Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 42 S Antrim Way, Greencastle, PA 17225
Phone: (717) 597-2152
Website: https://tonyspizzago.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tonys Pizza Greencastle PA
Authentic dough. Fresh ingredients. The finest hand-made pizzas. Made with love. (717) 597-2152. Let’s start ordering now. Order Online.
Tonys Pizza Online Ordering
… Greencastle, PA 17225. View Map. +1(717) 597-2152. Print Menu. About Us. Tony’s … Tony’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant specializes in Authentic Italian Cuisine …
Tony’s Pizza Greencastle – Facebook
We greatly appreciate it! Tonys Pizza Greencastle PA. TONYSPIZZAGO.COM … TikTok · Tony’s New York Pizza . Check out Tony’s New York Pizza ‘s …
Reviews
Jill Appleyard
My husband and I ordered dinner last night. A large Pizza.
The Pizza dough was chewy, the worst Pizza I have ever ate. We also ordered wings as well i asked for crispy wings which I did not get with buffalo sauce the wing sauce tasted terrible .
We ended up throwing the pizza and the wings in the trash. We will never order from Tony’s New York Pizza ever again.
… moreThe Pizza dough was chewy, the worst Pizza I have ever ate. We also ordered wings as well i asked for crispy wings which I did not get with buffalo sauce the wing sauce tasted terrible .
We ended up throwing the pizza and the wings in the trash. We will never order from Tony’s New York Pizza ever again.
Denise Cramer
This place has gone down hill ever since the new owners took over. Just ordered a Stromboli and a small cheese pizza. The pizza crust was over cooked to the point of being burnt. The sauce on the Stromboli has changed as well. We liked this place because it is the only restaurant that will deliver to my moms, but will not be eating there again.
… moreMichael Day
“Table for ten please.” Words that can ruin most places. But at Tony’s, the food came out quickly and everyone was pleased with their food. I had a cheesesteak with fries and a drink. The fries were crisp on the outside, soft on the inside. The bun was the highlight of the cheesesteak, as it should be. Drinks were unlimited, all for under $10. I’ve read the bad reviews, but consider this the other side of the coin.
… moreMommy Trio
The person who helped me over the phone had an excellent phone presence and was very helpful. When I picked up my order, she was pleasant, cheerful and communicated very well. I cannot remember her name, but would return again and again to receive this level of customer service.
… moreJosh Adams
Free and fast delivery. It’s NY-style, but a little greasy and thicker than normal. Still good though.
June 2022: I got their new margherita pizza with pepperoni. Over $18…pretty expensive. It was really good, much better than the regular pizza. I typically like light cheese, but this pizza could’ve used a little more mozzarella. Also a little too much garlic taste for me personally. I wish they had the cup pepperoni, that would go well. Lastly, take the toppings a bit closer to the edge (reduce the amount of crust). Overall probably an 8.3/10 but I have so many “suggestions” because of the price.
… moreJune 2022: I got their new margherita pizza with pepperoni. Over $18…pretty expensive. It was really good, much better than the regular pizza. I typically like light cheese, but this pizza could’ve used a little more mozzarella. Also a little too much garlic taste for me personally. I wish they had the cup pepperoni, that would go well. Lastly, take the toppings a bit closer to the edge (reduce the amount of crust). Overall probably an 8.3/10 but I have so many “suggestions” because of the price.
Isaiah Kershner
I have given this place multiple chances and I’ve never had anything good from here. My latest experience I ordered a Stromboli and the only thing in it was cheese and ham. Other places where I have gotten Stromboli it comes with atleast pepperoni also. Idk just not a great place and it’s expensive for average to below average food
… moreAmy Barnhart
A few months back me and my family stopped in at Tony’s Pizza for their sub special. We all ordered steak and cheese subs. My moms was a special cheesesteak with all the fixings. Our waitress was very friendly and had a smile on her face. There was only two Caucasian teenagers working in the place. The rest of them were her Hispanic. My mom received her sub. She took one bite of it and all of her onions and green peppers were gone. Our waitress asked her if she would like to get more for her sub mom said no it would be okay. However, the waitress assisted went and asked the cook for green peppers and onions. The cook asked the waitress who was it for. She pointed to my mom. He proceeded to look at her and then laugh. She brings over more peppers and onions. She puts it on her sub. Takes a bite of it. She had to spit it out because it made her mouth so hot that the cook was a smart-ass and gave her a jalapeno peppers instead of green. I asked the teenage boy to have the sandwich replaced and he agreed., the manager of the store argued with the teenage boy and proceeded to tell him that it will not be replaced. Then he proceeded to look at me and tried to give back my old sandwich in place of a new one. I proceed to tell him that was not the new sandwich that it was the old one that I brought up. He proceeded to tell me he was not going to refund my money back. Was not going to make me a new sandwich and if I did not leave he was going to call the police. because they have smart asses working in there and thought it was funny to give my mom. Who is 72 years old jalapeno peppers to eat. I used to work there back in the day (94) as a driver. Wonderful place. So was the people. However, after this new management it’s a terrible place. I would not recommend my dog or anyone else to eat there.
I also told the manager on my way out. who acted like the owner that Joe and the old management would not have treated their customers like this at all.
… moreI also told the manager on my way out. who acted like the owner that Joe and the old management would not have treated their customers like this at all.
Teresa Davis
I had a pleasant experience from beginning to end. Upon arrival, I was unsure about which dish I wanted to eat for dinner and one of the staff members provided me with assistance, suggestions and information about what each dish consisted of in order to make my decision easier. After receiving the eggplant roll dish I decided Upon, I was pleased with its presentation, taste, quality and quantity. I enjoyed what I could and am bringing the rest home for tomorrow.
Tony’s is definitely being added to my list of #1 places for Italian Dining. Everyone is urged to give it a try, I don’t you’ll be disappointed.
… moreTony’s is definitely being added to my list of #1 places for Italian Dining. Everyone is urged to give it a try, I don’t you’ll be disappointed.
Jessica Roelkey
Loved it pizza was great service was great and it’s BYOB no extra charge will be going back
… morePatti Sechrist
35.00 for this ! No salad no Bread . Cheeseburger sub Seriously! I meant to take a picture of fries, but someone ate the three of them before I could. And we are still waiting for the drinks. . All for supporting small business, never this one.
… more