza was just as good the next day!
Atmosphere: good music & kind people. There weren’t many other people in the dining room with us, but everyone seemed kind and respectful. You can see into the kitchen area & see them making your food which was cool. It felt like a homey mom & pop pizza shop.
I look forward to trying more of their menu in the future!
Andie James
Traveling back home to Indiana after staying in South Carolina for a week and ran across this gem. Great service, food was out in a good time, and the taste…amazing. We are picky when it comes to meatball subs & fettuccine. Meatballs and sauce taste homemade. Large portions on everything & the price was good. Thank you for a great experience. (had 2 pizzas as well)
… moreThomas Young
Ordered a pizza and had it delivered. It was supposed to have pepperoni, sausage, and bacon removed from half of it. After it was delivered, found that there was no meat on the pizza whatsoever. Called and told them what we had found and we were informed that the owner was 67 years old and has trouble reading the tickets sometimes. Then we’re told that if we return 75% of the pizza to the store that they’ll make it right (keep in mind this was delivery). So I returned the pizza to the store (minus 1 piece) and she said they’d remake the pizza. Then I sat on the bench in front of the counter and listened to passive aggressive arguments between the sorry ash owner and his staff while they remade the pizza that they didn’t make correctly the first time. Order it for yourself and form your own opinion, this is just a review of my experience. Pizza was mid and owner is far past his prime. Was still sitting waiting on my pizza as I posted this.
… moreBrittany Williams
For starters, the stars are only for the sweet little lady at the window…
I Ordered a barbecue chicken pizza…Key Word>>>BBQ<<<… Got home And bit into my pizza, There was no barbecue sauce to be found … I called them To ask, “it’s supposed to be barbecue sauce on my barbecue chicken pizza, right?” The man on the phone said “yes it it”.. I told him my pizza does not have barbecue sauce on it. It has red pizza sauce…. He then spoke to a couple of his workers asking them if they put barbecue sauce on the pizza or whatever… Then comes back to the phone and says “yes there’s barbecue sauce on your pizza. We put pizza sauce and then barbecue sauce and then all the toppings that you ordered.” …. And then told me on the menu it stated that it’s pizza sauce and barbecue sauce… When it’s clearly does not… (Proof Below) At that point, I was not about to argue with somebody who don’t even know what the menu says…. On top of all that my pizza is not done. It’s Doughy and Not edible… I just wasted $31. As a first time customer, I will never return… smh I’ll tell everybody to go to Domino’s first!
… moreI Ordered a barbecue chicken pizza…Key Word>>>BBQ<<<… Got home And bit into my pizza, There was no barbecue sauce to be found … I called them To ask, “it’s supposed to be barbecue sauce on my barbecue chicken pizza, right?” The man on the phone said “yes it it”.. I told him my pizza does not have barbecue sauce on it. It has red pizza sauce…. He then spoke to a couple of his workers asking them if they put barbecue sauce on the pizza or whatever… Then comes back to the phone and says “yes there’s barbecue sauce on your pizza. We put pizza sauce and then barbecue sauce and then all the toppings that you ordered.” …. And then told me on the menu it stated that it’s pizza sauce and barbecue sauce… When it’s clearly does not… (Proof Below) At that point, I was not about to argue with somebody who don’t even know what the menu says…. On top of all that my pizza is not done. It’s Doughy and Not edible… I just wasted $31. As a first time customer, I will never return… smh I’ll tell everybody to go to Domino’s first!
Brian Milhous
Steve the owner is a Great person and he has excellent ladies that work with him. Authentic delicious food and for the price the pizzas are unbeatable.
… moreBryan Jackson
We really enjoyed our visit here. The restaurant is quaint, clean, and welcoming. It has a nice vibe. The staff were all welcoming and very friendly, and our server was very attentive and fun to interact with. We got the meat specialty pizza, and it was also delicious. The pizza is Greek style, or at least that’s what I call it. A little bit thicker than New York style, not quite as crispy, or floppy. (If you like New York Pizza, you know what I mean.) They also serve Greek food, which we will hopefully get to try the next time we are here.
They also have a drive through.
… moreThey also have a drive through.