Nancy Ford Adcox
Great place to sit, relax, enjoy without feeling rushed. Juan and Hassan provide excellent and kind service. Even with kids running around (it’s very family friendly here) it was not disturbing to me as I worked on my computer. The price of the pizza was reasonable and the slice was BIG and delicious—I got the supreme. It was nice to find they had guest WiFi. I asked at the register and got the password. Soft drinks were refillable. Clean. I was here on a Wednesday night with plenty of booths so I didn’t worry about taking one for myself. I’ll definitely be back for more pizza, and will try the delicious-looking calzone or stromboli.
… moreJenna Higgs
I have been going to this restaurant since 2003 when we moved into the neighborhood nearby and have loved it since. It’s the best pizza I have ever had. I no longer live in the neighborhood but my husband and I make special trips to come have dinner here. No other pizza place lives up to Tony’s! So delicious!!!
… moreAriana Viveros
Delicious Food and great service!! The owner always greats you with a smile. Having the option to get a whole pizza or just a slice is perfect!!
… moreCaleb Whitby
Great NY style pizza. Best of the 4-5 spots in the area in my opinion.
… moreAaron Belcher
I’m far from a picky eater, and there are very few things I do not like. I have had so many different kinds of pizza before, all different types too. There is only one other pizza I have eaten that I have never wanted to eat again, and that pizza was Digiorno frozen pizza.
With that said, if I had a choice between Tony’s and Digiorno, I would take Digiorno without hesitation.
I hate to write this because I had high hopes for this place.
I was starving because I hadn’t had time to eat all day, and we finally got to eat at almost 9pm! I was beyond famished and really ready to eat when the food arrived.
I handed the kids their slices and then grabbed one for myself, bit into it and immediately set down the slice. I had taken ONE bite, I couldn’t eat any more. I just ate something else in the fridge.
I looked at the kids who were still happily eating theirs.
Confused, I asked them, “well boys, how do you like it?” They both smile with their mouths full of pizza and happily exclaim that it is really good! I kind of had a small grimace on my face and just quietly thought, kids will eat anything!
My take was, it was beyond not edible. It, to me, was absolutely gross! It’s 100% that sauce! I have never tasted a sauce for pizza I hated more. It was just a really bad tasting pizza. It was way beyond the price it should have cost! This isn’t even on par with gas station pizza. Brother’s Pizza is one of them, I think there’s one in Garner, and that pizza is far better than this place!
I’m not trying to deter you from eating here, I am just giving my honest experience. I ordered take out, and it will be the last time. Nothing could bring me back to this place, it was a one-time only.
This was my honest experience, maybe yours will be better, but I honestly am baffled that this place has such a high rating, I just had a regular cheese pizza, the hardest pizza there is to screw up!
… moreJohn Thomas Kong
We had lunch at Tony’s and absolutely loved it. The food is so very good and there was so much of it. The service was splendid and everyone was so polite. We look forward to coming back.
… moreAaron Richardson
Authentic NY style pizza by the slice. The crust is thinner than pan style but crispy and can hold up to becoming a handheld. I enjoyed the fresh taste and thought it tasted very authentic to the families recipe!
… moreMCA MCA (Roguebunny2013)
I’ve had pizza at some other places, but Tony’s is my favorite! My go to sub is the Italian Sub and go to pizzas are the Buffalo Chicken ans Meat Lovers pizza..never disappoints..lol. and other places pizza sauce mess my stomach up, but the recipe from here is perfect and the crust always has the right amount of crunch!
… morechris pieper
Have not been in a while. I forgot how good the pizza is. Just like the NY area. Can’t wait to try the manicotti……cheers!
… moreAleisha Byrd
I just visited this location look how my pizza looks on top of that I agree I made a mistake with my order I offered to pay extra to get this pizza fixed the way I wanted it manager told me I would have to pay full price for another pizza I also asked for a refund and was told I couldn’t get a refund under what policy you don’t offer refunds I spent 60 dollars with you guys in this is how you treat your paying customers you don’t offer to fix the problem
… more