VOTED IN TOP 3 PIZZA PLACES for 2025 We are a family owned, family run and a family oriented business with a very friendly atmosphere. Our Pizzas, Strombolis, calzones, wings, burgers, pastas and sandwiches are well appreciated by our esteemed clientele. If not the tastiest, we can claim that we have one of the richest & tastiest menus in the Mocksville, Bermuda run area. Dine in, pickup or call for delivery. we guarantee you that you will not regret ordering from us.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tony’s Newyorker Pizza 1678 Us Highway 64 E – Order Online
Tony’s Newyorker Pizza. 1678 Us Highway 64 E, Mocksville NC 27028-5464 … Tony’s New Yorker Pizza. Cheese Pizza (12″ Medium). Savor the rich, gooey …
Tony’s Newyorker Pizza – Mocksville – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Tony’s Newyorker Pizza at 1678 Us Highway 64 E in Mocksville. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your …
The NewYorker Pizza Mocksville – Facebook
The NewYorker Pizza Mocksville, Mocksville. 369 likes. Wings, Pizzas, Burgers, Subs, Hot subs, Philly stake Sandwiches, Stromboli, Calzone, Italian…
Reviews
Coral Starr
My daughter and I are staying at the Forest Lake Thousand Trails campground (in Advance, NC) and on December 5, 2024, we placed our order for delivery.
My daughter ordered a Stuffed Meat Lovers pizza and I ordered a cheese pizza. In addition, we ordered two spaghetti dishes with homemade marinara sauce so that we’d have something to eat the following day.
The pizzas were delicious. The stuffed pizza was filled with different kinds of meat, green peppers, and onions. My daughter said the pizza wasn’t too spicy and had lots of meat in it.
The spaghetti with marinara sauce was very delicious. We both enjoyed this dish very much. The marinara was a perfect blend of tomato sauce and spices. The spaghettis came with side salads and buttered bread.
If we are in this area again in the future, we are definitely going to order from them again. I highly recommend Tony’s New Yorker Pizza.
… moreMy daughter ordered a Stuffed Meat Lovers pizza and I ordered a cheese pizza. In addition, we ordered two spaghetti dishes with homemade marinara sauce so that we’d have something to eat the following day.
The pizzas were delicious. The stuffed pizza was filled with different kinds of meat, green peppers, and onions. My daughter said the pizza wasn’t too spicy and had lots of meat in it.
The spaghetti with marinara sauce was very delicious. We both enjoyed this dish very much. The marinara was a perfect blend of tomato sauce and spices. The spaghettis came with side salads and buttered bread.
If we are in this area again in the future, we are definitely going to order from them again. I highly recommend Tony’s New Yorker Pizza.
Benjamin Martin
The stuffed meat lovers pizza is the BEST slice of pizza I’ve ever had. I’ve had it probably 10 times, and it’s consistently perfect in every way. You get an enormous slice that I can barely finish every time and it’s only around 6 dollars a slice. Everyone needs to try this pizza if they care about quality, and bang for your buck. It’s always ready quickly and fresh but never disappoints. They offer much more than pizza as well.
… morePatrick Davis
Great food hidden in the back of the gas station. We had large pizza and wings special. Both were excellent.
… moreRichard Spillman
I had the same experience another person had, I called at 8:40 on a Wed night to place a $40 order of Strombolis. I was told the kitchen is closed. I called because I received a flyer in the mail that listed the hours as 10am-9pm. You can keep your flyers or follow the time on it. Y’all decide which
… moreAchieve Obedience
This place is the best “secret” in mocksville. As others have said it’s in a gas station so it doesn’t look like much but it’s hands down the best pizza and wings in the area. And do yourself a favor and get the fried ravioli and garlic knots. Holy smokes!!!! Amazing. Haven’t tried the pasta or subs yet since we always get pizza/wings/apps but it looks great too.
… moreIndia Cannon
I had a great experience at Tony’s Pizza Shop while ordering pizzas for healthcare workers over the phone. Tiffany, the manager, and the man at the front desk were incredibly kind, helpful, and respectful. They answered all my questions and helped me find the best price. I didn’t try the pizza myself, but the pizza staff seemed happy and respectful of one another. They made sure my order was clear before passing it to the cooks, which showed real care and teamwork. I believe positive energy can be tasted in food. Thank you Tony’s!
… moreFrancine “Specialk” Price
One of my neighbors ordered a pizza and said how good it was, so I ordered one also when we went to get food from this place it smelled Terrible. I must say there seems to be a new lady working there, and now the place is clean and smells very good.
… moreM Murphy
This place is a gas station, but they have the best Stromboli! They’re as big as your arm if you get a large. Great food in general. Delivery service – Free jug of tea if you spend $40 – fresh and handmade. Better than comparable food from traditional Italian restaurants.
… moreGary
This place is scary bad! Messed up order offered a replacement and clearly through on toppings to an old pizza they had laying around… they even admitted it. It was in a dirty box and It wasn’t even cut into slices… Offered a free one next time, there will NOT be a next time… I can’t afford to get food poisoning
… moreWendy Edwards
Giving 2 stars only because the pizza was good, service is HORRIBLE and very poor business practices. 1st over an hour to deliver food. I had to call to get them to “hurry” it up after waiting 45 mins. 2nd says no delivery fee under 6 miles, I live 4.9 miles away, I was charged $3. When asked why, was told because I live in an apartment! 3rd I was asked to give tip on card, I said no, I give cash. Receipt says tip of $3 so is it a delivery fee or the tip????? None of these charges were told to me before hand, only after I called for explanation. 4th apparently there is a processing fee for using my card, which was never told at all.
… more