James Butta
Stopped by here on a Sunday afternoon. Good atmosphere, wasn’t too busy which is surprising with my experience here. I sat inside and ordered a regular cheese and pepperoni pizza. Also got an order of mozzarella sticks.
The wait time wasn’t long at all and as you can see. The presentation of the food is great. No problem with customer service… the pizza is great. And the mozzarella sticks are as well. It’s definitely worth the visit.
… moreEric Kling
I’ve had pizza. Stromboli and subs here. Fabulous food. Great service. Home like atmosphere. Stop every time I come into town and I live 3 hours away. My wife always gets the crispy chicken salad and loves it. They really make you feel like family when you’re there!!!
… moreS Ha
First time visiting Tonys this weekend (Twice actually :)and was VERY happy with the food. The quality is amazing and I’ll def be returning. I treated company who is very particular with food quality, and even she said Tonys was a “Good Find with really good food. They have amazing employees also. So efficient an super friendly. They make you feel welcome Thank you 🙂
… moreElysia Monderewicz
Ate here for the first time since new management and everything was very good. Fresh ingredients, made well, good service, everything tasted good.
Edited** to add I ate here for a second time and got a cheese pizza and a supreme pizza, both were $40 and some change which I think was way too much for what it was. The cheese pizza was okay, but I was really disappointed with the supreme pizza, it had canned mushrooms, tons of onions, and pickled sweet peppers in addition to some of the meats, looked sloppy and was soggy. Odd combination of toppings for a supreme pizza, and expected fresh veggies.
… moreAshleigh Black
I am from out of town and whenever I come to Bowmansville, I always stop at Tony’s Pizza. They have the best options when it comes to true Italian food and I wouldn’t go anywhere else! I highly recommend everyone try Tony’s at least once, but trust me you’ll keep going back lol
… moreWayne Step
BUYER BEWARE! Do not buy their meatball sandwich! They do not give you full meatballs! They actually cut them in half so you end up with a big roll with hidden, hard to be found meat and half the meatballs!! Their pizza taste like cardboard! They cover all of their food in overly thick cheese so it hides the fact that you are getting less meatballs and other meat as well Terrible service! Do NOT recommend!
… moreNick Szewczyk
Great Italian food in the middle of Amish country. Friendly staff, big portions and fair prices. Delicious!
… moreDani Connor
Stopped in for the first time this evening. Service was fast and super friendly, and the food was absolutely amazing! The pizza was on point!
… moreSherry Marsh
A family member of mine went to pick up food from Tony’s tonight. The parking lot was not plowed and it was icy. As they were leaving, there was black ice in the parking and they slipped and fell. I am very disappointed that this happened.
… moreJK
Delicious, inexpensive pizza! You can’t go wrong. They also sell pizza by the slice!
… more