Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Informal strip-mall pizzeria serving up NY-style pies & slices, plus pasta, calzones & subs.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 6975 A1A S #2, St. Augustine, FL 32080
Phone: (904) 471-9027
Website: https://tonyspizzanow.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menu – Crescent Beach – Tony’s Pizza
… Beach area with the best pizza in St Augustine and the best quality in Florida … Sicilian Pizza, Tony’s Authentic New York Style Pizza, Crescent Beach FL …
Tony’s Pizza New York Style
Tony’s Pizza New York Style for 31+ Years has served the Crescent Beach Florida area. Tony’s Pizza has the best pizza in Saint Augustine and the best …
Tonys New York Style Pizza | Saint Augustine FL – Facebook
Come in and grab and XL – 1 topping and 10 wings for $24.99 before the JAGS game tonight.. Check in here and receive 10% off your purchase.
Reviews
Valerie J
We were recommended to Tony’s Pizza by two different friends, and now we know why! I ordered the Super supreme and my hubby had the white pizza. The ingredients were incredibly fresh, the pizza dough was absolutely delicious, and the toppings were generously piled on. IYou can really taste the quality in every bite. Our daughter had the spaghetti and meatballs with garlic bread. It was very tasty. On top of that, the hospitality was top notch—warm, welcoming, and attentive. We’re already looking forward to our next visit!
… moreSolutions2 Low-Voltage
This place is a classic for our family! We always order takeout on the first night of our stay. We like to GO EXTRA LARGE and EXTRA DISHES so we can have leftovers during the rest of our vacation. I tried the Boklava and they were delicious! They were fresh, made that day. The Greek Pizza is always great. The Extra Large goes the distance too. We have several slices to save for the rest of the week….The pizza is just as good cold, especially right after a hot day in the pool and beach. If you want something different than just the standard pizza then I suggest you get the GREEK PIZZA…Just make sure you like Feta, Black Olives, and Gyro Meat!!! I loved the STROMBOLI too !!! It was not overloaded with junk just great meat and cheese and not too much bread. The staff is very friendly. I order ahead of the rush time and I don’t get in a big hurry to go the 3 miles…It will be hot when I get there for pickup!
… moreMatthew Britten
14″ Meat lovers pizza was excellent. Good choice. Will be back for another meal before we head back to Nova Scotia at the end of February.
… moremike 9979
The pizza was phenomenal, made fresh from scratch & the customer service was exceptional. The owner of the establishment embodies humility and was always asking for feedback on his dishes to ensure that his food was on par with high standards.
… moreKatie Ross
We had the white pizza with spinach. This was the BEST Pizza we have ever had! The crust was perfectly crispy but not overdone. The ingredients were fresh, generous and perfectly placed. Im a crust girly and I cant express how perfectly done it was! Wish you were closer to home!!
… moreMike Beckett Sr
Great NY style pizza and we should know ( we’re from NY). Friendly staff. Limited, dated on site seating so best to take out. But excellent pizza. You won’t be disappointed!! We’ll be back!! Looking forward to trying the Calzones.
… moreJorge Argueta
So glad we stopped here! I ordered a cheesesteak and wow! The bread was so fresh and delicious! My friend got the Rider and loved it! Everyone was very hospitable as well. We will definitely stop in again!
… moreBC Spam
I just wanna say at first I was skeptical spending $20 for a small supreme pizza but let me tell you the nicest gentleman gave me my pizza and it was the best looking pizza I’ve had in a long time. The pizza was so good I had to eat it with a fork. I’m definitely Recommending this place to anybody that will listen.
… moreStephanie Lacey Dodd
Food was great going in but really messed my stomach up that night and heartburn all the next day. Could have been just me. The pizza had a lot of sauce and I normally do not like heavy sauce. Service was amazing and seating was okay.
… moreSelena
My family and I have been coming here for the past 20 years. Tony’s Pizza is a hidden gem If you want real, authentic Italian food this is the place to try! Tony makes the best Italian food ever! I hope this place will forever stay open. We live about 2 hours away, but when we come down to Crescent Beach we always stop to bring home enough food for the week! The Calzones and the White Pizza specifically are the BEST EVER! But anything from Tony’s is always delicious and I recommend anything he makes! I can’t recommend this place enough to anyone looking for Italian food! You won’t be disappointed at all! ✨
… more